The French Revolution: Was The Haitian Revolution Justified?

Improved Essays
“Power devolves to the people who have a right to resume their original liberty, and establish a new legislative (such as they shall think fit), provide for their own safety and security.”
-John Locke
Rebellion against a government is a necessary tactic to gain a sufficient quality of life for all citizens. One such rebellion, the French Revolution, lasting from 1789-1799, extinguished the reign of the monarch and their supporting nobles, who had used the countries resources for their own lavish accessories. Another revolt, the Haitian Revolution from 1791-1804, displayed the strength in numbers as slaves rebelled against their masters. Other more recent rebellions, such as the Arab Spring starting in 2011, called for the resignation of the
…show more content…
The top two and least populated estates were rich and privileges. On the other hand, the third estate which had the highest population were poor, starving, and exploited. The third estate was angry with the privileges that the higher classes had. For example, they did not have to pay France’s main tax. (“Causes of the French Revolution”).The upper class was treating the lower class unfairly, causing them to have to live in poverty. While the upper class lived a life of luxury, the lower class lived starving and angry. The French Revolution was justified because of the oppression of the poor. Further, in Haiti, slave labor had been used in the sugar trade, among other crops. The slaves were mistreated and their inalienable rights were taken away. They used the French Revolution as inspiration to have their own rebellion. In the article, “The Haitian Revolution” it states, “[Haiti] became France's wealthiest overseas colony, largely because of its production of sugar, coffee, indigo, and cotton generated by an enslaved labor force” (BlackPast.org). The unfair treatment to the slaves by the white Frenchmen in Haiti gave them a fair reason to revolt against the government. Eventually, their rebellion worked and the slaves were freed. Having a government that oppresses certain groups gives the people the right to …show more content…
Before the revolution, France had spent the majority of their money helping the Americans gain freedom from the British. With their bank account spent, the leaders of the country would cut back on their share of the money to help the country get back on its feet. King Louis did not do this. Instead he spent “anywhere from 6-25% of the entire French government income” on the upkeep of his massive palace. (The Palace of Versailles). Instead of using the income to help the poor, the King used the money for his own benefit, harming the country. His carelessness with money caused France to fall into a deep debt, upsetting those who had to pay more taxes to repay it. The rebellion was justified because the government was ruining the countries economic state. In modern Tunisia, citizens are oppressed by the government. A street vendor was told he could no longer sell vegetables on the street, and as a form of rebellion he lit himself of fire, dying a few days later. (BBC News). His protest sparked protest in the eyes of other Tunisians and began in the Arab Spring. The government prohibited the street vendor from selling his vegetables, which hurt him and his customers. The government unfairly took his supplies and forced him to stop selling his product. When the government harms the well-being of the country and its citizens, it is justified to

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The French Revolution is a result of the mixture of the bankruptcy of France, the inequality of the Estates, and the slaughtering of the Bastille. Rousseau’s idea of ruling by “General Will” gave citizens the idea that they have power in government. The Third Estate took this idea and made the absolute monarchy into a republic. Louis was so bankrupt he could not recover from the rebellions of the commoners. His marriage with Marie Antoinette never helped his situation because of her constant need for expensive dresses. Leaving the poor with nothing to eat left the people no choice but to riot for bread prices to lower. As the riots grew towards Bastille, they stole its gunpowder to defend themselves. The fall of the Bastille lead to a decrease in Louis’ military and political power. As Louis fell the National Assembly grew allowing the French Revolution to launch…

    • 773 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the eyes of the masters, the Haitian Revolution will harm the wealthy because the slave labor is the reason for their wealth. Their dependence on slaves to labor in the fields, build ships, and perform a horde of other subsidized labors is absolute. France uses the United States refusal to abandon its stance on slavery to do the same with its…

    • 1397 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the late 1700s and early 1800s, revolutionary spirit was everywhere. The world was shocked at the success of the American Revolution, in which the oppressed colonies gained independence from Britain. This success, along with several other causes, motivated the oppressed lower class of France to have their own revolution. Shortly after the French Revolution, Haiti, a French colony, was inspired by the same ideals and had one of their own. The French Revolution and the Haitian Revolution are very similar in the ideals that drove them, the way they were carried out, and the things they achieved both through the revolutions themselves and their legacies today.…

    • 1432 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Revolutions are seen by many as an inevitable part of many societies. They allow both the people and societies to progress and advance. One of these revolutions was the French Revolution, which led to the downfall of monarchies in other parts of Europe. The French Revolution began in 1789 and ended in the late 1790s. The revolution began with people wanting small reforms, such as changes to the system of taxation; leading to a complete change, transforming every aspect of French citizen’s lives, including for a short time, calendars and clocks. The events during the revolution gradually became more and more radical; starting with non-radical things such as the calling of the Estate-General and formation of the National Assembly, then progressing…

    • 1138 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The main issue being brutal torture land owners had to do on to their slaves. The people wanted to break away from Napoleon's french army who was in complete control over them. The Haitians were inspired by both the enlightenment, and the colonists of America, who had courage and bravery to break away from their own mother country. Napoleon had lost the fight, France granted Haitians their independence, and all the slaves were able to be free of torture and forced labor. The Haitians decided to use a republic, and in 1804 the Haitian Revolution came to an…

    • 878 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The French Revolution had many causes for its occurrence including, but not limited to, their leader, unfair treatment of the estates, and poor living conditions of the lower class. This led the people to revolt and made life even more chaotic for the residents of France. Their government, an absolute monarchy, gave King Louis XVI the right to do whatever he wanted for the “well-being” of France. As explained in Document 1, “He ruled by the divine right theory which held that he had received his power to govern from God and was therefore responsible to God alone.” This means that the king had complete control over the power and finance of France and often used it to only benefit himself. Another cause of the Revolution was because all of the…

    • 350 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A revolution is when citizens of a country rebel against their government seeking major change. This occurred in France shortly after the Declaration Of Independence was signed which pronounced the American Colonies free from the British’s taxes and unfair treatment as well as marked the end of the American Revolution. Unlike the Americans, the French were fighting amongst social classes or estates in their own government. It started with the rebellion of the Third Estate, which consisted of extremely poor commoners who made up the majority of France at the time. The most important causes of the French Revolution were the heavy taxes on the third estate, the unfair amount of land and power the 1st and 2nd Estate held, and the American Revolution.…

    • 616 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The French Revolution was divided into three social classes the clergy (first estate), the nobles (second estate) and the peasants (third estate). The upper class (the clergy and the nobles) raised the tax prices on the third estate but they didn’t have to pay taxes. They also raised the price of bread which made most of the peasants starve and they would fight over the loaves of bread. But later the third estate creates something known as the National Assembly and they created the Declaration of the Rights of Man which changed many things. There were many things that caused the French Revolution but the main reasons are the inequalities between the social classes, The Enlightenment, and the American example.…

    • 958 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The first of many reasons why the French Revolution began had to do with the many ideas that came about from the Enlightenment and those that believed in these thought processes. For example, the colonists in the successful American Revolution believed in the Enlightenment idea that all men are created equal and have inherent rights. Middle class citizens communicated their feelings towards the First and Second Estates, but ended up not having their feeling taken into account because the Second Estate got angry with King Louis and he then went back on what he had promised. This initiated the middle class to become “sensitive to their inferior legal position” (Doc. 4). Instead of requiring the First and Second Estates to pay more taxes because…

    • 282 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many events leading up to the war for Haiti’s independence were much like the French Revolution: the rebellion of the lower class (slaves and former slaves), the tension between different social groups, and revolt strategies such as individually poisoning one’s oppressor, which showed resemblance to the Great Fear that had occurred in France. The later stages of the Haitian revolution also began to resemble the American revolution, as French troops attempted to gain a stronger hold on the colony, to which Dessalines’ army fought back and forced them to retreat. The result of the revolution is also more similar to the American revolution, seeing that both colonies gained independence and formed a new nation. Although the example of the American revolution may have provided the Haitians with the willpower and courage to fight back against the invading mainland, the events of the French Revolution probably played a more influential role in triggering the beginning of the rebellion in Haiti, because it gave the blacks in Saint-Domingue had a place to draw inspiration from, as well as good knowledge of how the French had been defeated before. Without this inspiration, the resistance may have never been successful in the first place, and the need for the revolution would have not become necessary. In this way, the Haitian Revolution serves as a good example of how seemingly unrelated events can affect and trigger one…

    • 1153 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To conclude, the Haitian revolution and the French Revolution were more alike than different. These revolutions were inspired by the enlightenment and the american revolution. Moreover, they both struggling with the proper rights and representation of their people in government, and they did not like how they were being ruled, even though their economies were completely different. Thus there outcomes were similar but slightly different because of their location and disposition, they both had a new republican government and leaders, and helped reform the social…

    • 616 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The French Revolution started in 1789 and ended in 1799. It all began with the extravagant spendings of King Louis and Marie Antoinette, the bankruptcy, the poor harvest, the rises in bread and taxes, and lastly, American Revolution. All of these were factors in the suffering of the 3rd Estate. Imagine being part of the 90% people who were either peasants or the homeless that were starving and were treated unequally. The people of France rebelled because they were suffering from the monarchy.…

    • 1114 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This occurred in France from 1789-1799. Some of the causes of this revolution were social, economic, financial, and cultural. France was heavily in debt. They were in debt because France had fought against Prussia and Britain in the Seven Years War. They had also served as allies with the colonies against Britain in the American Revolutionary War. The country became poor due to the fact that they had borrowed a lot of money which they invested in the wars. Before the time leading up to the French revolution, France was headed by the Catholic church as well as by nobles.Many people disliked the absolute rule that monarchs and nobles had. The three Estates of france were not divided fairly. The First and Second Estates were made up of the clergy and of nobles while the Third Estate was majority of the population. The Third Estate was made up of the lower class and they still were the only Estate which had to pay tithes or taxes. Enlightenment ideas heavily influenced people’s desire for more power and for liberty. The French were inspired by the American Revolution and saw that a new nation (United States of America), was headed by the Catholic church and alao by nobles. The French Revolution ended in 1799 when Napoleon Bonaparte took power thus ending the monarchy. This revolution was just because it gradually fixed the fact the the lower class and people with lower social status were being heavily taken advantage…

    • 842 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    in contrast to the divine right of kings that characterized the French monarchy, and social equality among citizens and eliminating the special rights of the nobility and clergy.6 There was also the Haitian Revolution (1791­1804) a slave revolt in the French colony. Described as one of the largest and most successful slave rebellions in the western Hemisphere influenced by the Enlightenment with that “all men…

    • 686 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The French Revolution occurred under King Louis XVI, who was eventually executed. French society was dealing with high taxes and bad harvests which led them to dislike the government. They disliked the government because they were jealous of the privileges enjoyed by the…

    • 1579 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays