New Deal Success

Superior Essays
Before Roosevelt and his innovation of the New Deal, America was in absolute chaos. Compared to many of the countries in Europe, America did not feel the burden of WWI. In fact, she prospered greatly, lending money to many nations. However, that good fortune ended abruptly, beginning with Black Tuesday and worsening when the banks went bankrupt and closed, taking along much the the citizens’ money. The current president at the time, Herbert Hoover did nearly nothing, trying to adhere the the laissez-faire economic policy that the US had followed prior. Knowing better, Franklin D. Roosevelt threw the federal government into healing America, forming his different plans into a cohesive New Deal. Despite the fact that the New Deal did not end the …show more content…
Up until 1929, America’s GNP rested around $100 billion. However, in 1933, during the height of the Great Depression and near the end of Hoover’s presidency, the GNP decreased by nearly half, to $55 billion. Nevertheless, by the end of the Roosevelt’s New Deal and the beginning of WWII, the GNP rose back up to $85 billion, an astronomical increase considering what Roosevelt had to heal (Trueman). Some intellectuals who deny the success of the New Deal point to the year of 1928, when the economy recessed, commonly called the Roosevelt Recession. They claim that if the New Deal was entirely successful, then that huge recession should not have occurred. However, these critics fail to address the reasons why the economy dropped during that time. After constantly spending and printing money to help the economy recovery, Roosevelt underwent some doubt in his methods. He feared inflation and the huge federal deficit, so when the New Deal administration advocated cutting down federal spending, Roosevelt supported it. Clearly, the results proved disastrous, the economy taking another sharp turn. Fortunately, as soon as Roosevelt realized his mistake, he acted quickly in reviving the economy, and proved successful (Woolner). Essentially, while the economy did plummet sharply during 1938, the New Deal itself and the programs within it did not fail. It was the administration and Roosevelt 's initial oversight that caused the recession. If anything, the New Deal helped the economy quickly recovery after the Roosevelt Recession, proving its success. In addition, during the decade of the Great Depression, the average GNP did increase exponentially, showing that the New Deal did succeed overall in helping to heal the

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    The New Deal was for the most part limited, it did not in any way, set America on the "Road to ruin." If anything did put America on the road to ruin at all, it was the depression itself.Roosevelt's strategy was probably better than any other plan for the United States at this current time. This is because it not only stopped unemployment rates from rising, but even saw them decrease. By forming the Emergency Banking Relief Bill, Roosevelt erased the depositors fears of losing their investments, due to the fact that all operating banks were licensed by the Treasury Department. The public gained confidence in the banks, and Roosevelt had successfully suspended the citizens fear and implemented his programs.…

    • 1034 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Home mortgages were financed with ARM's. The 1st couple of year’s home mortgages were affordable, but when the interest rate adjusted upward, the house payment doubled or tripled, resulting in foreclosures, causing housing prices to plummet. The effects were unemployment, people losing their savings, in commercial bank deposits in 1929 and in retirement investments in 2008. Also frozen credit, home foreclosures, business and bank failures, a long, drawn out recovery, more government involvement and regulations in the private sector. Differences are, in 1929, agriculture and livestock commodities were way over supplied, and many of the stocks on Wall Street were bought on margin.…

    • 701 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hoover's Economic Changes

    • 951 Words
    • 4 Pages

    He employed an opposite strategy to Hoover's plan, which was to focus on supply through a form of trickle down economics. Roosevelt's Democratic programs set the basis of other social programs . He was also successful in reforming American capitalism to prevent the continued subsidies given to businesses instead of the working class. The New Plan did not bring America out of the Great Depression altogether. The top 10% between 1919 through 1939 owned nearly 45% of the share of wealth, and this gap between the rich and the poor was an imperative source of hardship for most Americans during this time.…

    • 951 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The New Deal Dbq

    • 1073 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The congress declared many of the bills unconstitutional, and did not pass them. Even though the New Deal improved many things and forever changed the country, it failed to achieve its main goal: ending the Great Depression.7 The New Deal caused the American people to solely rely on the federal government and look to them for answers to all of their problems. It completely took away the ingenuity and creativity of looking to his or her own community for help, and destructed the opportunity to begin community relationships. Everything started to become government owned, and made it increasingly difficult for small businesses to begin. Despite all of these flaws in the New Deal, it built a dominant new political alliance, and created structural stability and social security that underlay a postwar economic boom.…

    • 1073 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    President Herbert Hoover’s reasoning behind the depression was due to Americas the international economic situation. As a result of World War 1 the international economy was weakened, and only functioned as long as American banks exported enough capital to allow European countries to repay their debts to America and also continue buying American goods. On the other hand it was almost impossible for European countries to repay our banks without their own economy going bankrupt. Rather they relied on payments from Germany and Austria to cover their debt, even though they would never get reimbursed because Germany and Austria were in worse debt than anyone else. Late in the 1920s American companies began to slow down production, they reduced their purchases of raw materials and supplies from Europe; a result many European economies were weakened.…

    • 805 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The government had a great effect on how bad the economy was during the Great Depression and Great Recession, but the government, both then and now, imposed taxes and poured money into the failing economy. The Presidents both had similar ideas to put money into the economy and pass bills that would hopefully save the economy, but it could be argued that the Federal Reserve did a better job during the Great Recession. During the end of both the Great Depression and Great Recession the economy slowly returned to its previous state, but we did not go to war after the Great Recession. There are disputable similarities and differences in the Great Depression and Great Recession, but the government did learn something from the governments past…

    • 933 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Franklin D. Roosevelt abandoned previous President of the United State Herbert Hoover’s fear of the refusal of deficit spending. Borrowing federal money and abandoning a balanced budget was necessarily for Franklin D. Roosevelt to pay for his public work projects and human relief programs. The Recession of 1937 had to happen in order for Franklin D. Roosevelt to realize he needed to control the country’s budget once again. Programs like the AAA and the NIRA only temporarily fixed the economic problems. However, in the end the Supreme Court declared them unconstitutional and refused to have the programs funded as they had little use to the economy in the long run.…

    • 1111 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In this essay I will argue that the economic depression got the Nazis to a powerful position in the Reichstag, however when the economic depression declined the amount of votes that the Nazis obtained also decreased in the Reichstag elections. Therefore the economic depression did not make Adolf Hitler Chancellor but other main factors including the oratory skills of Hitler, the propaganda campaign of Goebbels and the fact that Hindenburg and Von Papen thought that they could control Hitler once he was Chancellor. The smaller extreme parties also would not work together although combined they could have had more support than the Nazis. The Treaty of Versailles also contributed to Hitler’s rise to power as the German people were still angry…

    • 1947 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This is because businesses no longer wanted to undertake long-term investments when profits would be taken away from the new taxes. The political climate created by the New Deal discouraged investment and prevented Gross Domestic Product from increasing to its potential. The New Deal also created policies - such as the National Industrial Recovery Act and National Labor Relations Act -intended to restore full employment. However, these policies allowed firms to collude to keep prices high and the price floor the government created to keep wage rates from falling caused the supply of labor to exceed the demand for labor, and thus, relatively high unemployment…

    • 1559 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    President Franklin Roosevelt and President Herbert Hoover were more different than they were similar. They both tried to stop the Great Depression. They also were looking for new ways to make America a better social and economic country. Nonetheless, President Herbert Hoover's popularity was falling as voters felt and he was unable to reverse the economic collapse or deal with prohibition. His policies during his presidency were ineffective causing unemployment reaching as high as 25-30%.…

    • 330 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays