Does Texting Affect Writing By Michaela Cullington Analysis

Improved Essays
The article of concern here is Does Texting Affect Writing? by Michaela Cullington. The research paper examines the effects of texting on students’ academic writing. In Cullington’s findings, she concludes that texting has a minimal effect on writing.
Cullington starts her argument through the introduction of texting which she then correlates to TextSpeak. Consequently, she uses the topic of TextSpeak as a bridge to voice a few concerns against her argument. Throughout her paper Cullington examines the effects of texting on academic writing in the form of TextSpeak to which she claims, has a minimal effect on student’s writing.
To champion Cullington’s argument, she then states her methods of research. She goes into extensive detail accrediting her methods and sources. After explaining each of her resources, she claims there is a time and place to use TextSpeak, and academic writing is not one of them (Cullington Page). Cullington had come to the conclusion that students could decipher when it was an optimal opportunity to use TextSpeak, and therefore there had a minimal effect on academic writing (Page).
Cullington summarizes her findings while adding her own personal anecdote. In
…show more content…
Regarding research, many experiments require a large pool of subjects that are varied and random. In the case of Cullington, her first mistake was her relatively scant sample size of nine humans. While this could have been overlooked, her second mistake was that she also failed to produce a random, unbiased audience. Cullington tries to justify her sample by proclaiming that her subjects were some of her “closest and most reliable friends" (Cullington 366). Consequently, as most people understand, close friends do not form an unbiased result making her methods of research

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    The basis of Michelle Cullington’s article, "Does Texting Affect Writing" has been viewed as a hot topic throughout the academic community. Cullington’s article pieces together inquiries from professionals in the academic sector, opinions from individuals in which her topic applies, and conducts detailed analysis of collegiate papers - searching for signs of "textspeak" to generate the research basis for her claim (361). Though her works ' effort was published in numerous journals, the structure of her article allowed for both her message and credibility to falter. Inadvertent contradictions and poorly executed research created holes for her readers to see through--allowing for her ethos to come into question.…

    • 1120 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    (366) Conducting her own research allows Cullington to build up her own points and express her finding to add to the discussion of the argument. These aren’t the only places she proves her own credibility to the topic, her essay Does Texting Affect Writing was approved by the Young Scholars in Writing, an undergraduate journal of writing published by University of Missouri-Kansas City (361). Any paper published in a journal would had to go through testing on its credibility and factual statement, moreover, it was published by a university. Given her action, analysis, and acceptance by the undergraduate journal committee, Michaela Cullington is credible and is reliable to talk about this subject and its information…

    • 847 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    While many strive for technological advances, others are worried that technology can take over cognitive skills in human beings. From watching television to strolling on the Internet, humans are starting to depend too greatly on technological devices and are losing the importance of the malleability of the brain. Because we depend too greatly on technology, people will start to lose the concept of face-to-face interactions, enhancement of relationships, critical thinking processes, and writing abilities. Michaela Cullington’s neutral perspective on technology in his article, “Does Texting Affecting Writing,” gives a plausible argument: that texting has minimal effect on students’ writing through their awareness of knowing not to use the “texting language” in their formal papers. I argue that people should not use text messages as the main source of communication –since texting affect negatively towards young students’ ability to write a concise, formal paper due to the excessive use of…

    • 931 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    They also claim that the frequent writing of, and exposure to text absent of punctuation is negatively impacting grammatical accuracy. Another point used to defend texting having a negative impact on writing is revealed by teachers expressing their displeasure of finding text speak in formal writing assignments. The defense is supplemented by teachers providing their own experience; one teacher explains that she had to give explicit instruction, to her students, not to use text speak in formal writing. Cullington researched several external sources, positions, and arguments. However, wanting a more intimate understanding of how texting influences writing and to formulate her own opinions on how she perceives texting to affect writing, she decided to conduct her own research which included interviewing several of her close, but diverse friends, as well as two former teachers.…

    • 704 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In John McWhorter’s TED Talk “Txting is killing language. JK!!!” he asserts that despite what many believe, texting is not, in fact, killing the written language. McWhorter concludes that texting is akin to the written version of casual speech. That rather than replacing formal writing it’s like new dialect, simply diversifying the complexity of language.…

    • 838 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The article “Public Thinking” by Clive Thompson is piece of work that argues against the idea that technology, social media and other types of digital informal writing negatively affect societies writing abilities. Thompson argues in favor of these digital writing methods and completely goes against these accusations by arguing that the digital writing methods actually end up helping the development of writers within our society. The article actually appears to be written in order to inform people about the benefits of this “digital literacy” while also addressing the flaws in the arguments against digital literacy. He formulates his article to support his argument through his constant creations of claims and counterclaim. Thompson makes…

    • 1615 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    They believe that students tend not to take the stress on punctuation while texting, so students tend not to use punctuations like “commas, apostrophes, and even capital letters to begin sentences” (Cullington 363). Some teachers started to take points off, if students used any abbreviations in their paper (Cullington 363). By doing this, students can learn to use appropriate words in the papers instead of abbreviations. Students will learn from their mistakes once teachers start to be strict with them. There could be a positive view-side of…

    • 1189 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Tyler Perry Book Report

    • 1418 Words
    • 6 Pages

    I tend to take a break half way through a paper watch a movie or eat dinner then I’ll go back and finish my paper. This way I will get a different view of th e topic and also it will give me better ideas for me to write about. In Michaela Cullington’s Does Texting Effect Writing article, she talks about how texting actually can have a good effect on writing because it makes you get creative to find new ways to get your message across on what you are trying to say. She states, “Texting also helps to spark students’ creativity, these authors argue, because they are always coming up with new ways to express their ideas.” Also it can be a benefit because it gets people motivated to write because they are already constantly texting.…

    • 1418 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A person who drives a car on the highway while he or she is texting will cause serious danger. When people talk together while a person is texting, it is impolite. Students who text during their school time will impact their attention to courses and finally impact their writing skills. On the contrary, Michaela Cullington, in her essay “Does Texting Affect Writing?” insists that “I can confidently state that texting is not interfering with students’ use of standard written English and has no effect on their writing abilities in general” (370). However, she is mistaken because she overlooks the facts that texting is a stumbling block of students to becoming good writers by wasting time and distracting students with narrow audiences and informal…

    • 832 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She also explained in many ways opposing viewpoints on how different sources and teachers viewed texting whether good or bad. Furthermore, she included occurrences where one source said one thing about texting affecting writing but added opposing detail to contradict what they previously stated. Lastly, Cullington mentioned other literary devices to help support her argument such as rhetorical questions, binary oppositions, imagery and so…

    • 840 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I hypothesised that all the teachers were going to say the same thing; that texting is what makes our writing terrible. Surprisingly this hypothesis was wrong. I asked my current history teacher for his opinion and he had no doubt in his mind that texting has the most impact on our writing. That with his students he see the use of short text and incomplete sentence very frequently. Strongly disagreeing with him, I asked to see some examples of this.…

    • 1098 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sarah: “Hey!! College is sooooo gr8!! I t stop there, she does her own research to find that “textspeak” and informal writing has not impacted students’ ability to write at all, and if anything, informal writing is giving students the opportunities to practice their writing skills more often. One big difference between all of these authors’ opinions is the outcome of this change.…

    • 711 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Technology has vastly improved how we go about our daily lives. From the early civilization days of handwriting letters to someone to now, when we can send that same message to the person in a text message, faster than ever before. It seems now, almost everybody in the world has a cell phone, computer, and possibly multiple ones per household. Technology has helped improve the standard of living in America. With the rapid growth with technology, is there a price to pay?…

    • 1013 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Michaela Cullington’s article, Does Texting Affect Writing, Cullington talks about the debate of texting affecting students writing. The writer uses many sources to back up both sides. Many teachers agreed that texting does inflict bad habits on student’s writing. Other teachers insisted that texting helped with student’s imagination and creativity while writing. In this article Cullington also involves the students themselves by asking them questions about their texting habits.…

    • 756 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    That perhaps the taboo of technology creating a dumber generation is in fact a misrepresentation. This is explained when Lunsford expresses that, “Young people are for the most part aware of the context and audience for their writing” (Lunsford 572). In other words, students are choosing on their own free will to alter their writing style. That the decision to not use proper punctuation or sentence structure isn’t because of the effects of technology, but more of a deliberate and calculated decision to express one’s character. It is further explained that regardless of the various types of writing styles, ultimately students are learning more through what she called “life writing” or writing outside of school curriculums.…

    • 980 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics