Electoral College Faulty

Superior Essays
What would have happened if four presidents that have long since been entered into the history books had not been the ones elected? In 1876, 1888, 1960, and 2000, the popular vote and the Electoral College did not elect the same candidate. However, the Electoral College had the final decision. The latest discrepeancy between the two voting systems revived the debate about the best election method. George C. Edwards develops the argument about how the Electoral College, with a faulty system detrimental to democracy, should be replaced with direct election.
The Electoral College fails in protecting American citizens and candidates. It does not protect minorities or third parties. Many times the votes of the minorities do not affect the
…show more content…
There is a balance between power of the states and power in the system that the founders created. If we get rid of the Electoral College, we will have to get rid of the senators. This would cause the country to become closer to the direct democracy that ancient Greece first had. However, this would cause the United States to move from a Republic to a Democracy. Yet, the founders did not build the United States to become a Democracy. (http://www.thisnation.com/question/011.html )Therefore, his view of every person having a direct vote to the president is invalid. The Electoral College is a large reminder of this difference. This institutionally, is not different from our method of electing representatives or senators. We elect representatives to vote for us on laws and issues as we vote, in essence, or our electoral representatives. Therefore, his argument that America’s democracy is in jeopardy is …show more content…
By voting the people can elect new representatives, senators, or even presidents to replace one that did not follow through with their agenda. Through the fear of not being elected once again, the elected officials will be more inclined to listen to the people. Between the people and government, this is the largest check and balance. When the system of electing becomes skewed against the people, it is a major cause of concern. The country was built on certain principles, and the people have a right to exercise these rights. The Electoral College, as this author believes, will destroy this major check and balance. What impact does this have on his view of the broader institutional setting? The system is not one of equality. Democracy should be where every vote and person’s opinion matters. However, in the Electoral College, the only votes that matter are where population is extraordinarily low. Also, when the people’s popular vote does not match the electoral winner, then the system fails. Therefore, the people’s choice does not matter. This causes him to believe that the institution is failing as a democracy.
There are two major limitations to Edwards’ argument. His bias is very noticeable throughout the book. This causes his support to become weakened since his is not providing a more balanced approach. Secondly, the United States was not built to emulate Greece and

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    How would you feel if your vote in deciding the next president of our country didn’t matter? Well, this is true for many people due to our broken Electoral College system of voting. I strongly feel that we should get rid of it for many reasons. My first reason is that it doesn’t give equal representation to certain states. My second reason is that it doesn’t match up with the popular votes that were taken by the people.…

    • 507 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Negative Effects of the Winner-Take-All Method In the current US election system, citizens do not directly vote for their next president. Instead, a group called the Electoral College carries out that function. Citizens cast their votes and those votes are tallied up by state. Once tallied, the Electors, also known as Representatives, of the states place their votes. Each state has a certain amount of electoral votes.…

    • 1088 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This is because over the course of time, popular votes have been lost along the process of the electoral system. Presidents such as Rutherford B. Hayes did not receive a majority of the popular vote. Hayes won 47.9% whereas Tilden received 50.9%, but Hayes still became president through a 185 to 184 vote in the electoral college. (Longley and Neal, 32) Another reason I believe why the Electoral College should be eliminated is because there is a possibility to increase the overall voter turnout. There is a possibility that more citizens would use their right to vote if they know for certain that their vote matters and makes an impact.…

    • 1995 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Citizens make up the state, so if you do not have citizens you would not have states. Then if we were to get rid of the Electoral College; then the candidates would pay attention to other states more than they do now. They are more worried about the winner take all system that they ignore the state they already know their vote for them. Which disenfranchises voter who supported the losing candidates. This system favors some citizens over others, which denies some people their choice of president.…

    • 984 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Electoral Process needs to be Reformed The election process in the United States is flawed and has caused serious controversy in past elections on whether or not the process is fair. First, the states all have equal representation to their House and Senate members. Secondly, the election process was set up for the lesser populated states versus the largely populated states. This amendment should be ratified because the Electoral College takes the power away from the people, does not allow a voter to vote for the candidate directly, and will help third parties compete fairly in elections. Some people argue that the election process is working just fine for the United States.…

    • 1095 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The concept of a representative democracy is flawed and will continue to be flawed because someone’s opinion will be left out. This does not mean however, that representative democracy cannot work. Many countries, including the United States, have managed a representative government quite well. It is only now that people are talking about changing the system of representation because a state of gridlock is occurring. Both major political parties in the United States are refusing to work together to solve problems.…

    • 1459 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    More people would be encouraged to vote if their votes mattered and had a larger impact in the goings-on in their country. Our current system also encourages a two-party system that stops any third-party candidate from having a chance. It is extremely difficult for a new or minority party to have a chance at winning the presidential election. This system forces those candidates to either join the two main parties or give up (Kimberling). Even though some third-party…

    • 1339 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Critics of the Electoral College question the secureness of the system. Many dwell on the possibility of the Electoral votes not reflecting the nationwide popular…

    • 1664 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The media’s role in legitimizing the Electoral College is due to the polarizing effect of public opinion. People who identify with a particular party, may in fact be apart of various interest groups. Their ability to influence politics is tied fundamentally to the founder’s warning regarding factions. Madison in Federalist 10 mentioned that the creation of factions is “sewn in the nature of man”, insisting that it would be inevitable for special interests to arise and partition society. The influence of these groups would need to be controlled despite the fact that Madison had not predicted that they would not be powerful enough to dominate the government due to so many checks and balances implemented into the federal system.…

    • 1757 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The electoral college has been in place since the preamble of the constitution. "The Electoral College is a process, not a place. The founding fathers established it in the Constitution as a compromise between election of the President by a vote in Congress and election of the President by a popular vote of qualified citizens. "(Office of the Federal Register 1) This nationally recognized system has been a topic of controversy. Some U.S. citizens believe that it is unfair, while other argue that it is the only way to choose a president.…

    • 505 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays