The Great Train Film Analysis

Superior Essays
America’s history or an interpretation of the nation’s history has been played out throughout the decades in film, the Western is no different. While other countries have adopted their own versions, the American Western has qualities can only be interrupted as American. While playing out the the fight against evil, greed, and taming of the frontier, the Western was also depicting America’s thoughts about itself. Like the films, the nation was fraught with conflict for what ideals it should stand for. As time went on the Western took on other themes that were coming to the forefront in the nation’s identity. Films like The Great Train Robbery, depicted good over bad, basic values that were evident. Others that came after it were also illustrating “much about America’s past, glorifying the past-fading values and aspirations of the mythical by-gone age of the West” (Dirks Part 1). Was America trying to escape the new ideas coming to the forefront of American life or trying to make sense of it? The Western genre tried to convey it’s own message on ever changing times about equality, individualism, and justification for the conflicts in which the nation was a part of. When a movie like the first American Western, The Great Train Robbery, are revisited, there is only one battle going on. This battle is between “a basic moral opposition between good and evil” (Cawelti 36). The movie basically conveys right and wrong. There are no additions of “others” are not …show more content…
People watch Westerns in order to escape an evolving nation or to make sense of all the changes around them. The Western film genre does attempt to hold on to the old ways when it comes to equality, individualism, and conflict. In the Western film, America is not only taming the new frontier and saving the day, it is trying to tame and save its own ideals and

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In today’s society Indians are not recognized or given enough respect towards them and their culture and lifestyle. However, this is nothing new, it has been going on ever since Christopher Columbus stepped foot in America. In the film industries, Native Americans have mostly always been depicted in negative ways. However, there have been movies that have tried to portray the reality of Native American lifestyle and culture in America. They still have some, but less, Native American stereotypes or myths than other movies .Two…

    • 917 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Reported from Variety, actors Jared Leto and Chris Evans are being strongly considered for the Dreamworks film adaptation of Paula Hawkins best-selling novel The Girl on the Train. The novel follows a woman who has just gone through a tumultuous divorce, but finds relish in her train commute. She observes a married couple from a far on her way to work, envisioning they live a perfect romantic life, but then finds herself tied into a strange mystery involving this couple. The film has already found a trio of actresses to appear in the film with it confirmed that Emily Blunt will star in it, and that Rebecca Ferguson and Haley Bennett will have supporting roles.…

    • 370 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    True Grit Film Analysis

    • 1352 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The western world of the United States experienced a great amount of attention during the second half of the nineteenth century. This period, commonly referred to as the Wild West, was the time in which cowboys represented the area. This period, however, was also the time in which excessive crime and violence characterized the area. With the opportunities to start farms and ranches and mine precious metals, thousands of Americans on the east coast began to move west. As a result, numerous small towns quickly erupted across the western states.…

    • 1352 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Through the eyes of both early Americans and today’s society, represented through the founding documents and Will Allen’s The Other Wes Moore, being an American means demonstrating change and progression. When the colonies became unhappy with the British Crown’s tyranny, they changed and progressed by writing “The Declaration of Independence.” While this change was seen as beneficial towards America’s future, not all changes that America went through were advantageous. The “Articles of Confederation,” for example, represent some of the adverse choices that America made. While the choices that characters faced in The Other Wes Moore were miniscule in comparison to the early American decisions, they still altered the outcome to a situation.…

    • 1690 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In his anthology, Americans: Dispatches From the New Frontier, best-selling author, award-winning journalist, and historian Hampton Sides describes different aspects and characteristics of American life. For more than fifteen years, Sides has traveled widely, exploring different version of America not widely recognized . In Americana: Dispatches from the New Frontier, which consists of two dozen pieces, Sides manages to give the reader a new poignant perspective of the unique and often bizarre subcultures in America. Besides Sides ability to bring the reader into situations they would never otherwise find themselves, Americana: Dispatches from the New Frontier, manages to stand out for its ability to unify and create a common identity among…

    • 208 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This is how Americans see them now. If a person were to go turn on the television, they would be able to come across a show from the wild west like Gun smoke or Bonanza. These shows have men who are tough and will not take no for an answer. This is what the western heroes did to take the land of the Native Americans. They use showdowns as a form of violence to portray its either going to be one way or the other and there is no in between.…

    • 1405 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The conventions of the western genre are specific and engrained in American society as the epitome and personification of the "final frontier." The American dream was established first with the Revolution from the British and further enhanced and engrained in history with the ride West. Many of the recurring concepts in westerns include the pivotal battles between civilization and wilderness, between humble homesteaders and hot-headed gunslingers, and between the internal struggle of "all for one or one for all. " Shane fits into the genre of a classic western because there is a heavy conflict between wilderness against civilization as seen in both physical and personified representations, the story formula follows that of moral versus immoral…

    • 135 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Far West Disadvantages

    • 1769 Words
    • 8 Pages

    The idea of the West comforts people as it reminds them that their dream of starting a new life can always come true in the open and “uncharted territories” of the West. Nonetheless, now that everyone is migrating West to fulfill their goals in starting anew, the amount of unsettled land is slowly running out and being transforming into the nation’s ways of civilization. Through the “last frontier” idea, the American settlers viewed a romantic vision of migrating to the West. Through the works of Mark Twain, he demonstrates the romantic overview of the “last frontier” as he portrays the characters in his novels to be escaping the “constraints of civilization” and escaping the natural world. Furthermore, Frederic Remington captures the romanticism behind migrating westward through his artwork as he depicts a cowboy as a natural aristocrat living in a world without the factors of “civilization” in it.…

    • 1769 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Neldon Ryan Hamblin Professor Robb Kunz History 2600 September 21, 2015 Compare/contrast Assignment A common theme is ever present in both The Legacy of Conquest by Patricia Limerick and The American West by Anne Butler and Michael Lansing: a profound feeling of responsibility by the authors to set the record of the west straight and to enlighten our minds with facts and depictions of the true west. They do this by using accounts from primary sources, not the fabrications of Hollywood or “John Wayne” that we are used to seeing. However, the books differ in explaining the origin of the romanticization of the west.…

    • 1281 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Smoke Signals Analysis

    • 762 Words
    • 4 Pages

    There are no cowboys or savage Indians tormenting or being tormented, there is simply a task at hand having to do with their tradition. Rather than a film with hero John Wayne protecting the Wild West from the ambushing Indians, the audience sees Indians minding to themselves and fulfilling their own customs. The film emphasizes family over the little violence and prejudices taking place. This also takes place in the contemporary 20th century, while most of the notorious and stereotypical fashions of Native Americans were place in the 19th century classic Westerns. The elements that usually create a Western are not present in this film, there may be hints towards the past Westerns, such as the comment on cowboys and John Wayne, but no other part brings out the essence of a Hollywood…

    • 762 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    After the end of World War I, Americans began to feel a distinct lack of national identity. They felt disconnected from their past and were unsure where the future was taking them. Compared to their European counterparts with their long and rich history full of art and literature, Americans felt that their country was inferior and provincial. A call to restore the American pride rose from the ranks of writers and artists, demanding the creation of a new history of the United States, one that would provide a worthy foundation of people, places, and events for American artists to draw inspiration from. They responded enthusiastically, excited to shake off the chains of worldly influence and forge ahead to create a new identity for America filled…

    • 976 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Westward Expansion Essay

    • 754 Words
    • 4 Pages

    While the previous chapter demonstrated that the utopian idea of ‘the West’ had been part of the American imagination since its founding, the following chapter will discuss the historical and cultural factors that shaped the mythic West within the American context. As some of the basis elements of mythic West can be traced back to the expansionist process and how it was justified both rhetorically and ideologically, Westward Expansion is a central part of the discussion of what constitutes the mythic West. Although the process of expansion was both complex and multifaceted, the factual events are not particularly important in relation to the mythic West. Rather, it is how the process was expressed and imagined that influenced the West’s image.…

    • 754 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    John Ford’s The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance is a depiction of an inescapable transition where the society is transformed from an old and wild social order to a modern and organized one. In this film, Ford brings to perspective the society in the past and how it died as a result of modernization. The western frontier ideals are brought to light with the transition from a lawless social order embodied by the gunslingers into a modern society governed by law and order (Ebert). The inevitable transition represents a death of the Old Wild West, which then paves way for a new, tamed and civilized society.…

    • 1490 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Response Paper #3 Mise-en-scene in True Grit The movie True Grit is based back in the old western times. This is a story of a girl who seeks revenge where our main character in Mattie aims to kill Tom Chaney who has killed her father. This movie has been one, that many believe has challenged the norms of a traditional western.…

    • 811 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    According to Studlar and Bernstein (2001), John Ford advocates the cinematic poetry and sentimental narrative toward both U.S westward history and his personal experiences since nineteenth-century. The conventions of western films on narrative and characters had massive success since cinema became the mass medium, which enable to showcase the historical wild West spectacle and nostalgic sensation in films (Studlar and Bernstein, 2001). My Darling Clementine illustrates with the audience falling for the Western films. Throughout the history of American westward expansion, My Darling Clementine implicitly reflects the progress of civilization in frontier towns such as Tombstone and the turning point from wild Western to moral society. At the…

    • 1609 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays