Analysis Of Peter Elbow's 'The Doubting Game And The Believing Game'

Improved Essays
“Highly unlikely, but not outside the realm of possibility”-David Duchovny. This familiar phrase from the popular nineties television show “The X-Files” manifested itself in my mind when reading the article that profoundly influenced the University of Central Arkansas’ Honors Program, Peter Elbow’s abridged version of “The Doubting Game and the Believing Game—An Analysis of the Intellectual Enterprise (Excerpts)”. Though on a much more theatrical and improbable level, this show relates to the Honors curriculum and Elbow’s paper with the same basic, parallel theme: doubt verses belief. In keeping this mindset, we can see: how Elbow’s proposal differs from “critical thinking” today, what can be assumed about the nature of truth and human intellectual …show more content…
To see how his proposal differs, we must first reiterate the term “critical thinking”. Critical thinking can best be defined in the dictionary as “the objective analysis and evaluation of an issue in order to form a judgment”. The key component in this phrase is “objective” meaning you do not depend solely on the mind for existence, but rather facts. In this case, your mind and feelings play minuet roles. Emotions are closeted in order to make a non-biased and correct judgment. In Elbow’s theory; however, emotions are encouraged. The doubting game, though seemingly similar to critical thinking, is indeed contrasting. When using this form of thinking, you are asked to look for error and essentially “doubt” a situation’s truth. In like manner, the believing game requires you to explore all possible assertions without limitations or “believe” that other possibilities are plausible. Though either thought process will produce success, Elbows proposals differ in the fact that they stimulate the thinker on a logical and psychological level while critical thinking emphasizes logical thinking …show more content…
One idea that fervently sticks out in my mind is when I participated in Lincoln Douglas debate, specifically on a case that questioned whether or not national security should increase within the United States. I, being at the time on the side of negative debate, heard my opponent’s case. I listened intently and pondered each of the points made, not disproving but simply imagining each and heard her side to the debate. I came to the realization that her case was persuasive and logical. Only after I had given the opposed a chance could I then truly find the fatal flaw and stand assured in mine. I had the option at the time to use Elbow’s “doubting game” in that scenario, like so many young debaters do. I could in a sense put blinders on and look for only error within the case. This process, though it may be triumphant elsewhere, is a weak form of attack in the debate realm. By choosing to use methodical belief, I ended up winning that particular round. I surmise that had I decided on the doubting game, the same results would not be probable. It is from cases like this one and many others that methodical belief has taught me to always keep an open mind to another individual’s ideas, a way of thinking that has carried over into my everyday

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    At the core of the University of Charleston’s (UC’s) curriculum, there are six critical abilities called Liberal Learning Outcomes (LLO’s) that must be demonstrated by the students before graduation (Liberal Learning Outcomes). Certain, if not all, classes are built with these factors instilled in their foundation in order that each student can achieve these specific skills. Coupled with UC’s mission statement which expresses how this university strives for each student to achieve their full potential, they provide beneficial tools for students to use in their careers.…

    • 1352 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Graff then reveals the logical conclusion behind his adolescent story, “I see now that in the interminable analysis of sports teams, movies, and toughness…I was practicing being an intellectual before I knew that was what I wanted to be” (383). Through the analysis of street smart subjects, Graff discovers the basics of critical thinking. Thus, Graff is living proof that street smarts have intellectual depth. This in turn, reinforces the reader’s earlier insights and solidifies Graff’s argument by molding credibility with logic.…

    • 1385 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Burger, A. J. (2001). An Examination of ‘The Will to Believe’. Retrieved October 6, 2017, from http://ajburger.homestead.com/files/book.htm Corbett, B. (1980). The Will to Believe.…

    • 1184 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The act of actively combating our inductive bias in Kathryn Schulz’s Evidence in Kathryn Schulz’s essay, “Evidence”, the argument of the essay follows various situations brought up by Schulz, showing that people should take a positive approach to being wrong, and accept our error-prone nature, rather than obsessing with a perfect inadvertently-free ideal. Schulz ties together a lot of strong evidence, but fades back from a clear conclusion, steering the readers toward a relationship between error and the self. She further studies moral transformation on conversations, our attachment to a view wrongly identified due to our pre-conceived opinion off prior experience. Schulz stresses that in order for us to improve our relationship with to evidence,…

    • 990 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Elbow's Argument Analysis

    • 700 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Elbow goes on to say that a healthy intellectual process will actually utilize both games alternatively to produce the best results. The believing game and the doubting game can work together like Yin and Yang to generate a broader and deeper…

    • 700 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In a place where media is as mainstream as reading, is there a decline of intelligence? Is there even plausible proof to deterioration of American intelligence? Mark Edmundson, author of “Who Are You and What Are You Doing Here,” and William Chace, author of “A Question of Honor,” both give their reasoning to this decay of intelligence. Both Edmundson and Chace examine the ways in which colleges and universities play a key role in the problem of “anti-intellectualism” in America. Mark Edmundson informs his readers of his beliefs that college is only the beginning.…

    • 1279 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mike Rose, the author of “Blue-Collar Brilliance,” argues that intelligence is not something that is defined by formal education, but rather the use of critical thinking and experience. In his essay, Mike Rose uses a plethora of examples ranging from personal experiences, historical examples, and visual content to support his assertion. The argument that education does not equal intelligence leads to an important question: how can intelligence defined and quantified? Mike Rose disputes the notion that blue-collar jobs are simple and mindless in his essay.…

    • 1000 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If students and teachers continue to host debates which pit students against each other, society will continue to foster ideals of arrogance and unhealthy competition. Furthermore, the idea of the “doubting game” that society unconsciously plays fosters the idea of cynicism. With agonism in education, everyone is a skeptic, which contributes to society's inability to adapt to new theories and ideas. By pushing for more discussion based arguments like Tannen suggests, society can progress with new ideas.…

    • 885 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    As is stated on his website “davidabanks.org”, David Banks holds a PhD in Science and Technology Studies From Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute among other degrees. In today’s society one might think such accomplishments would naturally give his thoughts the value of being credibly and eagerly shared. Unfortunately, this is not the case when criticizing the work of such a charismatic speaker as Sherry Turkle as he did in his article “Make Conversation Great Again". In an age where delusions are sold to the first bidder only to be later recognized as “fake news”, is real thought failing us because it’s not being sold?…

    • 1528 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Have a Little Faith by Mitch Albom is an excellent book about faith. The author has a great experience and a master’s degree in journalism, which gives him the skills to write books. Additionally, as a child, his schools and university were religious, which gives him the knowledge to write about faith. Tuesdays with Morrie, The Five People You Meet in Heaven, and The First Phone Call from Heaven are just three of the 42 books he has written. Furthermore, this book has great points about life lessons and faith, but these three are the most important to me: money could be used in different ways but it does not determine happiness, getting to know people, and giving second chances, and accepting all different religions.…

    • 1782 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    In Clifford’s “The Ethics of Belief,” Clifford argues the immorality of believing without sufficient evidence. In most situations, Clifford’s point of view would be practical; if we wish to be true seekers of the truth, it would be unethical to ever believe in something without sufficient evidence. This is a valid statement, but there are exceptions to this idea which are dependent on the situation. When it comes to the type of evidence presented, a belief can be justified or found to be wrong. Clifford sets two questions we are to ask ourselves when it comes to believing things that aren’t proven with physical evidence, rather shown by testimony.…

    • 1624 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This same idea stretches into business classes where the believing game is also commonly needed. There are situations were all your options are going to be correct, whether you're deciding on methods of investment in personal finance or choosing which system of depreciation is best for your business in accounting management. Because these classes have adjusted my thought processing, I can recognize when believing is superior to doubting, like when choosing what literary devices to write about in an AP essay or having educational debates. This understanding will help me outside of my academics as well with simple things like voting and finding a solid line between practical and…

    • 800 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He believes that society has a responsibility not to let our passions, prejudices, or emotions interfere with our evaluation of evidence. In the paper “The Will to believe”, James argues that there are situations in which believing with insufficient evidence is sometimes acceptable. James says that our beliefs have consequences but sometimes there are situations when it is better to act…

    • 361 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Postman believes that schools are trying to avoid the upheaval that comes with critical thinking, going as far as to say that “ a free-thinking populace might reject the goals of its nation-state” (160). In other words, he’s saying that people who know how to think critically are harder to keep under control. He also addressed the concern that an education in skepticism may not work by countering with the idea that “there’s no guarantee that anything done to or for children in school works” (160). Some may have reservations anyway, but Postman wants to try for it.…

    • 1100 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Critical thinking is not only a process, but a skill that develops over the course of a person’s life. Dr. Linda Elder, the Assistant Director of the Center for Critical Thinking, created a stage theory of critical thinking development that defines critical thinking into six stages. In reference to the article by Linda Elder and Richard Paul “Critical Thinking Development: A Stage Theory,” I believe that stage four, the practicing thinker, best represents my development as a thinker. As previously mentioned, Dr. Linda Elder’s stage theory of critical thinking development consists of six stages. In stage one, Linda Elder argues that a majority of people begin heavily embedded in this stage of the “unreflective thinker.”…

    • 1046 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays