The Importance Of Alcibiades

Improved Essays
On behalf of the great state of Athens, I accuse the deplorable Alcibiades of defacing the religiously significant herms throughout the city. To add to his heinous crime against the state, not only did he deface the herms, but he did so immediately before the departure for the Sicilian Expedition. Eye witnesses have stepped forward and shed light upon the traitorous act, claiming Alcibiades and his friends committed the crime. In addition to vandalizing the herms throughout the state, Alcibiades and his group of rebels also made a drunken parody of the Eleusinian Mysteries. I will not even mention when this notorious man physically harmed Hipponicus simply for a joke. The innocent man had done nothing to deserve this physical abuse, however, that meant nothing to Alcibiades. This …show more content…
It is known throughout Athens that Alcibiades imprisoned Agatharchus, a prestigious painter, and would not grant his release until all the walls in his home were graced with the artist’s skill. These immoral and selfish acts have become common ground for Alcibiades, resulting in the desecration of the herms to be a plausible event. This young man is influential; this young man is repugnant. It is my distinct fear that this man will get a lenient sentence due to his military stance in this state. The state feels Alcibiades’ expertise is needed during this expedition, however, these people are mistaken. Athenians should not allow such a disrespectful man be in charge of the lives of our state’s bravest men. Should Alcibiades stand trial before the expedition, those whom he has somehow charmed will claim his innocence. This man has brought bad luck upon our military and the future of our state, how can he be permitted to continue to live his carefree and ruthless life? I am simply an honest and faithful citizen of Athens, therefore, I beseech the court to think clearly upon this

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The case Against Athenogenes was a dispute over an agreement for the sale of slaves. The individuals involved in the case are Epicrates, a citizen of Athens and Athenogenes, a metic from Egypt. Epicrates was the plantiff, he brought the case against Athenogenes, the defendant. This was a private suit covering the damages caused by Athenogenes in the agreement. A hetaira named Antigone helped complete the agreement between Epicrates and Athenogenes (5).…

    • 807 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nicias and the Importance of Persuasive Leadership How did Nicias fail to convince the Athenian assembly that the Sicilian Expedition was a strategic error? His arguments, while valid and logical, are not sufficient to win over the assembly to undo their vote of war. Not only does Thucydides have incomplete information about these events, but Thucydides’ prior knowledge of Nicias’s failure colors the way he reconstructs Nicias’s ineffective arguments against war. Nicias attempts to dissuade the assembly from a war it has already approved by discussing the lack of a compelling reason to aid the Egesteans, the challenge of conquering and ruling Sicily, and the fragile truce with Sparta. Because Nicias’s appeals are ultimately unsuccessful, Thucydides uses this failure as an example of ineffective leadership in the Athenian state.…

    • 912 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    What is more illuminating is that way she weaves the story of the men in Neaira’s life using the judicial system for political and personal gain (Hamel, 155). This speaks a lot about the Greek political system, because when one thinks of Greek politics a fair and just system comes to mind. Yet this abuse of the court system for personal or political gain happened all too often and usually, like this case, consisted of outlandish accusations used to harm an opponent with the scandalous…

    • 1152 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As the scene opens on the agora of Athens we are introduced to two legal charges one an indictment, the other a prosecution. While both cases are equally confusing and blurry, Euthyphro,…

    • 1153 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    We must show no weakness to others, as that will make us vulnerable and easier to attack. The reconciliation agreement will bring much needed peace, closure and strength back to Athens. I firmly believe that we must not waste our own time and money putting the thirty tyrants through a lengthy trial process. We must as citizens rise to the common occasion of forgiveness and peace. The Thirty do not deserve more of our time and attention.…

    • 1340 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Again, this is stated in Plutarch's work that ”Mantinean men-at-arms, a thousand in number, declared plainly that it was all because of Alcibiades that they were making their long expedition across the seas, and that if any wrong should be done to him they would at once abandon it” (Plut.Alc.19.5). These pieces of evidence shows, that Alcibiades was truly committed in the expedition and wanted to expel any detrimental factors that would impede the success of what would be a massive undertaking. Knowing this level of commitment Alcibiades exhibits towards the expedition that the democratic majority advocated for, it is evident that it would be both contradictory and ludicrous to mutilate the Hermae statues. This again entails, it is very likely someone was trying to frame him. The delay of his trial which will be discussed next, explains why this would be…

    • 1456 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The most thought provoking text for me this semester was the chapter on Alcibiades from Plutarch’s Lives. From reading about, and discussing, the life of the ancient Greek war-hero, I was provoked to question what people look for in their leader, and what exactly makes a leader “good”. To spare no sentiment, Alcibiades, by today’s standards, appears to be downright crazy. He frequently was involved in physical altercations in which he would intentional injury others, often times without being provoked. He showed up at a man’s house fully unclothed asking to be “chastised”, and he even once cut off a dog’s tail.…

    • 761 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The most authentic, valid, and useable record that has been kept protected and unspoiled of Socrates’ defense of himself is the Apology. While the words penned in the Apology were not documented at the time they were spoken, Plato was present at the trial and; therefore, the record documented in the Apology was the words and confrontations of Socrates as Plato remembered them. However, one should put in mind that Plato was an admirer of Socrates and believed he is the true hero; in addition, he was still a student. Therefore, he may have been biased, in favor of Socrates, in the Apology. The Apology’s main focus is on Socrates’ responses to the different charges which are leveled against him by different accusers.…

    • 1138 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Athens on Trial In 399 BCE a grave mistake was made by Athens which will go down in history. It was the trial and execution of Socrates, a great and mysterious philosopher. Socrates was charged and found guilty for not worshiping the gods and corrupting the mind of the youth. Both off the charges are trumped up or not true at all because he believed i vn the Oracle of Delphi but did not agree with what it was saying and that he did not tell the kids to follow what he was doing, they did it on their own free will.…

    • 825 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One of his biggest rivals in the beginning of his public career was Aristides, who is said to have “always aimed at securing the utmost advantage for the state,” unlike Themistocles whose only concern was his own furtherance (Plutarch 79). After gaining enough influence, Themistocles had Aristides ostracized and also bribed Epicydes into declining the leadership of the Athenian forces, actions that create an image of a man driven by uncontrollable competitiveness and not by concern for the good of his people. With these two opponents out of the way, Themistocles was free to exercise his own schemes during the Persian wars. While Themistocles’ supervision did result in victory for the Greeks, it also enflamed his arrogance. After the war, Themistocles “carried his ambition to its furthest limit,” which created growing opposition towards himself (Plutarch 94).…

    • 984 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Can you assess justice and how you forage for it? Oedipus Rex, the King of Thebes, was in sought for the truth of his crimes. He perceived justice was never on his side because Apollo and the other gods never wanted him to receive equity. He presumed he was an honorable man that was failed by the justice system. However, the audience is ambivalent about the way he was in quest for his honesty and his apprehension of the precise definition of justice.…

    • 518 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    What are the charges against Socrates as recorded in the Apology. Is he guilty of them? why or why not? In Plato’s Apology, there were several charges against Socrates during his trial.…

    • 744 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I chose to analyze Gorgias’ writing, the Encomium of Helen. Gorgias is defending Helen by pointing out specific reasons as to why she should not be blamed for starting the Trojan War. “How can one regard blame of Helen as just, since she is utterly acquitted of all charges, whether she did what…

    • 1791 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In ancient Greece, human nature drove men to embrace passion, ignore justice, and act on envy at the expense of morality. It pushed men to engage in grotesque acts of violence for the sake of revenge, making the ubiquity of human nature in the period a central concern (3.84). The “laws of humanity”, those principles of justice and morality which had evolved over the previous centuries of Greek society, became irrelevant in the Peloponnesian War: what mattered was survival. Political strife became intertwined with death, loss of property, and moral decline as the example of Corcyra became the norm in the Hellenic…

    • 1515 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    In Athens, the old-fashioned and traditional way of life is what one would consider the proper and just speech. Contrary, unjust speech is not accepted in the court of law because it does not appeal to the gods. Unjust speech is seen as boosting self-indulgence and is seen as a threat to the city (Clouds, pg.151). Throughout Aristophanes’ Clouds there is a battle between what is new and old, just and unjust. This is clear in Clouds, considering that Pheidippides would be considered “New”, overturns the old, which would be considered “Strepsiades”.…

    • 1689 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays