Argumentative Essay On Tracking In Education

Improved Essays
Since the late 1990s, a weaker version of the tracking system of education used in Europe has gained popularity in much of the United States. Tracking is how schools separate students based on academic ability and achievement into small groups or classes. This system separates the so-called above average students and places them into more advanced classes. It also places students who perform below-average in less difficult classes. Students are placed in classes only with students who are on the same track they are on. The tracking system of education was originally used in the United States around the same time large numbers of immigrants started moving to America. At this time, students who were in schools were either native students who …show more content…
Many believe labeling students from a young age is harmful because these stereotypes stay with them for the rest of their lives. Students on the lower ability track often do not receive a quality education the way students who are considered high ability do. Also most of the students on the lower ability track are from lower income families and minorities. The main argument for tracking in education is that high ability students should not be slowed down so other students can keep up with them. However, the biggest problem with tracking is the most experienced and qualified teachers are often placed with students on the high ability track and not the students who actually need skilled teachers to succeed. (Loveless) Another major problem with the tracking system is the way students are viewed by their peers and teachers. Students who are placed on the lower ability track are often made fun of and ridiculed for not being as gifted as their peers. Students who are placed on the lower track often have a fixed mindset, believing they cannot achieve what their peers can. The tracking system makes students in the lower track lose confidence in their own abilities. This attitude ultimately affects their overall performance. Sometimes there is too much pressure placed on students who are considered high ability. Students who are tracked into the higher track spend most of their life fighting to be the best. This can motivate people to do great things, but failure is inevitable and can damage someone who is used to being the best at everything they

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Standardized testing has been a method that has been implemented into the school systems in order of them to be able to measure a student 's achievement. While in some cases the students come out on top, but more often than not a lot of students are left behind due to their inability of the attaining their school systems standards. The school system 's ability to measure students achievements needs to change in order for the school systems to be more successful. For a long time the upper/middle-classes have generated the highest test score on standardized testing, while leaving lower income classes falling short. Most standardized tests are created to cater to the middle/upper-classes.…

    • 1601 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Many minority and low socioeconomic status students face this inadequacy, believing they are naturally unable to succeed in school. This self-image often persists in the minds of students, even when offered the opportunity to move up in the tiers. Yonezawa (2002) studied how students would react to an attempt at eliminating the barriers between academic tiers. Given the freedom of choice, African American and Latino students in the low tier actually resisted entering high tier classes. A simple explanation is that these low tier students believe themselves to be placed correctly in the tier they can succeed in academically.…

    • 1795 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Crucial Calculation

    • 1343 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Their health are in risk of danger, just because they are worried on what grade they will get. Pressured students usually have no assurance if they will pass the subject or not, because honestly, some pressured students did not learn anything because they are forced to study just to get the grade that they want. It’s either “passing grade” or “high grade”. Their only goal is not to fail. As I have said, the student’s potential hides in their subconscious, which is why a dense environment may subject them, to learn in their consciousness,…

    • 1343 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Those students’ daily lives are extremely complicated; they are unrecognized, isolated and often have a variety of unhealthy characteristics which contribute to anxiety. These students’ education system should change in order to better assist them. By identifying the gifted using characteristics such as level of motivation and not academic scores and offering gifted services which give them a challenging, accepting atmosphere, the neglect of gifted students will end. All these gifted students require, like all human beings, is recognition and compassion. Ending those stereotypical myths and granting these students what they deserve in their education is not too much to ask in the twenty-first century, especially when the majority…

    • 774 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Often successful, highly accomplished students are treated differently than others because they are not vulnerable. Many students feel their stress comes from schools, teachers, homework, parents. Few people realize that the source of pressure is not from others, it comes from yourself. The intense competition will give a lot of people's pressure because of the competition winning or be losing, it affects your life. Pressure source comes from…

    • 1263 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If a student didn’t perform well on a test and has poor grades, The charter school denies them access and only enroll top performing students, which then gives the illusion that they’re “outperforming”. To make matters worse, they also decline disabled students and will and steer them away towards other schools with more special education programs since they’re more expensive to educate. Often times when a student does end up being accepted, the education they will receive will not be any better than that of a public school. The for-profit schools, that many students end up in, also don’t care about student success. One charter schoolteacher reported that during her teaching career, the school would have many teacher parties and refused to buy basic classroom supplies even though they made much money off of tuition alone and student success continued to struggle even more.…

    • 1071 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The demands of high­school are causing stress levels are becoming dangerously high. We as a society need people to not fear the “real world” but to welcome it with the confidence of having all the knowledge that will be needed to succeed. Many students are dropping out of highschool due to the fact that they no longer feel that they are being taught what is essential to live, this is one of the main reasons that students are feeling stressed. High­school students are now showing higher stress levels than adults and there are few if any signs that schools are working on reducing the stress. Most if not all high schools students have experienced stress or anxiety during testing causing a huge negative impact to their social and…

    • 1405 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nclb Act Persuasive Essay

    • 1473 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Lawmakers may think that this is the best plan because it allows students the opportunity to take a chance at receiving a quality education. Although a majority of these students are behind, these children should be given a chance to have qualified instructors to teach them. “The ruling sent district and state officials scrambling to prepare school systems to receive students transferring out of unaccredited [districts]” (Zubrzycki: “Mo. Transfer Law”). Other school districts dislike this law because these incoming students have lower test scores; therefore, these students bring the school average down.…

    • 1473 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Standardized tests creates a lot of bad stress on the students, which is not healthy for the students and will also have a negative effect on their performance as well. The pressure to do well on test cause the teachers to change their structure of the curriculum to the tests then helping the students to gain real knowledge that will help the students to succeed in life. Many students are very smart but have a hard time taking tests. Most students will take them longer time to study and prepare to take the standardized test and still come up short in getting in to a college they like. Taking the Standardized test requires a lot of money because it can take students multiple times taking the tests to get a good score to get into their favorite college.…

    • 1075 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Obtaining Good Grades

    • 1628 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The majority of students all over the world strive to receive what they deem “good” grades. However, it has reached a point that students abandon learning to achieve them and succeed in life. Therefore, the immense amount of pressure society puts on students to obtain good grades detracts from their ability to learn. Students have many misinterpretations about their grades, particularly what they represent and their relationship with learning. For example, they often mistake long-term learning and course grades as equals (West and Carrell).…

    • 1628 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays