The Body In Hegemonic Masculinity

Improved Essays
Disabled bodies are represented in various different ways, most of which are not in line with the traditional views of masculinity. Opsteyn (2015) argues that a lot of literature infantilizes disabled men, referring specifically to post-war writing to exemplify this. The reliance on others to perform tasks that are positioned as normal by able-bodied discourse is viewed as not only emasculating, but infantilizing. This image of the disabled male as childlike is one that remains dominant and is reproduced in various media representations of disability. Another popular representation of the disabled body in dominant discourse is one of asexuality. Shakespeare (1999) offers the idea that most popular media representations of disability focus …show more content…
As discussed earlier, the use of the body in sport plays an important part in characterisation of the quintessential masculine figure. Lindemann and Cherney (2008) argue that the the physical sport of wheelchair rugby, as well as the hyper masculine sporting culture that surrounds the game, subverts the assumptions of the function of the disabled body. The players in Murderball view their sport as a way to challenge the expectations of the disabled body as passive, infantile and unmasculine that are so prevalent in current hegemonic discourse. The language and conversations that revolve around the sports field between athletes (for example in locker rooms and sidelines) are a hugely important part of masculine identity (Wellard, 2009). Lindemann and Cherney (2008) point out that the on and off court conversation in wheelchair rugby players is akin to that of able-bodied athletes. They use this to argue that the on-court practice of the disabled body in quad rugby, as well as the off-court conversation, contribute to the hegemonic discourse of ableism and reinforce the standard form of heteronormative …show more content…
The drive towards hegemonic masculinity is not automatically absent in physically disabled men, as has been suggested in popular media representation. Although these men are often unable to express physical masculine behaviors in the same way that able-bodied men do, the ways in which they challenge the discourse of able-bodied masculinity align with the reinforcement of hegemonic masculinity rather than subvert it. This is done through the formation of gender identity through the devaluation of other oppressed social groups, such as disabled women and ‘lesser’ forms of masculinity such as homosexual and intellectually disabled men. Heteronormative ideas about sex, as well as values surrounding violence and the sporting body are present in the language and conversation employed by disabled men. While the culture of disabled sport, especially wheelchair rugby, disputes the passivity of the disabled male body, it does so in a way that reinforces the ideals of aggressive, sexualised

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The essay’s diction evolves from a sense of empowerment to decisive, a mark that Mairs utilizes her power. Amidst other possible words for her condition, Mairs sticks with “Cripple,” hailing it as both “Straightforward and precise,” as well as having an “Honorable” history. Following that, she juxtaposes the definitions of other labels alongside, such as “Handicapped” or “Disabled,” and presents her adversity to each. Shifting to a tone that suggests disgust or perturbance, Mairs compares the semantics of other labels to other emerging…

    • 391 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In the essay "Disability," by Nancy Mairs and film "I'm not Your Inspirations," by Stella Young, both topics examine and analyze the positive and negative stereotypes of disabled individuals in mass media. According to Mairs disabled people are portrayed as victims to act weak and helpless in popular television. On the other hand, Young stated, "media has sold the lie that disability is bad and exceptional" because of this people are misled about the diagnose of someone's disability. Rather than being misled by the media or becoming becoming helpless victims, both Mairs and Young presented an argument for the media to represent physically challenged individuals as "normal" in popular…

    • 110 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Masculinity In Murderball

    • 907 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Rubin and Shapiro’s inspiring documentary, Murderball, associates with the notion of “masculinity” as expressed in Cynthia Barounis’ “Crippling Heterosexuality” by zeroing in on the combative habits of a quad rugby player, the essence of the sport, and the relationships of the players with their significant others. Murderball illustrates the game previously known as “Murderball,” now referred to as wheel chair rugby, and the experiences of Team U.S.A. and Team Canada to the 2004 Paralympics. It can be discussed that the reason for creating this documentary was to reveal the amount of rivalry that occurs between people with disabilities or how their lives have been changed from having to be in a wheelchair. As we watch the film, the continued theme of the movie is that if you believe in…

    • 907 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mairs adopts an urgent tone as she explores why the media should represent the disabled community because not only it will affect the disabled, it will affect the “able-bodied.” She points out how one can become disabled “involuntarily, without warning, at any time.” People, therefore, will have an easier time, mentally and physically, if “we insert disability daily into our field of vision: quietly, naturally, in the small and common sense of our ordinary…

    • 703 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Summary Of Masculinity

    • 1618 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Gender roles and performance are often the first visual cues many people have when meeting another person. This seems to have been a primary concern for many young gay men in Lawrence and Ames. Members of society discovering they are queer based on their appearance and mannerisms. In Lawrence a young gay man wrote a coming-out story in the Vortex that discussed his struggle not only with homosexuality but with his effeminacy. He said for many people it was his rejection of masculinity that was the hardest to grasp.…

    • 1618 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This paper explores two recent articles, ‘Tough Girls in a Rough Game’ written by Mary Celeste Kearney (2011) and ‘From Riot Grrrls to roller derby? Exploring the relations between gender, music and sport’ written by Adele Pavlidis (2012), which focus on female athletes in roller derby and how women are subjected to patriarchy in sports. This essay compares how both of these articles discuss patriarchy and gender norms. However, the articles differ, in how Kearney (2011) discusses how women are represented as dramatic and sexualised in the television show, Rollergirls; whereas, Pavlidis (2012) explains how roller derby, in reality, empowers women. Kearney’s (2011) article focuses on an American television series, Rollergirls, and the way it was produced and promoted (p. 284).…

    • 2100 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Rhetorical Analysis “Disability and the Media: Prescriptions for Change” In the media, there is a controversy on how the media portrays a person with a disability. Charles A. Riley II, article has a pointed view on how the media acts, and how they need to change their ways on viewing the world of disability. Riley writes this article to get his point across to the world that the media needs to be changed.…

    • 1320 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Masculinity In Hockey

    • 1276 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In a city of ten million people, one sport was able to create an identity for its inhabitants, and represent what it meant to be a proud fan of their local team. The sport is Ice Hockey, and the city is Chicago. In the city of Chicago, people always enjoyed going to sports events, but it wasn’t until the Blackhawks became a hockey powerhouse that the city realized what it meant to be a true fan. Because of this sport, the people of Chicago were able to form their identity and be proud of a team they had fostered. In the creation of this fandom, specific trends in the way people act are evident, which distinguishes them from other sports fans.…

    • 1276 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Hegemonic Masculinity

    • 1855 Words
    • 8 Pages

    The term “patriarchy” has been used to describe the social system of men holding the power and authority. Since the 1960s, feminist are working hard to spread the awareness of how patriarchy system related to the inequality treatment existing in both genders (Cranny, 2003). It is argued that different sectors in the world such as labour force, education, politics and more has been undergoing a domination of male, known as “hegemonic masculinity”. Since this phenomenon of hegemonic masculinity has been deemed natural, ordinary or normal (Donaldson, 1993), various actions and thinking are seen to favour masculinity characteristic, or in this case, men. Raewyn Connell describes the situation of masculinity favouring situation as “patriarchal dividend”.…

    • 1855 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For example, Disabilities such as learning impairments have a high dependence on professionals, people with effective social roles or expertise, that exercise authority to affect the quality of vulnerable lives. Most with disabilities experience prevalent disempowering labels such that self-identity is contradicted by the attitudes of others. In Connecting Lives (The Open University,2014a) Stephen Sweetman is familiar with the stigma, labels and constraints in society thus at first, rejects the identity of having a disability. This emphasises on how important people’s bodies can be in the connections people make with the places they live despite having lasting relationships and how can this be disrupted when people's body change.…

    • 750 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Boyhood Organized Sports

    • 775 Words
    • 4 Pages

    “Boyhood, Organized Sports, and the Construction of Masculinities” written by Michael A. Messner discusses the sense of identity placed upon boys at a young age that coincides with sports. Messner interviewed former professional athletes to understand the masculinities of sports on a more micro level. His article argues that organized sports are gendered institutions that are only there to make boys more masculine. This article argues that point very well though displaying the experiences of the retired athletes and how they became interested in sports, though his study may be considered a bit outdated in this day and age. Messner’s research from 1983 to 1985 came to the concussion that most American men did not considered boys men until…

    • 775 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Feminist Disability Study

    • 1491 Words
    • 6 Pages

    From my previous class on disability narratives, I learned of feminist philosophers such as Susan Sontag, Rosemary Garland-Thomson, Anita Silvers, and anthologies like Feminist Disability Studies and Gendering Disability that have done a large amount of work on invisible disability, the language used when describing those who are disabled, and the relationship between gender and disability. In addition, numerous queer theorists, like Eli Clare and Alison Kafer, have expanded on disability studies to include queer disability theory, which has helped demonstrate the interconnectedness of these disciplines. I mention these various scholars to emphasize that these are not new ideas - academics have recognized the important relationship between feminist theory and disability studies. The concern is the lack of widespread…

    • 1491 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    By portraying people as successful in spite of their disability mainstream media is expressing that people can only be accepted if they do their best to be “normal”, as defined by the majority of an ableist and discriminatory society. This perspective is different than that of disability activists as acceptance of disability is a prominent feature in many writings as something that needs to be done for progress to be made. Rachel Robertson demonstrates the effects of this in her piece as she describes how she has “become a kind of cross-cultural translator” (145) for her son and the world they live in. Due to her acceptance of her son and his differences she can play mediator in a society that doesn’t accept him because he’s not normal and doesn’t conform to the portrayal of disabled people in the media. The unrealistic expectations that the billboards set make it difficult if nigh impossible for disabled people to achieve, and because they don’t achieve these expectations society doesn’t accept them because they are viewed as not working hard enough to be…

    • 1003 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the movie, Million Dollar Baby, Maggie a female boxer finds herself without a coach, but works out day after day in the gym to prove herself. This movie shows how females are capable of doing anything males can do. In todays world the female rose has changed dramatically, especially in areas such as sports. Modern society has an altered view on female athletes, some misconceptions including the controversy between female and male roles, females having masculine qualities that are not ideal and that there are only certain sports they can participate in. While some believe women should always follow the traditional female roles, nowadays it is common to see dominant females participating in all levels of workforce, including athletics, there are also many stereotypes given to female athletes critisizing their abilities.…

    • 1240 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although women are ‘known’ for being feminine and soft, yet they can be good at sports. Nowadays in the 20th century, female discrimination continues to spread through the American society. Females in the US continue to be viewed as the "weaker sex", and inescapably this mentality continues to impact women in the American society. Discrimination of women in sports has increased over the years causing several effects on them; developing numerous psychological problems, developing health problems, and changing their physical appearance. But is it true that women can’t play rough, masculine sports just because of their gender?…

    • 882 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays