Steven M. Cahn: A Film Analysis

Improved Essays
This essay will argue in favour of the view presented by Steven M. Cahn that, while society may not approve of immoral action (with good reason) this is far from sufficient to conclude that anyone who performs an immoral action for the sake of happiness cannot be truly happy.
The key example Cahn uses is Judah Rosenthal (a character appropriated from a Woody Allen film) to explain his argument that the happy life need not be identical with the “morally-good” or “virtuous” life (Cahn & Vitrano, 2015). Judah Rosenthal is a doctor who gets his lover killed (after she threatened to reveal their affair) in order to sustain his reputation as a doctor as well as his relationships with his wife, family and community. In essence, Cahn argues that Rosenthal commits an immoral action in order to maximise happiness (and prevent his life being destroyed) and that we can deem Judas happy, despite his murderous act. As such, Cahn argues that morality and happiness are not the same, as while the majority
…show more content…
This view then is susceptible to all criticisms of objective list theories; which Cahn notes, in stating that while morality may be an important (or even necessary) condition for a happy life for most people, you cannot generalise this to all people (Cahn & Vitrano, 2015). So while most people could not act as Judah Rosenthal had (and in a Kantian sense of universal principles it would be highly detrimental to society if everyone did) there can be extenuating circumstances for which immoral action will be far more conducive to happiness (Cahn & Vitrano, 2015). Thus, while for most, the happy life is a moral life, this can be a coincidental occurrence and the happy and moral lives are by no means

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Summary of Adam Grant Adam Grant’s article, “Does Trying to Be Happy Make Us Unhappy,” discusses finding happiness. Grant’s thesis indicates that, trying to be happy will not make us happy. He evaluates an individual case by applying different happiness related theories. At the beginning, Adam Grant points out that searching out for happiness is not a correct way of persuading happiness.…

    • 377 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the essay, “In Pursuit of Happiness” by Mark Kingwell, the author references John Ralston Saul, a “contemporary critic,” (Kingwell). In the text, Kingwell mentions Saul’s notion that nowadays happiness is more commonly represented by a person’s wealth or “material comfort”. Saul’s statement is true; think about all the convenience or luxury items a person will buy during their lifetime. Today in the age of technology, many people are comforted in the fact that their new touchscreen phone is waterproof, scratch resistant, and for an added measure, protected with the longest lasting insurance plan.…

    • 293 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Everyone has their own individual definition of happiness. Richard Taylor describes happiness as “a state of being, not a mere feeling” (Taylor, 116), but how may one come to this total state of fulfillment? Vivien Sung who wrote Five-Fold Happiness and Richard Taylor who wrote a chapter on happiness in his book An Introduction to Virtue Ethics both agree that happiness is made up of many different parts. Because happiness is made up of different components, achieving prosperity, longevity, and wealth are three elements that can lead to being fully…

    • 91 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Are you living life, right? What if someone told you that you were doing this whole life thing wrong all along? In reading the writings of transcendentalist, ones perception of life may be completely altered. The comparing and contrasting of modern day Americans lives and how that should, can be eye-opening.…

    • 606 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Walter Mosley 's essay, “Get Happy” the author repeats the opening lines of the Declaration of Independence. This technique serves not only as an introduction and a preview of the forthcoming message but also establishes context and reminds the reader of what the phrase actually says. So many people think that our Declaration of Independence ensures Americans of life, liberty and happiness, but in face it is the pursuit of happiness. Mosley believes that in comparison to life and liberty, “our potential for happiness has lagged far behind.”…

    • 838 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hamblin continues to discuss the idea that money cannot buy happiness in terms of material possession but it can in terms of experiences. He defends this by explaining that it is more difficult to compare experiences than it is material possessions. Hamblin mentions Killingsworth’s definition of happiness is “moment to moment experience” and he uses a variety of rhetorical devices to display this idea and paint this picture for us. Hamblin begins by using an appeal to ethos by providing knowledge from other creditable persons by mentioning Killingsworth and Gilbert, containing degrees in psychology, as well as providing personal information.…

    • 968 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Tellishment Argument

    • 739 Words
    • 3 Pages

    What is the moral theory of utilitarianism? According to Vaughn, “[Utilitarianism is] the view that right actions are those that result in the greatest overall happiness for everyone involved” (Vaughn, 79). At face value such a moral theory sounds great, because it should promote general happiness. While this is true, a particular argument, the telishment argument, shows that utilitarianism is not a viable moral theory because it promotes decisions that run contrary to historical moral inclinations. To prove this is the case, this paper will first dive into what happiness means in the utilitarian sense, the telishment argument itself, what points of contention the tellishment argument brings up against utilitarianism, and finally, what utilitarianism has to say in its own defense.…

    • 739 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Rhetorical Analysis

    • 1180 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The pursuit of happiness is a universal concept amongst humans. But is this concept universally believed and understood in the same way? Is happiness really the end goal, or does pursuing a meaningful life lead to a more fulfilling life? In an article from The Atlantic, “There’s More to Life than Being Happy,” Emily Esfahani Smith discusses the misconception of the pursuit of happiness and the difference between those who seek a life of meaning through the use of ethos, pathos, logos, and other rhetorical devices utilized within these methods. First, Smith expertly utilizes ethos throughout the essay to support her research by numerously stating the scholarly sources she uses.…

    • 1180 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Pursuit of Happiness The Declaration of Independence refers to the “pursuit of happiness”, which has been raised in debate to determine if the word happiness should be replaced with the word pleasure. This is a valid argument, because happiness and pleasure seem to be exchangeable, but in reality these terms involve different emotions. This paper will discuss The Declaration of Independence reference to the “pursuit of happiness” and determine is pleasure should replace happiness.…

    • 388 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The view of happiness as well as the role that pleasures and desires play in achieving happiness can be seen throughout Western philosophy. Detailing a hypothetical dinner conversation between Aristotle, Epicurus, Hobbes, and Epictetus, will such an understanding be described. In such an account, I will be detailing: what issue/s each guest would raise; what thesis would each defend, and how each would respond to the other; as well as who is most likely to disagree with whom and on which points, and who, on the other hand, might find allies or sympathizers. Each philosopher defines/views happiness differently. Aristotle defines happiness as an activity of the soul in accordance to virtue and reason.…

    • 1449 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Every art and every inquiry, and likewise every action and choice, seems to aim at some good, and hence it has been beautifully said that the good is that at which all things aim.” As Aristotle makes inquires and deliberates over what is the highest end for the human life, he debates over what constitutes the highest good. Throughout the Nicomachean Ethics, Aristotle argues that we aim at some end through our pursuits of action, and that those ends are in some way connected at achieving the highest good. Aristotle suggests the possibility of happiness, translated from the Greek word eudaimonia, which refers to a “state of having a good indwelling spirit or being in a contented state of being healthy, happy and prosperous.” For the one who…

    • 1453 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Since a very young age we have been told by our parents to always tell the truth. But, do we always follow that order? No. Sometimes people lie. Lying can be defined as when a person knows the truth, but instead he says otherwise.…

    • 1259 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Immoral and vicious people can not be happy because of their actions. Immoral actions are not good and do not lead to happiness because they are taking part in harmful actions which may impede some else’s…

    • 971 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1. What, according to Aristotle, is the relationship between happiness and virtue? Working to possess and exercise virtue is essential to achieve the highest degree of happiness. Virtuousness is a unique element of happiness in the sense that we can work to control it through our own habituation. This can be compared to the plethora of components that our disposition creates a predetermined outcome for, including the external and physical goods we desire. Aristotle expands on this idea, stating that when happiness, “...comes as a result of virtue and some process of learning or training, [it is] among the most god-like things; for that which is the prize and end of virtue seems to be the best thing in the world, and something godlike and blessed” (Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics, 947).…

    • 770 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If one hundred people, were asked what does it mean to live the good life, no two responses would be exactly the same. Even though everyone’s response would be different, many of the responses would most likely include being happy. Similarly to how people’s responses would differ if asked the original question, everyone would have their own definition of what happiness means to them because certain words mean different things to different people. Many of the authors that were covered in class talked about happiness and its relation to the good life. The authors that gave the most insight into their view of happiness were Aristotle, Immanuel Kant, and John Stuart Mill.…

    • 1325 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics