Summary Of Andrew Gelman Blue State Poor State

Improved Essays
The premise of the book Red State, Blue State, Rich State, Poor State by Andrew Gelman is to explain the divided red and blue color map that represents the way states vote in elections, Republican or Democratic. Throughout the book, Gelman presents substantial data, numbers and graphs, to show the voting trends of individuals, counties, and states as a whole. Analyzing all this information, Gelman reveals that how an individual votes relies on many factors that interplay with each other producing numerous different outcomes and that one of these factors alone cannot accurately predict the voting tendencies of individuals, counties, or states. As Gelman thoroughly explains, rich people tend to vote republican and poor people tend to vote democratic, …show more content…
I had already know that large cities tend to be liberal, that poor people tend to vote more liberal, that the coasts tend to be more liberal. I honestly think the reasoning behind those facts and data graphs is that those places tend to have a higher rate of diversity, more of a cultural melting pot, and a higher focus on politics since big cities have more of a say and thus want to participate, are usually involved more in politics. I also disagree with Gelman’s argument that older people are more involved in politics than the younger generation. While I do admit that previously, the younger generation was not involved in politics, I believe that increasingly young people, like me, want to be involved in politics and are seeking out opportunities starting from a young age. Young people now are growing up in a generation where it’s hard to avoid becoming political when important issues such as climate change, hate speech, and mass shootings are affecting our generation most. We are the generation which grew up in a society where hate speech is common, where mass shootings that kill many innocent people are becoming normal to see on the news. Our generation is in the process of learning that our voices matters, we can make a difference, and that there are people out there, politicians, who will listen to …show more content…
Democrats can draw the lines so that Republicans don’t receive any congressional votes even if they hold a fair share of the population’s support. Just recently, there was a Supreme Court Case that was based on a dispute of congressional district drawings and whether or not they were drawn based on a product of racial discrimination in Texas. The argument is that the way the district lines are drawn in Texas, it doesn’t provide black and hispanic voters an equal voice and representation and provides white people with a stronger voice and say in government. Though I felt like Gelman brought up interested and accurate data and arguments about how individual vote, I felt like he didn’t talk enough about how it doesn’t really matter how individuals vote if towns, counties, districts, and states can essentially void some of the voices in the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Chapter three, in the 5th edition of American Government: Your voice, your future, is about how public opinions, attitudes, and beliefs are established and used politically. Chapter three also touches on polling and its use in the political system, government power, and the differences between liberalism and conservatism. As stated in the text, Americans do not share the same concerns when it comes to how involved the government is in everyday living. Statistics offer a closer look at how these differences vary depending on race, sex, and demographic. Specifically, when it comes to the difference in opinion between the sexes, a clear viewpoint is displayed.…

    • 610 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    When states need to redraw districts after every census, it is often up to state legislatures to figure out the lines. Within limits, the state legislatures can draw the districts however they see fit. The basic requirements from the federal government are equal populations in each congressional district, and compliance with the 1982 Voting Rights Amendment. The Voting Right Amendment prohibited both discriminatory intents and effects when drawing district lines, and allowed for the creation of majority-minority districts as a method of remedying discriminatory effects. Most other considerations – such as a desire to make districts geographically compact – are based on state laws.…

    • 1524 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    With the next census coming up in 2020, the United States will have to analyze areas where that population has either increased or decreased and redistribute the electoral districts accordingly. Unfortunately, this will result in some form of gerrymandering to sway voting populations for either Democrats or Republicans. After the 2016 elections, it seems as those redistricting had be in favor of the Republicans so they can reclaim areas that they…

    • 1429 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    When political scientists look at voting behavior and political beliefs, they often turn to people’s upbringings. When looking at this, one area often studies is the environment where people grew up. This means the city and state of a person’s upbringing. While many say that the most effective way to influence political beliefs is through those closest to a person, the geography of where they grew up cannot be ignored. States in America vote for presidents, not people directly and this provides an avenue of people to see how those around them feel and in turn how they should feel about politics.…

    • 1333 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    People don't get a choice about who they want representing them as a country, which is the whole opposite of what being a democratic country means. Their voting for a reason and should be able to have a say in what's going on in the government. But sometimes when politicians are drawing these borders their not always looking out for the people and sometimes only care about their own political interest. For example, if they're more on the Republican side then their more lenient to drawing the district borders in a way that will benefit the Republican party. Which doesn't respect the wishes and desires of the voters, and allowing this to happen is not what democracy is about.…

    • 558 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In The Week article “How to rig elections, the legal way”, The week staff describes how parties gain an advantage by redrawing voting districts. This process of redrawing voting districts to favor one’s political party is considered gerrymandering. It creates districts that are irregularly shaped and is a legal process unless it violates the 1965 voting rights act which makes it illegal to redistrict based off of minority voters. Gerrymandering has been successful in recent years because in 2012 gerrymandered states such as Pennsylvania won 49% of the vote and took 72% of house seats. Redistricting is overseen by whoever controls the state legislature and happens every ten years with data collected from the recent census.…

    • 383 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In addition, redistricting and gerrymandering are used to promote political parties such as the growing dominates Republican Party. The elections are now more based on unfair gerrymandering, interest group funding, and campaigning rather than the politician. Therefore, the voting right act, unfair campaigns, and gerrymandering can dilute minority voters and their voice in…

    • 484 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Today in America, our youth are taught that the right to vote it one of the most important rights we have. It can help us shape our future as a country. But what if this cherished belief weren’t true? There are those that argue that a single a single person’s vote cannot make a difference. But are they right?…

    • 998 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gerrymandering Case Study

    • 1042 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Most people believe that the outcome of elections in Texas is decided by the voters, but in our current single-member district system of electing representatives, frequently that is not the case. Often times who will win in an election is decided long before election day, usually by those who draw the district lines. For example, if the districts in texas are drawn to be 65 percent republican then the outcome will most likely result in republicans that have the majority of seats in the legislature. In a single member district system, only one member can be elected to congress for each district, that is why drawing the district lines is by far one of the most important aspects for a party to win seats. The parties assure their representatives…

    • 1042 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this sense, proponents argue that the process “somehow preserves federalism or small states ' legitimate interests” (Edwards 2005, p. 11). One concern of the democratic process is developing methods for maintaining equal representation across all states despite their size. Imbalances due to the weight given to states, the potential for the winner to lose the popular vote, and disproportionate advantages are all cited as major failures of the Electoral College in adhering to democratic principles. Proponents for direct elections cite these implications as a source of criticism of the current system. The national attention on those states that have the variability for political competition can cause an imbalance in issues that candidates consider (Grofman & Feld, 2009).…

    • 1854 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Electoral Vote Dbq

    • 389 Words
    • 2 Pages

    There is so much information in this chapter that it is hard to know where to begin. Four times the electoral vote and the popular vote were not the same, three times in the 1800’s, and then in 2000. The author states that he is in favor of the popular vote winning rather than the electoral vote. There is good reason that this is not the way we elect our leader, and he chose not to share that with his readers. Since most of the population are centered around cities, and in some cases very large cities (New York, Chicago, Los Angeles etc.), these major populous areas could, and would pass laws favoring them, while rural area’s would not have a say in the matter.…

    • 389 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The majority of the youth in California have not been active and turning out to vote, while the state and county elections greatly affects them. Elections and votes result into what the future of California will look like and its citizens, which is the youth’s and college student’s future as well. The question I aim to research and write on is, why not turnout to vote if they care about their personal future in California? There is a large population of youth and college students in California, while the voter turnout in elections continues to decline rather than increase. I aim to research this puzzling question and make an argument on this phenomenon.…

    • 168 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gerrymandering is the process of drawing congressional districts in a way that favors one political party or interest group. These partisan officials like state legislatures and state governors often use three different gerrymandering methods to give their own party’s candidates an electoral advantage. Strategies of partisan gerrymandering following 2010 census has had a huge impact on gerrymandering on the U.S House election results in 2012 and 2014. According to Gerrymandering Plus Ohio, a pdf document posted on Blackboard Sacramento State SacCT, the three gerrymandering methods were packing, cracking and kidnapping.…

    • 777 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    According to a political article published by the New York Times, unemployed citizens are twice as likely to want to vote for candidates who support unemployment benefits. Wealthy caucasian men are more likely to oppose income redistribution because that would mean taking money from them making them less rich which they do not want to be. The idea is that Democrats and Republicans are very different. As stated before, many favor policies that protect minorities and liberal ideals. Republicans lean towards the opposite.…

    • 199 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Political Polarization “The unanswered question of American politics in this era is whether our divided political system can function in times of stress” (Ezra Klein). Our political system is comprised of two parties with opposite views on important topics. When the representatives of these parties experience more constraint to vote towards their party 's stance on issues they are less likely to compromise and therefore get less accomplished.…

    • 1188 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays