Treadwell Vs Mccandless

Better Essays
Imagine walking into the wild while abandoning everything ever known in life such as family, friends, place of residence, and even daily hobbies and pastimes in an attempt to dissociate from society just to experience freedom, or prove a cause that many find unnecessary and life threatening. Although it may seem like an adrenaline rush for some, there is a very slim chance for survival given the surroundings and circumstances. The author of Into the Wild, Jon Krakauer, reveals Chris McCandless to be an introvert who feels the need to live off the land in Alaska and to escape the fabricated upbringing by his parents. In an effort to show the dangers of living and exploring in the wilderness alone, director Werner Herzog introduces Timothy Treadwell …show more content…
Both McCandless and Treadwell were educated, with McCandless having the advantage. McCandless attended and graduated from Emory University in Atlanta, Georgia where he’d “been a columnist for , and editor of, the student newspaper, The Emory Wheel”. He graduated with a degree in history and anthropology with a 3.72 grade-point average and was offered membership to Phi Beta Kappa but declined after stating that titles and honors are “irrelevant”. Unlike McCandless, Treadwell did receive a scholarship to attend Bradley University in Peoria, Illinois to swim, but he later dropped out. Although prepared mentally, McCandless was not prepared in any other way for a long isolation. Before leaving, he abandoned everything besides essentials which included some clothes, a miniscule amount of money, and a bag of rice. A major problem for McCandless proved to be his lack of a sufficient amount of food. With the help of a scientific book regarding wild plants, he trained himself to find sources of food in Alaska. Unfortunately, this proved to be fatal due to the fact McCandless had died from eating moldy potato seeds, which were listed as safe to eat in the book. Due to the fact McCandless wanted to live off the land, he didn’t carry supplies or even a necessity such as a map with him into the wilderness because he wanted to create a map for himself in order to become accustomed to his surroundings. Unfortunately, this decision turned fatal because it possibly could have assisted McCandless in crossing the Teklanika River that Summer. Unlike McCandless, Treadwell had the luxury of being dropped off in an airplane with supplies that would last all summer. Being near a grizzly bear is undoubtedly a dangerous feat, especially in the wild without protection. Treadwell would have been alive if he hadn’t decided to extend the duration of his travels. In the extra time, grizzlies foreign to the area and

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    When McCandless is found dead, the troopers find, “a diary- written across the last two pages of a field guide to edible plants” (26). This is the only reference book McCandless brings on his adventure. The book highlights only some of the plants he may not be able to eat. McCandless is extremely vulnerable here because he decides to eat a potato, unknown to him to be poisonous, which caused his…

    • 1071 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In a society heavily based on family values, Chris McCandless abandons the status quo and runs into the wilderness seeking solitude and self-discovery. In Jon Krakauer’s Into the Wild, the protagonist Chris McCandless escapes a privileged young adult life to pursue a better understanding of his self-identity, which he believes he can find in the Alaskan wilderness. Although intending to chase his sense of adventure and escape materialistic ideologies, McCandless was egotistical in his exploration. Before leaving for his adventure to Alaska, Chris McCandless told his sister Carine of his plans to leave his family behind, as he was tired of feeling controlled. McCandless was known to be apathetic towards his family, excluding his sister Carine;…

    • 868 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    To Be Free Everyone around the world develops problems in their lives; these problems may include the struggle to meet society and family expectations. However, the ways in which people deal with these difficulties vary. Some individuals choose not to act and allow their problems to exist, while others seek constant assistance. A less popular route is to leave society completely and become an independent, otherwise known as living life on the road. This alternate path is depicted in Into the Wild, a documentation of the life of Chris McCandless and his journey to Alaska.…

    • 1524 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    McCandless traveled into Alaska with rice and a small amount of knowledge on poisonous berries, told from the story. Although Chris tried to act as though he was doing something great he actually was causing harm to himself and everyone he actually cared about. Chris McCandless’s adventure was complete nonsense because he was unprepared, he had no knowledge on how to truly survive in the wild, and he left his life behind for an awful reason. McCandless was a lost teenager that should have gotten help rather than trying to fix himself in the wild. The story starts off with a man with the name of Jim Gallien just driving.…

    • 1274 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    “Yes, look- you don’t eat anything!... So finish at least what’s on your plate!” (Spiegelman 43). During the Holocaust, one of the ways the Nazis dehumanized their victims would be to starve them. Without food, it would be easier for them to die or be killed. Since Vladek experienced a severe deficit of food during WWII when hiding from the Nazis, he desired for his son to eat as much as possible because of a remembrance of a lack of food (112).…

    • 672 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Many people in America are unsure where they belong or where they should be. Some people choose to explore the world by traveling while the others choose to rot in their boring lives. Life in America is hard, there are highly expectations from people and the judgment is in every corner one turns to. The three novels, Into the Wild, Travels with Charley, and On the Road are three unique novels about separate individuals who choose to travel in order to seek what they are looking for. McCandless, from Into the Wild, is a young man who travels to Alaska to seek for the freedom he wanted and to escape from the reality he was living.…

    • 1837 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    d. Subjective meanings/ pg. 13: the meanings that people give their own behaviors Food and nutrition can be a major problem. The irony really kicked in while watching the video when I saw all these workers slaving in the fields, picking these crops, yet not getting the vegetables or right nutrition that they needed. When on break from working, we saw them snacking on chips and soda. We never saw them eating the crops they actually picked, which would not be good either considering all the pesticides on them.…

    • 399 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Animal Buffet Analysis

    • 1167 Words
    • 5 Pages

    It had been a very dry summer and a dry summer meant no water for the tree roots. The tree roots getting no water would mean the trees would lack the nourishment to grow the acorns, hickory nuts or walnuts the animals needed to feed through the winter until the next fall harvest. No water would mean no berries for the birds and turkey. No green grass for the deer to eat. The little squirrel and surely all his animal friends, were very, very hungry and there was no food to be had.…

    • 1167 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    “Many Alaskans have wondered why, in his desperation, McCandless didn’t start a forest fire at this point, as a distress signal(Krakauer 198).” McCandless left his former life and changed his name to create his own society. He wanted to be completely away from other people and live off the land of the Alaskan wilderness for a while. As he had already done so for around 2 months thus far, why would he suddenly decide that he should send a distress signal? It doesn’t fit with his philosophy of life, which is why he likely didn’t send a distress signal. He must’ve…

    • 1035 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In addition, Jefferson felt completely dehumanized and worthless because he knew that no one cared because slaughtering was common in the South. Chapter 11 is frustrating because when Grant visits and bring Jefferson food, Jefferson kneels down on the floor and puts his head inside the bag and starts eating with no hands therefore proving the attorney and the white stereotype of blacks being animals. Not only does he eat like a hog, but he began to dissociate himself by his use of grammar. It is not the fact that Jefferson will be killed soon, but the fact that he is called a hog is what truly angers and upsets…

    • 873 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays