Madeline may have never existed to begin with because she appeared very so often and when she did nothing was hardly said. Poe states “While he spoke, the lady Madeline (for so was she called) passed through a remote portion of the apartment, and without having noticed my presence, disappeared” (876). When Roderick wrote the letter to the narrator, he told him that he was suffering from fears and nervousness, which maybe the reason he never left home causing him to be isolated (Poe872-73). Roderick may be in fear of his sister coming back to haunt him, which is why he is suffering and his illness is getting worse. Madeline may have had supernatural powers because when she appears at the end of the story, the house crumbles into the tarn as soon as Roderick is killed (Poe 884). As Roderick and the narrator were reading the story everything started to happen to them and the house, therefore Madeline may have just been a hoax all
Madeline may have never existed to begin with because she appeared very so often and when she did nothing was hardly said. Poe states “While he spoke, the lady Madeline (for so was she called) passed through a remote portion of the apartment, and without having noticed my presence, disappeared” (876). When Roderick wrote the letter to the narrator, he told him that he was suffering from fears and nervousness, which maybe the reason he never left home causing him to be isolated (Poe872-73). Roderick may be in fear of his sister coming back to haunt him, which is why he is suffering and his illness is getting worse. Madeline may have had supernatural powers because when she appears at the end of the story, the house crumbles into the tarn as soon as Roderick is killed (Poe 884). As Roderick and the narrator were reading the story everything started to happen to them and the house, therefore Madeline may have just been a hoax all