Status Incongruity Hypothesis In The Defense Of Gender Hierarchy

Improved Essays
In line with this research, Rudman, Moss-Racusin, Phelan, and Nauts (2012), utilized status incongruity hypothesis to perform a study on the defense of gender hierarchy as it relates to backlash against female leaders who exhibit agency. The researchers highlighted the roles of prescriptive and proscriptive gender stereotypes in their first study, which served to provide the framework for their other studies. In the first study, participants completed an online questionnaire and were randomly assigned to complete one of six surveys that measured the relationship between prescriptive and proscriptive stereotypes and social status. The results from this questionnaire indicated that while men are expected to exhibit high status and agentic traits, …show more content…
Specifically, it was hypothesized that agentic women would be rated as higher in proscriptive leadership traits than men, which would negatively impact their likeability as leaders. A sample of undergraduate students reviewed information on job candidates up for a promotion, which were manipulated so that participants were either reading the letter of a male or female candidate, who were portrayed as either agentic or communal. The results provided support for the hypothesis that agentic women would be less likeable than agentic men, and seemed to indicate that women could minimize the repercussions from backlash if they handled their success in a way that diminished their agency (Rudman et al, 2012). The remaining studies continued to build upon status incongruity hypothesis, but one other important result to note was that women also had a tendency to view …show more content…
(2004) posited that individuals seem to prefer to remain in their comfort zone by having the mindset that women are less competent and achievement oriented than men, and when evidence of this is contrary to their beliefs, rather than changing their mindset, women are penalized for their success. The purpose of the second study was to extend the findings of the first study as it relates to the likeability of women in industries typically considered a male domain. The hypothesis for study 2 was that while women would be deemed less likeable in these situations, this effect would be mitigated in an industry considered feminine or neutral. Results from this study, which had the same experimental procedure as study 1, provided support for this hypothesis, and the authors suggest that this results from violation of gender norms because men were also subjected to prejudice when successful in stereotypical feminine domain. The authors were careful to point out that form this prejudice takes and the actual repercussions are likely different for men than for women, because men are more likely to be disrespected while women were most likely to be disliked (Heilman et al., 2004). The third study explored the likeability factor in more depth, specifically as likeability relates to potential rewards. This sample included working adults, and a 2 x 2 x 2 factorial design was utilized to measure and compare the sex of the employee, their perceived competence, and levels of

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Myth Of Gender Inequality

    • 124 Words
    • 1 Pages

    Gender inequality is not a new tendency on this decade. “Gender difference is the most ancient, most universal, and most powerful origin of many morally valued conceptualizations of everything else in the world around us” (Sandra Harding; 1986).Although the movements that had been created in many countries in order to stop this phenomenon of gender inequality and to move in a gender-neutral attitudes concerning discrimination in schools and in workplace it persists through time. It is a myth that gender inequality only exists in not develop countries. People have a tendency to think that only poor countries suffer this kind of situations, but gender inequality is a global problem. In countries such as Canada and United States and many other…

    • 124 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    "Once upon a time, it was a man’s world,” states David Brooks firmly. For centuries it has been understood that men rule over the more important dominant and power positions of the world. From great male pharaohs, to an increasingly systematic view of presidency, men have been able to manipulate genetic gender roles in order to instill the notion that it’s truly a world only able to stand with the leadership of men. However, contrary to the beliefs of the gender based roles of conduct in society, that represent males as supreme in intelligence and in physical dominance, we have evolved into an era where woman carry an equivalent and sometimes ever greater capacity to strive for success than ever before over men. To begin with, no longer…

    • 1168 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gender Inequality Essay

    • 922 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Another example is that female coal workers cannot get promotions to a higher position, because they were considered a “weaker sex”; they can become mother one day, so they are considered “soften” in many cases (Padavic 2002). The stereotype of women being weak and lack of leadership causes problem for women to move up the promotion ladder. It comes from the same idea that women have lower position than men in the social stratification, and women are not granted with the symbolic rewards of trusting their capability in leadership. Because of the stereotype of female, women still have lower status than men in the society right…

    • 922 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Speech On Sexism In Men

    • 590 Words
    • 3 Pages

    A New Generation of Pressure: An Analysis In Sexism In Men Topic: The different types of gender roles and stereotypes men go through. General Purpose: To inform Specific Purpose:…

    • 590 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Question 1 From a young age, I recognized my mother as my caregiver and my father as the provider for our family. The concept of women’s role in a family setting as a caregiver and a father’s as provider is not new. As I grow older, I have realized that this view is traditional and does not apply to all men and women or family dynamics. My parents first taught me about these roles by setting them as a standard.…

    • 1290 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Burgoon et al. (2016) use expectancy violations theory to examine how different forms of interfaces that confirm or violate user expectations affect the communication process, social judgments, ability to influence, and accuracy to recall associated with HtEAC (communication with a computer generated person). Burgoon et al. , (2016) have participants interact with an embodied agent or with a human partner to solve a task. Their results suggest that people trust EAs more than actual human beings (Burgoon et al., 2016).…

    • 1219 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To be assertive or to be different In her article "swagger like us" Ann Friedman discusses how women can achieve professional success in a working world that is still dominated by men. In her article she discusses two ways in which women use to progress in the workplace. One of the ways woman can progress in the workplace is to "act like a man". By doing this females would be overselling themselves in job interviews, ask for more raises, demand a better title and also being more assertive when expressing their own opinion. Ann Freidman connects this idea to a blog post called "A rant about women" by Clay Shirky.…

    • 884 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Sociology Chapter 12

    • 561 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Chapter 12 talks about the paid work role and health. An interesting point of this chapter was that hostile environment sexual harassment is more likely to happen to women who work in nontraditional occupations. They are seen by males as a threat to their jobs by rejecting traditional female gender roles. Some believe that sexual harassment is used as a form of punishment for not complying with prescription components of gender role stereotypes and as a way to maintain the status difference (Helgeson 482). This point is important because it might help to understand the nature and origin of sexual harassment in the workplace.…

    • 561 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Catherine Rampell, a respected journalist for The Washington Post, wrote an article titled, “Be Pretty, But Not Too Pretty: Why Women Can’t Just Win.” This article talks about how women in the work place are ridiculed for how they look and how they act in corporate and political America. Women are struck with different stereotypes in the work place on a daily basis.…

    • 1049 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Comparative analysis: Empress Wu Zetian and Pharaoha Cleopatra Stephen Damron Strayer University HUM 111: World Cultures I Dr. Ronald Gavin May 29, 2016 This comparative analysis examines two powerful and historically significant female rulers from ancient times. The Chinese Empress Wu Zetian, who lived from 624 to 705 is compared and contrasted with the Egyptian Pharaoh Cleopatra, who lived from 69 to 30B.C.E ("Wu Zetian," 2014). It is concluded that, despite their important differences, both rulers found it impossible to attain ultimate power through the official hierarchy, and thus had to utilize their own restrictive gender roles, as well as violence and cunning, to assert and maintain their…

    • 1055 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gender Roles Sociology

    • 497 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Gender roles affect everyone regardless of their age, gender, sexuality, or race. For the purposes of this essay we will define gender as he meaning society gives to people who identify as a male or a female as stated by J.J. Macionis, professor of sociology, in his book Society: The Basics (2017). Gender roles are also defined as the the roles society expects people of certain genders to perform. To provide a common example of gender roles we often hear, especially from the older generations, that women should stay at home and do the housework and take care of the kids where as men should change the oil on a car. Society also heavily discourages people who attempt to reverse gender roles.…

    • 497 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Social Construction Approach Essay Social construction theory is defined as society’s imposing historic and cultural influences having the power to exploit the biological differences between men and women to put both sexes into two different gender specific roles (Klement, 2016). Gender has less to do with nature and biology. There are no grounds to continue to create excuses for male dominance (Klement, 2016). Author Anne Fausto-Sterling presents the notion that gender is a socially fashioned concept.…

    • 1042 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Benevolent Sexism

    • 976 Words
    • 4 Pages

    “Status inequality is a system of inequality that is founded on cultural beliefs about status difference between types of people” (Ridgeway 2011:156). When a woman acts in these ways, others may reciprocate the masculine identities. In interaction, these characteristics of women make them “more dependent on men by virtue of expressing positive characteristics, ultimately positioning women as inferior” (Wade and Feree 2015:148). The traits associated with women need counterparts to be justified, which are qualities associated with masculinity. A woman may be praised for a petite frame, but it also puts her at risk for less physical defense.…

    • 976 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Personal Reflection As I reflect on my completion of my graduate program I will need to develop my skills and personal attributes for my future endeavors. This program has prepared me to be able to function in any capacity in the healthcare field. As a healthcare administrator, I will be responsible for planning, directing, and coordinating medical and health services. Eventually one day I will run an entire facility upon obtaining my Ph.D. As a healthcare administrator, I will be directing change when it comes to new healthcare laws, regulations, and technology.…

    • 1104 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Beliefs involved assumptions about the nature and the skills required for effective leadership in organizations (theory implied) assumptions about the inherent differences between men and women (gender stereotypes), and assumptions concerning appropriate behavior for men and women (estimated role) .Most organizations believe that men have properties such as assertive, confident, focused and not easily influenced by emotion. Besides that most parties believe that women are not able to play a good role as a leader. We truly do not agree with gender-based discrimination because of the most important thing for effectiveness in management is about how leaders can manage the organization. So, whether men or women gender is not important because both men and women have their own strengths.…

    • 836 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics