The Drama Of The Gifted Child Analysis

Superior Essays
"The Drama of the Gifted Child", by Alice Miller, is about a youngster who had such a powerful urge to satisfy his guardians wishes, that he lost himself and his own character. It is about a kid who never truly got the chance to find his actual self. The greater part of his youth was comprising of satisfying his guardians wishes that he never got the opportunity to get himself and his own character on the grounds that he has dependably been to caught up with satisfying others. The book comprises the wishes of the guardian being regularly unknowingly offered on the kid, with the child taking in these wishes and transforming into another person. Full of helpful ideas, this book appears to accuse and control circumstances keeping in mind the …show more content…
She cannot yet see through her mechanism of self-deception" (57). Here, Miller is examining the capacity to purposely experience torment as a grown-up, instead of experiencing a cycle of disillusionment, concealment, and depression. Unlike the child who plans to please and whose "pretentiousness" covers all disappointment, the grown-up has the opportunity to face "reality" and experience torment, in the occasion, as opposed to putting it off to feel later. It irritates me that Miller attests this-that she says, with certainty, a child "cannot see through their own mechanisms.” I believe that is out of line to use as a noteworthy point, on the grounds that I think numerous grown-ups additionally can't see through their own mechanisms. Many grown-ups have security systems that make them feel better, and numerous grown-ups misdirect themselves for this same reason. While it's helpful to assert here that a kid does not have the capacity to recognize this instrument, the fact is debilitated by her not recognizing that numerous grown-ups do not have the capacity as well perhaps it's harder for the kid to see, however I would think the grown-up may have a more grounded will, and with that, a more grounded refusal to recognize what he doesn't wish …show more content…
She says, “He is not really himself, nor does he know or love himself…” (63). Here, she is discussing the "skilled kid", who, subsequent to growing up so agreeable with the wishes of his guardians, regularly endeavors to revolt, however this is still not "himself",since he his opposing something that was not him either. I think the terms of "acting naturally" or "not acting naturally" are decently useless. How does Miller know to begin with, if this truly isn't himself, or in case we're bound to be sure individuals at all? Maybe regardless of the possibility that we follow up on our guardians' wishes, assimilate, unwittingly, their cravings and follow up on them-perhaps that is exactly who we are, and possibly that is the only thing that is in any way important who we are in the moment. Miller contends that we're in trouble by stifling our more normal longings to satisfy people around us, yet perhaps that "misery"- in the event that it exists, is just human impulses and emotions we have to feel keeping in mind the end goal to be human. Similarly, Miller expounds on "when a patient begins to experience his own feelings and can recognize his own needs" (93). Again, I don't think she can know regardless of whether somebody is encountering, or has been encountering, his or her "own" sentiments and "genuine" needs, or regardless of the fact that they too exist by any stretch

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Rewarding for good is not a bad thing, but it is completely different when a reward is given for not being bad. One should not seek to do good just because the reward. Modern discipline has become so dependent on rewarding that the children have become very shallow and have no deep understanding of morality and values. In traditional discipline a child grows up to become self-disciplined and grounded in a foundation of absolutes. The leniency that is most often found in modern parenting styles may create an adult with more self-entitlement than self-discipline.…

    • 1388 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    A common belief about people with ADHD is that they are outgoing and do not succeed in school. While one person may have difficulty learning, another could be successful, often times making it harder to discover any signs of distress. Many perceive that children with ADHD are considered “wired” but they do not realize that these children have a disorder and the symptoms are often disregarded (Kidshealth). People frequently judge those with ADHD when they are not treated because they do not know how to be in command of their actions and mentality. Although there is no known cause of ADHD, it is common for people with this condition to have a parent diagnosed or having been exposed to prenatal substance abuse (KidsHealth).…

    • 2346 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The kids do not have anyone to love them, and that might hurt the child in the future as they might be hardened. Though this form of parenting seems awful, it’s not all bad. There are some pros that the other styles can not offer to its extent. Crystal Lombardo from http://plantingseedsbook.org/ talks about the Uninvolved style. She reveals a truth that other articles did not present, “ kids, even at a younger age, are able to learn how to be responsible in life and be able to grow up without depending on their parents.” This is a very interesting idea that I never thought about.…

    • 1162 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I Listen To My Parents

    • 739 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Parents often neglect the power they wield, both slowing and confusing a child’s development. Neglecting moral issues leaves the youth clueless to interoperate issues and prevents them from forming moral guidelines. Parents conflicting morals further confuses and hinders a child’s understanding of right and wrong. However, parents who invest in moral discussion aid moral understanding and development in their children. The many influences children encounter leave them venerable to moral misunderstanding, so a parents responsibility to morally educate their children becomes immensely…

    • 739 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this world there is a diversity in the human behaviour. Some people show good manners and character, whilst others do not. However, what is often forgotten and to some extend taken for granted, is that a great person does not immerge out of now where. It is through care and nurture from the parents that conditions the child’s willingness to show kindness and respond positively to discipline. Yet the arts of parenthood cannot be taught or understood by everyone, and results to an imbalance in the parenting, where it is either too loose or too uptight.…

    • 1019 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Also incomplete information in the mind of the child promotes irrelevant thinking and fantasizing, which is wrong in the long run for the child. Let me quote one example here, a couple who has decided to separate, conceals this information from the child who is the worst impacted party. But the child senses, and asks questions for which he/she is not told the facts; or will be told the lies. Ultimately the child is going to know the facts, so why not make him aware at the right time, at the proper place. Let him face the facts and realize the situation.…

    • 957 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Ingoldsby And Shaw Summary

    • 1193 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Internalizing is expressed as jealousy from not receiving as much attention from one parent as a child would like to receive. Finally, there is cognitive deficit which is described as more of an academic and peer issue that children may have. In today's society, we show only the perfect families but we fail to realize every family is not perfect and some people have to go to trials in life. The essay at hand explains a myriad of ways that stress can impact a child, and even though you may not see it, it is still…

    • 1193 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Teenage Independence

    • 783 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The honest truth is that at this stage in their development you can’t. A major piece to growing up is learning to rely on your own feeling, self-control, and understanding as opposed to someone else’s. Adolescents are beginning to create their own path and will only rebel if you force them to accept others standards and beliefs. Control will only lead to power struggles that will negatively affect the relationship. Some parents will argue that there is a need to control their adolescent because they haven’t experienced the world yet and therefore does not possess the ability to know what is best for their future.…

    • 783 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Adversity is a factor in every person’s life, but not everyone is lucky enough to possess resilience. Resilience is the ability to prevail when faced obstacles in life. There are many methods people use to gain resilience, and there are many reasons why people cannot, but one reason why people never become resilient is because they live a life with unsupportive or detrimental parents. Elizabeth from the short story “Jericho” by Margaret Price and the boy from “Untitled” by Anonymous are key examples of this idea. This principle is also supported through the opposite scenario: When parents are supportive towards their children, the children tend to be resilient.…

    • 1112 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Alice In Wonderland Theme

    • 1441 Words
    • 6 Pages

    It reaches out to children with its childish overtone, but reaches out to those who can spot the mature undertones. Lewis Caroll chose this odd setting to emphasize the true madness children see the adult world as. Growing up is a difficult task everyone must face. At first it might seem like a frightening path of never fitting in, being challenged by authority, and at the end of it all, it seems like you’re going to lose your head. If you’re willing to adapt and grow, then this scary Wonderland is no different than your reality…

    • 1441 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays