The Dilemma Of Diversity In David Brooks's People Like Us

Improved Essays
David Brooks, who is a successful journalist, columnist, and self - described “comic sociologist” at The New York Times, communicates the dilemma of diversification in his expository essay “People Like Us”. The writer thinks that people should encourage diversity to perceive and esteem each other 's different reflection. David Brooks demonstrates why all different kinds of humans are attracted to identical and similar races, ethnicities, religions, beliefs, political values, and classes in his essay based on typical examples surrounding us. Author’s convincible thoughts give interesting questions to readers include me, and it makes us reflecting and considering one more time with the necessity of diversity in not only America but also the global …show more content…
According to Brooks, Americans aware, and understand that the U.S. consists of various races and beliefs, but they do not carefully consider, and believe the necessity of diversity. “What we are looking at here is human nature. People want to be around others who are roughly like themselves. That is called community”(Brooks 309). The author of this essay asserts this interesting phenomenon with human instinct. This event to live, dwell, and settle with the similar people can be understood by analyzing human’s behavior of natural inclination. Because people crave to converse and share their emotions and opinions with corresponding people, Brooks argues, “Geography is not the only way we find ourselves divided from people unlike us. Some of us watch Fox News while others listen to NPR...Americans tend more and more often to marry people with education levels similar to their own, and to befriend people with backgrounds similar to their own”(Brooks 308). He shows particular cases of how people find similar characters in this quotation. However, the author also warns and notifies against this situation, which is human grouping with similar people, who have identical ideas. Personally, I feel bad about my un-diverse life at these points. I think all my American friends can sympathize with this view, which Brooks said in his essay. People, who live …show more content…
At the end of the essay, the author said, “Maybe you should stop in at a mega-church. Sure, it would be superficial familiarity, but it beats the iron curtains that now separate the nation 's various cultural zones”(Brooks 310). People need to experience with other beliefs such as different views of opinions and dissimilar kinds of considerations for the deep understanding diverse side of the ideas. Familiar materials and ideas can comprehend easier than unfamiliar thoughts. A society and community with many ideas can help to contact, understand, and reflect various viewpoints of people, who live in that group. For example, joining another club, going another church, experiencing different kinds of new ideas, and concepts. The author of this essay, David Brooks, also explains that beginning with new little suggestions such as ‘do not think about the enormous plan’, and ‘focus on the few valuable new understandings’. Unfamiliar, and puny experiences became significant understanding and esteeming minds after the countless tiny different practices. These kinds of his solutions make me feel compelled to seek solutions such as ‘what is the realistic way for me to make healthy diversity surrounding myself?’ or ‘how college students like us can create community, which love diversity in college?’ The essay “People like us” gives question marks to every reader include me, who read

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In Flemings City of Rhetoric, he attempts to explain how the geographic landscape impacts and influences us to shape our political beliefs and who we are as people. Fleming first focuses on the ways political ideology developed and how those ideologies effect our relationships. Our political beliefs “group” us together (Fleming, 22). It makes sense. Many of the friend’s people make have similar ideologies, beliefs, values, and morals.…

    • 449 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article “People Like Us,” columnist David Brooks uses first-hand accounts and statistics to outline various scenarios in which he claims America extols the virtues of diversity, while the country’s regions and neighborhoods instead provide an unvarying framework for life. He asserts that the modern American is now free to move about the country without old-fashioned ties to original support networks (career steadiness, family, faith roots, etc.), yet even in that geographical freedom, one infrequently branches out far from racial familiarity or one’s other, existing comfort zones. The individual may resettle their family in a new city or state, but studies show one attracts, and is attracted to, others who believe, behave, buy, vote,…

    • 239 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the introduction to his book, The Trouble with Diversity: How We Learned to Love Identity and Ignore Inequality, Walter Benn Michaels introduces his views on why diversity has come to be more appreciated than in times past, as well as his main point and goals for his book. Michaels organizes his introduction with an approach that allows a reader to fully understand his goals for the book, but uses a style of writing that may prevent an audience without extensive knowledge of the subject to fully grasp the meaning of Michaels’ message on diversity. Michaels begins his introduction by discussing The Great Gatsby. In which, a penniless man, Jimmy Gatz, transforms into a rich man that is an epitome of the American values of the 1920’s but is still unable to win…

    • 685 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Midwest, a place in the world where communities are closely aligned to one another. These small, rural communities rely on every person in order to create that community. It seems as though that knowing everyone around the small communities was what made a person successful in life. Additionally, these communities valued hard-work and honesty when it came with almost everything they did in their lives; whether it was working in the farmlands or spreading information throughout the communities about certain people to look out for, it was hard to be anonymous inside the city. Unfortunately, there are sometimes citizens that do not look forward to that kind of lifestyle.…

    • 1476 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In spite of decades of diversity policy and practice, America is in many ways more divided than ever when it comes to issues of identity. Critics from the political left argue that we simply need more diversity to overcome the division, while critics from the political right argue that diversity has devolved into an unworkable set of unfair entitlements that are themselves the cause of the division. Understanding the Misunderstanding, the first part of the four-part series Ourselves Among Others: The Extravagant Failure of Diversity in America and An Epic Plan to Make It Work, explains the sources and causes of the social divide in America, and also shows how neither the political left nor the political right have understood the problem or…

    • 303 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Super Diverse Communities

    • 1468 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Zach Chaudoir English 1120 Matthew Goldberg December 1, 2015 What Super Divers Communities Could Learn From Outcast United In the book Outcast United, by Warren St. John, we see how rapid demographic changes in Clarkston led to a vast array of culturally confusing and incendiary moments, but through the establishment of social connection became the training book for working with super diverse communities. The book focuses around an assortment of adolescent refugee boys brought together from an extensive arrangement of ethnic background through the game of soccer, and how their female coach, Luma Mufleh, impacted their lives and their families. This book guides us towards the inescapable truth that in order for super diverse communities to…

    • 1468 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Brooks seems overly passionate in his tone: "we must collectively devise a means to overcome this 'societal mess,' ultimately to revive 'the American identity'"(Brooks). His well analyzed ability to outline and rhetorically summarize his persuasive argument, collectively, from such a wide abundance of relevent current issues is one of the reasons the article itself is so effective at communicating and speaking to such a vast audience on an emotional level. In the entirety of the article, Brooks makes reference to a multitude of varying ethnic and cultural identity groups, including but not limited to: Latinos, Muslims, African-Americans, Republicans, Democrats, Anti-semites, Jews etc. Inevtibaly what most of these cultural identities also carries is one form or another of stereotype or negative conotation within American society as a whole and with that, controversial and emotional debate. Collectively, all of the cultures have in common, a heavy emotional emphasis as a reader within identifying and discussing these cultural differences amongst each other, especially in regards to the context in which the author outlines them.…

    • 1282 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    America is composed of diverse groups of religions, ethnicities, and languages. However, largely apparent is the discrimination, controversy, and hostility between groups. Disagreement between individuals within the same town, within the same neighborhood, provokes discord and dismisses the harmonious concord Thomas Paine speaks of. While his characterization of America’s cultural makeup remains true today, Thomas Paine’s characterization of the country’s social interactions is wildly inaccurate.…

    • 652 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The debate, “Does America Cherish Diversity?” has a great popularity, and has brought a great deal of unique opinions. Patel believes that America cherishes it’s diversity, and McGregor does not think America cherishes it’s diversity. Our class overall believed that America does cherish it’s diversity, but I'm writing this to tell you my opinion not theirs. My opinion on the matter is that America does not cherish it’s diversity, and they should not have to, but they should respect other’s diversity, and others should respect their diversity from them. There are many reasons I believe America does not cherish diversity.…

    • 502 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Introduction Good or bad diversity is present all around us. Diversity can be a positive aspect to society because it can offer a variety of objects, ideas, and people into the world. People need to be accepting of diversity because it is has a variety of good functions to provide to a society. However, diversity can also cause issues because not everyone in the world is accepting of differences. This does not make diversity bad, but rather shows that people need to be willing to embrace differences.…

    • 2524 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    His point is that people unconsciously choose to interact with others who share some common features with them…

    • 1440 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Appiah, writer of Cosmopolitanism: Ethics in a World of Strangers and Michaels, writer of The Trouble with Identity: How We Learned to Love Diversity and Ignore Inequality both had different personal views, opinions and arguments when it came to the topic of diversity. Michaels argues how we are more focus in race and cultures and avoiding the real problem, economic inequality. Meanwhile Appiah acknowledge diversity in a more positive way and explains that the best way to approach diversity is by Cosmopolitan because, we will get to learn from our differences and embrace them. Appiah and Michaels both had arguments that went against with what the other one had said, making this discussion and analysis more interesting since the reader had both sides of the argument.…

    • 972 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In his essay, “People Like Us”, David Brooks defends his claim that the United States is not composed of those seeking a culturally diverse environment, but rather those segregating into pods of similar people, stating that, “what I have seen all around the country is people making strenuous efforts to group themselves with the people who are basically like themselves” (Brooks). I agree with this statement, as I myself am guilty of this and tend to gravitate towards those who I am most comfortable amongst and who I feel I can be my true self with. For instance, I tend to spend time with people who enjoy the…

    • 808 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Bruni uses the term “clannishness” to illustrate how people in the United States separate themselves from one another by conforming into certain groups with specific ideologies (1). These divisions lead to issues in diversity, despite there being distinct groups, because there’s a constant sameness in these groups and a refusal to understand the ideas of others. The challenge Bruni proposes pushes college…

    • 1351 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout time the diversity of the United States of America and the country’s ability tp bring people together has been hailed as one of its crowning achievements. Proud patriots of the country would boast that America is a place where everyone can achieve their “American Dream” and find the life that everyone(supposedly) seeks. While this idea sounds nice in theory, in practice, things are not always as they seem. Certain authors, like Whitman, celebrate the United States of America for its diversity and for the vibrant culture where he believes that all can be interconnected and prosper. Meanwhile, other authors, such as Allen Ginsberg are skeptical of the boastings of true diversity and see America in a much more critical perspective in terms of its diversity, or lack thereof.…

    • 1009 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays