The Giving Tree By Shell Silberstein Analysis

Improved Essays
In the book “The Giving Tree” by Shell Silberstein the reader learns that the Giving Tree has a deeper meaning than just a regular children’s book. When you read the book it sounds just like a nice story, but after you interpret the meaning of every line you realize that there is much more to it. Some interpret the book as something to promote bad behavior and others interpret the book as a way people looked at nature at the time the book was written. The giving Tree is about a boy who is friends with a tree and ends up using the tree to benefit himself throughout the book.
My interpretation of the book is that the Giving tree and the boy have a parent to child relationship while teaching many important life lessons. In the book the parent being the tree gives the boy unconditional love throughout the book never keeping count. So she gives and gives and gives, never expecting anything in return, never asking for anything back, and never reminding the boy of all she has given up for him. For example when the boy needs a house after already
…show more content…
Blanche Laver had interpreted the book to be promoting bad behavior instead of teaching good life lessons. For example she claimed that the book promotes a “destructive relationship”, and she claims that one person is a victim and the other is the beneficiary however the relationship is never really like that. It’s a problem in our society that people always want something in return. Really Blanche is just really selfish and doesn’t believe that unconditional love is a thing. For her both people need to be getting something out of the relationship to be happy however I believe that Silverstein is trying to say the opposite that you don’t always have to be getting something to be happy. But I do agree that somethings in the book aren’t portrayed correctly, for example the boy never thanks the tree for what he gets and I believe that gratitude should be displayed in the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    When I was young, my parents pressed me on how giving back was a good thing, but I never realized it until I was older. As a child, my mother read the book “The Giving Tree” to me. The story is about a boy who visits a tree everyday and builds a strong relationship with the tree. Initially they would play all day long, but as the boy grew older, he would ask the tree for various things, such as apples or shade. The tree would always give the boy whatever he wanted, followed by saying that helping the boy made her happy.…

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Instead, rather, he tries to illustrate to readers that the flaws of society need corrected before people punish others for acting on natural impulses. Hawthorne believes that sometimes people cannot control their emotions and desires, having sexual desires and passions are not something extraordinary, every person harbors such desires, it is something that can be found in the nature of every human being. Nonetheless, Hester’s id overpowered her superego, and she had an affair despite knowing its immorality in her…

    • 977 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Atticus Parenting Quotes

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In the beginning, Scout and Jem was not particularly proud or willing to show off their father, but by the time the book concluded, they wanted the entire world to look upon Atticus. This really expresses how shallow people are without comprehending it. People have this idea that a person has to be a certain way to become “normal” when in truth, everyone has their own beliefs and outlook on the world,but most often people sacrifice their own individuality to fit…

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the short story “The Giving Tree,” you will find many meaningful quotes, so much so that scholars have long debated the true meaning behind the story. As a reader, this book becomes open to the individual reader’s own interpretation. Someone once said, “Running away from your problems is a race you will never win.” I believe this quote is true to this story and to life in general. About halfway through the story, the boy is old and has been beat up by life and just wants to run from his problems. However later in the story, he comes back to the tree, the place that has always been there, helped him and made him happier.…

    • 623 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The tree gave love but she never received it. The boy took advantage of the tree and took all the love she had. Also in the story, the boy and the tree did some aging. “But the boy stayed away for a long time…. and the tree was sad” (Silverstein).…

    • 967 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Women were meant to be proper and ladylike but also very protective of their reputation and class otherwise were disliked thus showing the insult Lydia is subjected to, in the eyes of Mr Collins, is justified. In addition, later in the letter sent from Mr Collins he says, “…to throw off your unworthy child from your affection for ever…”. The use of the adjective “unworthy” demonstrates the seriousness of the Lydia’s behaviour, Lydia isn’t deserving of her family’s love and resources. Also, the noun, “for ever” makes this disapproval final and long lasting. Initially, the extreme views presented by Mr Collins are seen as offensive by modern day readers but alternatively, Austen is perhaps identifying the flaws in society, with the extreme language she use to suggest that the mockery Lydia is subjected to isn’t necessary.…

    • 357 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She has spent so much time denying her feelings for Benedick, and claiming that men are evil, that she is afraid of what people will think of her now. She does not know whether they would mock her for falling for someone she swore she hated. They might look down on her for being fickle and changing her opinion. She does not know what their reaction will be, and that scares her. Rather than facing this fear, she rejects Benedick, because that is what she has always…

    • 1605 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The song is showing us that women are not getting treated fairly and right, as if they are not part of the world. For example in the song it says “Now a man will take a good girl And he’ll ruin her reputation”(Parton 17,18). From this lyric we can infer that women have no life. The husband or men are controlling the women. The first part of the song starts of by saying “I can see you're disappointed/ By the way you look at me/ And I'm sorry that I'm not The woman you thought I'd be Yes,/I've made my mistakes But listen and understand/ My mistakes are no worse than yours Just because I'm a woman(Parton 1-8).” This is telling us that the men were always disappointed in women.…

    • 1074 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The short story “The Birthmark” by Nathaniel Hawthorne illustrates that no individual is flawless; we are all internally flawed because we try to change others and our flaws, but we need to learn to accept those flaws. As Aylmer, the main character tries to heal the birthmark on the face of his wife, Georgiana; he unintentionally destroys her. In our daily lives, we come across people who do not believe in themselves because they have issues of self-esteem. They have always been told that they are not beautiful enough, however, the person telling them those things are the unattractive ones with insecurities. In order to avoid these people, we have to tell ourselves that we are beautiful and beautiful people surround…

    • 1108 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Helene was never her real friend and Carter thinks of Maria more of a liability than an ex-wife could be a friend. Maria’s relationships are toxic. One of the reasons she became close to BZ was their shared disdain for life and depression. It is extremely tough to break relationships and completely change the social circle. However, it is possible and advisable.…

    • 2263 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays