Crime Control Vs Due Process Model

Improved Essays
Stanford University law professor Herbert Packer’s models analyze two contrasting standpoints of the way the criminal justice system is, or should strive to, be. The two split positions charted by the Crime Control and Due Process models seek to describe perhaps the two most prominent positions in regards to the power and influence of the criminal justice system: that the safety of the community should be valued over all else, or that the rights of the individual are the most important values to uphold. These ideological conflicts remain the forefront of problems within the criminal justice system, and understanding each persuasion is essential to analyzing and overcoming differences in each stage of the criminal justice process.
The Crime
…show more content…
The goal of incapacitation, or using prison (or some type of imprisonment) as a way to remove more offenders (or potential offenders) off the streets, exists conjointly with the outlook and ideologies of the Crime Control Model. Those following the philosophies of this model cite that the best way to protect the community is to remove offenders from public interaction, so incapacitation would best serve the needs of both the offender and society. Society benefits from the lessened potential of an offender committing further crimes against the law abiding, and the offender must deal only with the restraints defined under his sentencing, and not further punishment (such as retribution). With the goal of incapacitation looming, it is easier to quickly and efficiently push offenders through and standardized criminal justice system without much thought for the outcomes for the individual. Citing the goal of incapacitation also provides more validity for the discretion of law enforcement officials, especially when making arrests or detaining parties. If removing threats from the street at any cost is translated to policing, it allows for any perceived threat (by an officer’s standards) to be detained, regardless of the criminality of the …show more content…
This model’s intention is to prevent any missteps in the criminal justice process, especially in sentencing, allowing for the truly innocent to go free. This could be one aspect of rehabilitation, which could be interpreted to mean going from a state of incarceration to deserved freedom (as rehabilitation by definition means to return an individual to their previous condition). Other aspects of rehabilitation would benefit actual law-breakers by allowing them ample time to recover from their afflictions. Especially in cases of less serious crimes, such as DWIs and petty theft charges, the individual may be much better served by programs intended to correct the behavior of offenders, rather than simple jail time. The Due Process model assures each individual’s case will not be rushed, and allows for much more time for the completion of these types of programs and in return promotes leniency in plea bargains from the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The conflict and consensus models are two parallel models that work toward furthering the protection of society. The conflict model focuses on preserving the rights of the people while the consensus model focuses on public safety (Cronkhite, 2013). When considering how these two apply to viewing criminal justice as a system it is quite simple. The conflict model creates an urgency to protect the people from harm yet also to preserve individual rights that are guaranteed by the Constitution. If the conflict model is to be applied to criminal justice, then it is important to recognize that laws and policy can be implemented by the criminal justice system to combat crime, while also ensuring that the people do not lose their rights.…

    • 904 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Lincoln Lawyer The purpose of this paper is to apply Packer’s two models of the criminal justice system to a media depiction. The two models of the criminal justice system in which Packer speaks is the crime control model and the due process model. The goal of the paper is to find a better understanding of the two models through media depiction. This paper is going to illustrate how due process and the crime control model is depicted in the movie The Lincoln Lawyer.…

    • 1958 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    First Colonial Jail Essay

    • 758 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Rehabilitation allows for the criminal to get the help that he or she needs to hopefully one day be able to go back to society to be a contributing member. An example of rehabilitation would be if a citizen was taken to jail for drug use and possession and the judge ruled that the defendant will have to go to jail for a certain amount of time and following their incarceration attend a drug rehab. The model the United States uses for sentencing and corrections is called the justice model. The justice model is a “process of determining sentences according to fair and just sentencing policies. The model is based on retributive notions of deserved punishment; the sentence should fit the crime.…

    • 758 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Crime Control As Industry warns us about the wicked growth of the US imprisonment levels, and the threats that this trend can have around the world if it continues to develop. A good way of stopping this from happening is to have a deeper look into the way the penal systems work and in particular to highlight the differences between political processes and…

    • 954 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In recent discussions of the jail system, a controversial issue has been whether incarceration has helped contribute to the efforts of decreasing crime On the one hand, some argue that mass incarceration is a horrible failure. On the other hand, however, others argue that incarceration brings crime down. In sum, then, the issue is whether mass incarceration is the solution to lowering the crime rate or not. Though many people assume that mass incarceration drops the crime rate, it still does not change how the same criminals that are incarcerated are being released from jail committing the same crimes over and over making it almost impossible to drop the crime rate.…

    • 810 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Due process model protects the individual that's being accused and their rights. It focuses on individual liberties. It allows the individual the right to make decisions on their cases. Like whether or not they want to be represented by a lawyer or themselves. The individual can also provoke information that might hurt the case.…

    • 139 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Integrating these approaches into correctional facilities can improve them and meet the needs of both offenders and victims out in the community. Theoretical Practices for Restorative Justice, Crime Prevention,…

    • 1214 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Incapacitation as a rationale for punishment or goal of the correctional system allows for offenders to be confined within institutions and prevented from committing additional crime within their society during the time of their sentence. The persons criminal record and type of crime committed determine if the offender will continue to commit crime. Ultimately, the incapacitation rationale focuses on the characteristics of an offender. Furthermore, Selective incapacitation has been brought to the correctional systems attention over recent years. Therefore, the correctional system is sentencing offenders who repeat certain kinds of crime to extensive prison terms.…

    • 594 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Crime control and due process are two very different processes to determine guilt. When an example of crime control is in effect it could be a split second decision that relies on a police officers best judgement. While due process involves many opinions and a group reaching a consensus on a individuals guilt. In today's world I feel that due process is the better option today but we as a society doesn't look kindly upon the use of crime control, For example, the Michael Brown case in Ferguson, Missouri. When the grand jury found Officer Wilson innocent, riots broke out.…

    • 100 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Criminal Justice System is composed of two conflicting models, the due process model and the crime control model. The crime control model has a goal of maintaining social order and preventing crime, while the due process model focuses mainly on the rights of the individual. With law enforcement using quickly advancing and emerging technology like drones and super squad cars, there are disputes about each model due to issues of misuse of police powers and privacy concerns. These debates involve which model is more adapted for the well-being of society and, which model overall is better for reaching the main goals of the criminal justice system. Both models have similar goals of preventing crime and protecting the public, but the way in which these two models succeed those goals slightly differ.…

    • 740 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In this essay I will discuss two approaches to punishment which are retributivism, also known as non-consequentialism, and utilitarianism, also known as consequentialism. I will then analyse three justifications of punishment within the utilitarian approach which are reform and rehabilitation, individual and general deterrence and incapacitation. Retributivism is a sociological perspective of crime which looks at the different forms and changes in punishment. It is a backward thinking approach as it does not look at future consequences of punishment and is mostly concerned with offences already committed and getting ‘justice’. This approach is considered similar to ‘an eye for an eye’ as it is based on the idea that if we inflict harm on another…

    • 1129 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Correctional Ideology

    • 1878 Words
    • 8 Pages

    The previously discussed ideologies had several problems with the effects that they caused. The current correctional practices have problems that have caused the desire for crime prevention to become prevalent. “Almost all offenders are eventually released, however, and the problem returns unless it has been effectively treated while the offender was in prison” (Allen 57). The logic behind crime prevention is clear. Preventing crime is to prevent everything that follows the crime as well.…

    • 1878 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the last 40 years, incarceration in the United States has reached epidemic proportions. We have the highest incarceration rate in the world; we hold 5% of the world’s population, but house 25% of the world’s prisoners (Kelly 2015). The use of incarceration has gradually become a more acceptable and more used form of punishment. As a result, our prison population is overflowing with offenders ranging from petty theft criminals to violent offenders. As cited in the textbook, purposes of our justice system should be retribution, deterrence, incapacitation, and rehabilitation, (Clear, Reisig, & Cole 2016, p.72-73) but we focus far too much on punishment first and rehabilitation second, if ever.…

    • 1156 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Once balance is restored, the chances of the prisoner re-offending are diminished (Inayatullah, 2011). In contrast, there is the punishment model. Inayatullah (2011) states that the argument is that all the rights are given to the offender and the victim has none. Therefore in this approach, the best way to reduce present day and future crimes is to keep serious offenders in jail. Evidence shows that twenty-five percent of criminal activity can be reduced by lengthy prison sentences.…

    • 1674 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A good example of selective incapacitation is the three-strikes law; with this law the sentences increase as the person who is previously convicted of two or more serious crimes. There are four issues with this type of incapacitation as discussed in the book, predicted behavior is poor, the lost of incarceration with the offender’s career, and there are a constant level arrest, conviction, and incarceration. Lastly the non-representation of inmates giving them generalization based off of…

    • 1334 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays