Analysis: Why Nations Fail

Superior Essays
Tyler Jamieson
Don Carlisle
MHIST-115-5195
19 Apr. 2015
To Fail or Not to Fail The difference between a country that is considered successful and a country that can be tagged as a failure relies heavily on its economics. Economics is the study of how people, or in this case nations, allocate their scarce resources (Economics). In every nation there is a government whose goal is to allocate the resources at hand in the most efficient manner possible. History shows that the governments that have accomplished this goal have been the most successful. Why Nations Fail, written by Daron Acemoglu and James A. Robinson, highlights the recurring similarities and differences between successful and unsuccessful nations. Acemoglu and Robinson explain
…show more content…
Acemoglu and Robinson would describe the American economic institution as inclusive. “Inclusive economic institutions foster economic activity, productivity growth, and economic prosperity (75).” Characteristics that are found within inclusive institutions are an unbiased education system, the protection of private property and a central authority that provides public services. Nations such as North Korea who do not have these key characteristics Acemoglu and Robinson call extractive. In North Korea the education system promotes the governments own propaganda unlike the unbiased system in America. There is no such thing as private property in North Korea, again unlike America. In North Korea the government does not provide key public services like the American government but rather it is an extension of the ruling Communist Party that would rather focus on controlling its people as much as possible …show more content…
In the 1460’s much of Europe began using printing presses but the Ottoman Empire restricted the use of this technique by disallowing the use of the printing press to print in Arabic. Fast forward a few hundred years to 1800 and we see that a mere two or three percent of the Ottoman Empire was literate according to Acemoglu and Robinson. Compare that to the sixty percent adult male and forty percent adult female literacy level found in England at the time (215). Both of these examples provide evidence that stubborn societies will fall behind if they choose not to take advantage of the innovations that the rest of the world is swallowing

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    My analyzation of Richard Notkin’s piece, All Nations Have Their Moment of Foolishness was altered once I read his artist statement. The way my analysis changed was the reasons behind Jesus’ feet, George Bush, and the hooded prisoner. Further, the hooded prisoner in Abu Ghraib Prison is an image of war and destruction according to Notkin’s artist statement . When originally saw the man my first thought was that he was part of the KKK because of the hood he is seen wearing but upon receiving more information about the tile it came to be that he was actually a tortured man being watched/tortured?…

    • 414 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    North Korea is supposedly communistic but studying the actions that have taken place, it is more totalitarian like that of Anthem. When learning about their society they shut off all of the country's lights except the capital’s every night at a specific time. North Korea has around 24 million people in poverty and those numbers are still growing, according to U.S. News.com. They refuse help from any other countries and rarely allow foreigners into their country. The society is under extreme totalitarianism that the people in poverty are basically forced into that lifestyle.…

    • 616 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Laura York Mr. Reece American Government AP 25 September 2017 Contrasting Political Systems The United States of America, North Korea, and the United Kingdom all three have contrasting political systems. With different political systems, they have different decision making processes, economic systems, and the peoples’ personal freedoms’.…

    • 420 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    What is the impression of North Korea? Some people may say it's militaristic, whereas others may say it's isolated from other countries. These ideas are considered as conventional wisdom, which people can misunderstand depending on topics. Suzy Kim's book Everyday Life in The North Korean Revolution 1945-1950, and Hazel Smith’s book Markets and Military Rule support or challenge conventional wisdom. However, ways to analysis North Korea are different between two authors.…

    • 1000 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    After eleven Southern states seceded from the United States in February of 1861, and the country was one the brink of a Civil War, the rest of the world watched to see if the ideals of freedom and democracy would defeat the institution of slavery and tyranny. In Don Doyle’s book The Cause of All Nations, he explains how at the outset of the war, European nations had taken great interest in America’s struggle and ignited a division between those who sided with the North and those who sided with the South. This division involved the aristocracy and conservatives sympathizing with the Confederacy, and the liberal-minded middle class siding with the Union. The American conflict was important to Europeans because the fate of republicanism and democracy…

    • 1647 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “State failure” means “the implosion of the state” according to Bates’ article State Failure. State failure is characterized by two major processes: First, “governmental predation” which means that those in power in the state abuse their position to exploit resources from others, who lake power rather then to provide security for them. Second, the state loses its monopoly of the means of force, which leads to a militarization of society. The author then addresses three contributing factors of state failures: economy, ethnicity and democracy.…

    • 456 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Not all countries that are resource rich are successful. Countries like Venezuela and the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) are resource rich, but their GDP is really low. In 2013, Venezuela’s GDP was 438.83 billion USD, while DRC’s GDP was $484.21 billion USD. Venezuela has the largest oil reserves in the world, it’s economy should be high, but it’s not. Instead it’s economy is decreasing every year.…

    • 148 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    You use it nearly every day, whether it be to pay for dinner or to write your grocery list on but who invented this? In 105 AD Cai Lun was credited for the invention of paper, an object that would become the foundation in regards to the success of China and nations as a whole. Cai Lun made the biggest impact on society due to making paper convenient, with paper, historical documents could be written, and finally, paper is widely used in today’s society. Cai Lun thought of the idea of inventing paper after visiting a village and noticed that there was a thin layer of material left on a bamboo mat.…

    • 1076 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    On September the nineteenth an article was written about North Korean social injustices. It explains many unfair practices and laws that are different than how we live in the United States. Many other authoritarian countries live under similar rulings as North Korea. These social injustices include forced labor, poverty, access to healthcare and education, and unfair treatment in regards to race, gender, religion, and culture. North Korea has been ruled under the authoritarian leadership of the Kim Dynasty since 1948.…

    • 541 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Author George Orwell created a totalitarian society where no one knows what's really going on behind closed doors in his novel, 1984. This society, which features the main character, Winston Smith was fabricated as to what Orwell believed modern society would be like in the year nineteen eighty four and on. Though the similarities may not match up to America’s current situation, North Korea’s dictatorship does. North Korea is currently lead by Kim Jong-un whose face is plastered on buildings much like that of Big Brother, the leader of Oceania. The totalitarian style government in 1984 has many similarities to North Korea’s present form of government.…

    • 340 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In North Korea, sixty two percent of the whole population relies on either biweekly or monthly rations. Some of these people are in desperate situations, while others are not. On average, forty percent of the population urgently needs food assistance. Two thirds of the country do not have a constant meal plan and are fighting for food. This adds up to about 2.8 million people that are fighting chronic malnutrition and food insecurity.…

    • 1059 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The country of North Korea has been a very curious subject for the people of the United States countless other governments in power throughout the world. Many factors of North Korea have remained a secret over the last few decades, but some have become more open over time to the outside world. The United States and North Korea are both made up of an extreme difference in views within the power of government and also policies that follow their rule, but surprisingly share common virtues that consist of everyday life in their countries. Even the most diverse countries still often consist of many mutual traits aside from their strong distinctions.…

    • 975 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Background information on Eastern Congo Eastern Congo or Democratic Republic of Congo is the third largest and has over 75 million people who reside there. In 1998 till now, Eastern Congo had many conflicts and severe poverty which claimed the lives of over 5 million women, men and children. Additional issues such as women being victims of sexual violence and children forced to fight as military soldiers. Weak states are not intrinsically weak, or weak because of geography or colonialism; they are weak because they supply lesser or less-than-adequate quantities of political goods, or poorer-quality political goods, or both.…

    • 374 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The North Korean Famine

    • 352 Words
    • 2 Pages

    During the late twentieth century, North Korea’s governmental controls, over its citizens, were weaken. Reportedly, a famine severely engulfed the country killing approximately 600,000 and 1,000,000 civilians, or 3-5 percent of the North Korean population (Haggard and Noland, 659). Inevitably, the negative effects of the famine caused the country’s market and power to shift from companies and institutions to the general public. Therefore, North Korean’s new marketization shift enabled the general public to become too socioeconomically powerful for the state. Additionally, the marketization shift infuriated the state’s governmental officials because of its ability to generate an “independent civil society around unregulated market relations”…

    • 352 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    He notes that because of the famine people had to begin farming for themselves and their families at night, which created some level of private property where the regime wants people to have none. Furthermore, North Korea had to reluctantly allow it because of the millions who were dying of starvation as well as the amount of people who were disobeying the regime trying to feed themselves. Kang writes that “though the Party was fervently opposed to private land use, the peasant movement grew so strong that the Party had no choice but to give ground. It never changed its laws, but it grudgingly accepts the practice, and is content merely to remind the peasants that in the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea no land belongs to a single owner.” He notices that one of the biggest differences in South Korea is money and acquiring as much of it as possible is the normal, but in comparison the people in the North are concerned with acquiring enough just to…

    • 954 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays