Theory Y Theory

Great Essays
Louis “Lou” Maynard was appointed as a sergeant with the Craigview Police Department after six months on the job. Assigned to his shift was two officers who were within one year of their retirement. Previously on the shift, the co-workers worked well together performing their duties and day to day assignments, with the exception of the two soon to be retired officers. The once united team began to feel disconnected and broken. Maynard felt that any reports submitted by his co-workers were almost insufficient to where their work ethics became questionable, but not to the point that disciplinary action was required. In the past, both officers displayed a positive attitude and work relationship with their fellow co-workers and on occasions, attended …show more content…
It is a straightforward theory based on the belief that managers conduct themselves according to the assumptions, generalizations, and hypotheses they have about human behavior. (McGregor, 1960) There are two main theories: theory X and theory Y. Theory X, the employee has a strong dislike to work and has to constantly be told what to do. Job security for most people is their main concern. Some people because of their unwillingness to work will have to be instructed, forced, and sometimes pressured that if the company needs are not successful, disciplinary action will follow in an attempt to accomplish set goals. Like everything else a major worry for employees is longevity and job security. This view of human behavior is still somewhat prevalent in the policing field and is reminiscent of autocratic leadership. (McGregor, 1960) This employee will work if their basic needs such as money and safety and security issues are …show more content…
A supervisor should have some level of formal education prior to promotion because it’s something that will set them apart. Supervisors who have prior education can be acknowledged as a method to teach, train and direct someone under your supervision. A lot of new hires are required to have some type of degree whether it is an Associate’s degree or higher and with the challenging workforce many thinks education go farther than experience. For a subordinate who is close to retirement, but lacks education, to have a much younger person to be given authority over him in his eyes could be a slap in the face although he have years of experience and know the job inside out. There are bounded to disappointment, emotions effects, self-esteem issues, feeling overlook and not

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    They’re convinced that they must do all the work because their staff doesn’t accept responsibility. Settling In, as a manager many think that that if not successful immediate change is needed. However, one of your first decisions a manager should do is hold back from rapidly instituting changes in the method of operation. Sudden changes often result in a fear response that will work against you. When changes are needed to made, its best to explain what will be taking place and why.…

    • 1046 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Employees need guidance and direction from upper management. New employees that Yamato Transport (M) recruits may need extra help in learning an unfamiliar job. The absence of a training program that Yamato Transport (M) rarely had may cause workers to fall behind in their level of performance and feel that their abilities are lacking. Apart from that, an unequal or substandard wage structures for employee at Yamato Transport (M) will be a cause of the understaff issues. Inequity in pay structures or low pay is great causes of dissatisfaction and can drive some employees at Yamato Transport (M) to quit.…

    • 1133 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Working Abroad Analysis

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages

    But you as a manger need to know what that culture is and work within it, because in not doing so, you will not get the proper motivation for your employees, and in the end that will undermine you as a manger. Leaving your home land to work in another country, or even sometimes region, and be problematic for a manger. management culture tends to be to drive our employees, even micromanage them. But what we really see here a lot is managers that lead by example by being at work as much as possible, working long hours, and never taking time off. In other countries, there may be similar or even different management culture.…

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Unethical Legal Issues

    • 786 Words
    • 4 Pages

    To prevent unethical behavior, make realistic goals for your staff. If your employees are expected to achieve extremely hard quotas and goals, this could make them want to engage in unethical behavior to attempt to get the job done. Always consistently monitor your employee performance. Employees left unattended sometimes slack in their performance and take credit for someone 's tasks that were left undone. Train all employees very well because untrained employees often cut corners and make excuses for not completing work up to the standards the business…

    • 786 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    Being unaware of what an employee should be improving can lead towards making dangerous mistakes. Not everyone in the company will be perfect what they’re given as their assignment, which is why it’s important for the leader to take out some time and briefly discuss with the employee so they aren’t making any more mistakes and can improve. While job-hunting on Indeed.com, I came across with a security job entry-level position. As I reviewed the company’s review, an ex-employee left a comment claiming that there are no feedbacks from the manager. The leader won’t pay attention to you unless you make a mistake.…

    • 1356 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    When management began to tighten their standards, they tend to start having negative behavior and feedback. The workers will start to wonder if their jobs are being jeopardize. According to C.E. Davis and E. Davis, standards are expectations which are rules, characteristics, and guideline that define a particular level of performance. (Davis & Davis, 2014) Workers are required to follow rules in any business.…

    • 789 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Resistance to Change Paper Resistance to change is referred to the act of opposing or dealing with issues which is a common conflict for the managerial staff. During the improvement phase, many organizations experience resistance from their employees. The issue is not how resistance occurred but the results of the change it cause to the organization. The resistance to change typically cause behavior issues for employees when change is implemented. When this issue manifest the following concerns occurred within the workplace, such as productivity, job performance, quality products and services, and interpersonal relationships.…

    • 1386 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    They both need to be solved soon due to their undesirable effects on work process. “Your biggest problem is you can’t get enough employees to keep up with your work. Your absenteeism is high as well as your turnover. You keep telling management that you need to become a more employee-oriented employer, but they are stuck in “their normal” rut.” (How To Solve the Turnover Problem). Repeatedly turnover problems can cause unwanted issues in the workplaces, that’s why it needs to get solved presently.…

    • 998 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    A chain of command, which is defined as an order of authority and power organized, would usually be the answer to a majority of problems in the workplace. The issue is that when the chain of command fails or treats certain employees unfairly, not many other options are available. That is why whistleblowing is done, to fix issues as a last resort. Employees risk their jobs by going to the media and expressing the issues they deal with their workplace. Loyalty is clearly shown when an employee wants to fix an issue within the company, while they are still employed by the company and risk losing their position.…

    • 1554 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Administrative Leadership

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages

    This leadership style is more emphasized the team 's decisions and allows them to take the lead in determining the objectives and methods of those which would be achieved. As a member of the team, I could feel that the leaders left the employees without a clear direction, supervision and coordination. Furthermore, they forced the employees to create a plan, then implementing and evaluating it without a clear standard. In this model the employees were required to have sophisticated ability, skill and experience since the leaders did not make the rule of job description and rarely made a relationship with the employees. In some cases the Laissez Faire leadership style could cause frustration admit the employees as the lack of guidance from leaders.…

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays