Organ Transplant Case Study

Improved Essays
As the lead surgeon in a major hospital, and by virtue of seniority and the key decision maker for organ transplant cases, involving Jerry, 55-year-old male, a family man and mid-level manager, Lisa 12-year-old female with lifelong health issues, Ozzy, 38-year-old male who happened to be a homeless drug abuser, and finally Dr.Doe, 35-year-old male an oncologist and also Lisa’s dad. Who are all waiting and hoping for suitable heart to become available and a quick sound decision to be made pertaining which of these patients will receive the heart and schedule surgery same day.
The most considered will be Dr. Doe, the 35-yearold male an oncologist and Lisa’s dad. This is because, despite the reason that, the organ is not tested for a match. Meaning is a fifty-fifty chance of survival. But if the organ transplant was successful, it will be of a greater good, and also result of the greater happiness for the Dr. Doe and the society in general. Being an oncologist, he will be more useful
…show more content…
Though she would have been the second in consideration, in the sense that, since she has been on a lifelong health issues, the transplant would have given her at least a chance of happiness, but the transplant is not an assurance of survival, since being immediate and the heart is not tested for a right match. For the society, when considering her age, she has a long time to contribute to the society but she is not of good health.
As Utilitarian, we are invited to ask the question that poses the ultimate utilitarian test: What will happen if we actually choose this action instead of another one?” What, indeed! Such as a question makes no sense in deontological ethics, like those of Kant, because the single criterion of deontological ethics is that principle and intentions drive the decisions completely outside of concern for outcomes and

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Ethical Organ Donation

    • 1514 Words
    • 7 Pages

    A Policy Proposal for Ethical Organ Donation It is estimated that there are around one hundred and twenty thousand patients waiting on the national waiting list for an organ transplant. The demand for healthy, fresh, and, new organs is high. “According to the National Health Services Blood and Transplant, more than twenty-two million people have pledged to help others after their death by registering their wishes on the National Organ Donor Register. Despite the high number of registered donors, most will sadly die in circumstances where they are unable to donate their organs” (Griffith, R. 2016).…

    • 1514 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Activity 4.3.1 Who Should Receive the Organ? Introduction In 1984, the federal government passed the National Organ Transplant Act (NOTA) which established the framework for a national system of organ transplantation. Under NOTA, the Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network (OPTN) are responsible for formulating organ allocation policies and is administered by the United Network for Organ Sharing (UNOS). Deciding who receives donated organs is not always easy and clear-cut.…

    • 509 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Part A Usually to be able to be eligible for a heart transplant, possible recipients would: • Have to be in good health, besides from the heart failure • Have to be most likely to die without undergoing the transplant • Have to be able to handle the drug treatments and examinations that would follow on after the transplant • Have to be unsuitable for other therapies • Most likely be 70 or younger (Criteria in order from 1-5, 1 being the most important) 1. Most likely to die without undergoing transplant; I think this is the most important because of obvious reasons; they’ll die if they don’t receive the heart transplant. 2. Handle the treatments and examinations afterwards; if a person wasn’t able to handle the aftermath of the transplant…

    • 1461 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Katie was eight years old and she was hit by a car and unfortunately died. Her parents was trying to take it all in and someone told her katie should become a donor. At first her parents never really thought about it but they went through with the idea. Turns out because they went through with the idea, Katie was able to save two little boys and two grown men (Huston). Since her parents chose to donate Katie’s organs, they were able to save four people’s lives.…

    • 1097 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Should there be a choice to save lives? Did you know anyone over 18 can prevent someone dying every 90 minutes from not receiving an organ? There are up to 1,700 Australians on the organ donation waiting list at any one time to receive an organ and you can save up to 10. Unfortunately, there were only 378 donors in 2014. Australia is the best in the world at transplanting organs into people’s bodies.…

    • 468 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to Butts and Rich (2013), the first ethical principle is the medical entitlement method. This method involves treating the sickest patient first. In the case study, Mr. Mann is currently in the hospital because his condition is deteriorating. Mrs. Day is extremely sick also, but is not requiring hospitalization at this time. According to this principle, Mr. Mann has the right to the organ transplantation before Mrs. Day.…

    • 1352 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Unwind Book Report

    • 1181 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The book Unwind is a fictional book written by Neal Shusterman. In the book, everybody donates 99.4 percent of their body when they are unwound. In the future, this may actually be possible. Based on information that I found, it could happen and the future and decrease the numbers of people on the waiting list for organs.…

    • 1181 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    God Squad Case Study

    • 1817 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Initially, this sounds like a simple task, however, the God Squad must determine how to distribute scarce resources with minimal knowledge of the patient’s individual case. Most likely members have little to no knowledge of the actual intensity of the surgery or the medical repercussions of the procedure. Additionally, the God Squad has no universally set criteria to determine which factors to consider when evaluating a patient’s case. As a result, the God squad constructs their own criteria based solely on psychosocial factors. Permitting the God Squad to have control of the transplant list sounds potentially problematic, however, the utilitarian approach claims that the members of a God Squad are the most qualified to make such decisions.…

    • 1817 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Patients Y and Z argue why not kill a random person to use their organs for Y and Z to live. They continue by saying after all they didn’t deserve their terminal prognosis because the patients did nothing to contribute to their…

    • 838 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the United States a lot of people are faced with the choice of something that occurs after death. Thinking of the afterlife is scary for some people but it is a decision that needs to be decided. The choice is organ donation to be a donor or to not be a donor, this can be decided by a personal say or a family decision. In the case of Heather Semans, it was a decision made by her family to donate an organ to someone who needed it.…

    • 1577 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This includes being impersonal, not establishing how to resolve conflicting duties and that rules are absolute. In light of these limitations, I know that some people will disagree that the surgeon should choose the deontological approach. To those who would argue that utilitarian is the best approach I say that while deontology has its limitations so too does utilitarianism. How can utilitarianism calculate pleasure and pain for unforeseen consequences, the violation of individuals’ liberties and rights or lastly, deriving the act as morally right just because a lot of people derive pleasure from an act? These criticisms apply to this transplant…

    • 891 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Organ Donation In Canada

    • 435 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Introduction Imagine, being in the ICU, still fighting for those last moments of life. This is the position of hundreds of people in need of an organ transplant every single day. How would it feel to know that millions of people out there are capable of saving lives, but no one’s stepping up? As many as 18 people die every day waiting for an organ. For many that might not seem like a lot but at this rate, that is almost 6500 deaths each year.…

    • 435 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Statistics claim, “Every ten minutes another name is added onto the national organ transplant waiting list” (donatelife.net). In today’s society there is an issue that is often forgotten, and that is organ donation. Many people don’t often think about this problem due to the fact of many distractions such as current events, politics, personal matters, and many more. Although there are many reasons as to why this topic isn’t brought up often, doesn’t mean it should be brushed off the shoulder and set aside. Patients have to face life or death situations due to the lack of organ donations, and there are so many resolutions that can be made towards this issue.…

    • 1123 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Why Is Arthritis Important?

    • 2465 Words
    • 10 Pages

    TOPIC Every day, more and more people require a new organ. Whether it’s a new lung, heart, kidney, liver, brain or any of the other myriad of minor organs, anyone could need one due to an injury or disease. There is, however, a solution for people in need of an organ. Patients in need of an organ are placed on a wait list for an available organ provided my donors. “Unlike relatively simple tissues such as bones and skin, to give a heart, the donor must be declared brain dead and the family must consent” (Morber).…

    • 2465 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Do you hate waiting for something you really, really want? Well, so do hundreds of thousands of people, but instead they’re waiting for organs. Unfortunately they can’t wait forever, and 18 people die each day waiting, but that can change. According to the article, “Donor Stories”, by Robin, a mother in Tennessee telling about her 15 year old son Blake. As Mother’s Day draws near, I feel a sense of dread coming over me.…

    • 1041 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays