Examples Of Court Observation

Superior Essays
Court Observation

Juvenile crime is undoubtedly a controversial issue in Canadian politics. With decades of research and multiple different acts that have been passed in regards to the juvenile/youth justice system, youth justice in Canada is found to be quite lamentable. What is meant by “controversy” in juvenile crime is that there are many disagreements on the action that is necessary in dealing with a juvenile delinquent. Is the punishment too small? Is the punishment too severe? The controversy behind this is an occurring process to this day and we will look further into how youth justice started, and how it came to be to this day. I had the chance to go view a juvenile delinquent’s court case proceeding. The court room consisted of
…show more content…
Most importantly with this legislation being introduced, it guaranteed right to obtain and instruct legal counsel. With this being said of the YOA, this also ties into what we have today in the YCJA. In both legislations during a court case proceeding in action, defendants have the right to have help from a counsel, and if the defendant cannot afford a lawyer, require that the government appoint one or pay the defendant 's legal expenses. In the case I went to see, the defendant did in fact have a lawyer present during the proceeding because it is their right to have one if needed, just like in the YOA. This act also established the national age of criminal responsibility at 12 years old. In today’s world of the criminal justice system the age varies from province to province, and each province has more discretion as to what the cut off age will be. But what could the change in ages be a result of? There may be many factors that vary between provinces that enact them to select a certain age of criminal responsibility. The establishment of the YOA brought a few good things to the table for that of youth offenders. But was the YOA too good for youth offenders? Based on page 49 of the textbook, official data tells us that in the early 1990s about 18.6 per cent of young offenders who appeared in court have had five or more prior convictions. Approximately 46 per cent of those charged in youth court had one or more prior convictions since 1984. It got even worse in the late 1990s where nearly 42 per cent of cases with convictions involved repeat offender. The jist of these statistics displays that the older a youth gets, the more likely it becomes that he or she has had prior charges. With only a short span of 15 years, the cons outweighed the pros resulting in another shift away to another “act”. Critics of the YOA found that it was representing an unfortunate shift away

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    When I first started reading ‘No Matter How Loud I Shout’ by Edward Humes, I didn’t know what to expect as I have not learned a lot about the juvenile justice system. After reading it though, I would say that what I’ve read has taught me a large amount of what really goes on in the juvenile justice system. Although there are several things I learned by reading the Humes book, three of the main things I learned is that the juvenile system doesn’t really work, there are programs which do help kids, and that some kids in the system are not given the help they need. One of these is that the juvenile justice system doesn’t really work.…

    • 720 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    An estimated 250,000 youth are tried, sentenced, or incarcerated every year across the United States (campaign for youth justice). There is large controversy regarding whether or not children and young adults should be required to be sentenced as adults, regardless of their age and circumstance. This is believed to be the most logical way of approaching this matter because every case should undergo the same consequences despite the criminal’s circumstances. An opposing view would argue that it is necessary to take into consideration the situation of each criminal case before deciding on the punishment. They would also claim that children specifically, should be given another chance due to their lack of maturity.…

    • 1774 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Edward Humes vents his disappointments about the juvenile justice system in No Matter How Loud I Shout. As a counselor and teacher of juvenile delinquents in LA County, Humes depicts huge numbers of his experiences. He talks about the general juvenile justice system in the United States, yet additionally limits it down to the system of his district as he depicts one year of cooperations with seven delinquents. All through, Humes brings up a significant number of the weaknesses that he has gotten comfortable with through his work. Humes contends that the gaps in the system, the absence of care by authorities, and the misrepresented responses of people in general exacerbate a terrible circumstance much than it ought to be…

    • 1776 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    All eyes were glued to the judge as he said the words that would change the juvenile’s life forever. He was being sentenced to life in prison as a part of a crime he committed with his friends. Many young adolescents some as young as 9 , are being forced to go to prison for long periods of time on an almost daily basis. Minor’s should not be allowed to be tried as adults and to be sentenced to life in prison, as an adult environment would be to brutal for them to cope with. In addition, most kids are very susceptible to peer pressure and often act on impulse in large groups.…

    • 1526 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The juvenile justice system has come a long way from way back in the 1800’s to 2000’s we live in today. The process in which juveniles are convicted and punished has become more refined and set toward more reform than punishment. Did you know that back in the 1800’s and earlier juveniles were held in the same jails as adults were? The earliest start of the separate juvenile justice system can be traced back to the early 1800’s (Taylor, Fritsch and Caeti).…

    • 934 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ycja Pros And Cons

    • 1112 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Not only will it help us have a more fair and equitable system, but it will improve the safety for ourselves and the people in our surroundings. This act will also help the youth understand the good from the bad and hope to can prevent repetition of the same criminal offence. By doing this we can guarantee that the criminal offences committed by youth will continue to decrease in future generations. I believe this act can make the youth see what they did was a terrible act and change them into even better people than before. If these youth turn into better people, they will influence the other people around them and we could all have a safe environment for all ages of Canadian citizens.…

    • 1112 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This display of mercy would avoid any backlash or negative feelings towards the justice system and law enforcers which leads to decreased crime rates and creates more trust. Furthermore, the YCJA has proven to be effective by steadily decreasing the amount of cases in Youth Courts. “The Canadian youth courts completed about 48,000 cases in 2011/2012, resulting in the third consecutive annual decline and the lowest number of cases since data were first collected in 1991/1992. The decrease between 2010/2011 and 2011/2012 occurred across the country and among virtually all types of cases” (Statistics Canada). Of those cases only about 57% were actually found guilty, which is considerably lower than about a decade ago (Statistics Canada).Therefore, the Youth Criminal Justice Act has long-term…

    • 1119 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ycja Case Study

    • 534 Words
    • 3 Pages

    A title Criminal Code of Canada and the YCJA How are the Youth Criminal Justice Act and Criminal Code of Canada different? The Youth Criminal Justice Act describes the consequences for young offenders between the ages of 12-17. The Criminal Code deals with criminal offenders 18 years and older. Some of the causes for this issue are adults and young people. Trevor is a young boy with no family.…

    • 534 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the novel No Matter How Loud I Shout, author Edward Humes’ addresses the dysfunctions of the juvenile justice system. For a long time, most people did not even notice that the juvenile justice system is dysfunctional in any way. Once people did notice, they would tend to only focus on the child’s age when a serious crime takes place. This creates the notion that states need to lower the age of children who may tried in adult court. This notion is an ineffective tactic to try to reduce youth crime and address the dysfunctions of the juvenile justice system.…

    • 1979 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Edward Humes’s book, No Matter How Loud I Shout, follows the life of seven teenage boys who are working their way through the juvenile justice system and also serving time for their crimes. No Matter How Loud I Shout provides a clear and vivid picture in readers mind about the juvenile system and how it operates. It shows readers how unjust some situations in court can be. Humes spent a year researching California’s juvenile justice system and his book was inspired by his experience.…

    • 1937 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Juveniles should not be tried as adults for it is wrong to hold adolescents, under the legal age, to adult standards. If children do not even receive the same rights as adults in the first place, it makes no sense to try them in adult court. These juveniles should have the opportunity to be rehabilitated in a positive manner, for they tend to come from troubled households and violent neighborhoods. In over half of the cases these troubled kids don’t know any different way than a life of crime when surrounded by both social and environmental factors that influence their delinquent actions. One must commemorate that juveniles are mentally underdeveloped, and still have time to innovate if their issues are dealt with precisely and accurately.…

    • 1310 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, community corrections programs have often failed to reduce prison populations. The juvenile court 's work is very difficult and involves some of the most emotion-laden and controversial issues in our society. As such, its decisions often find disagreement. The extent to which the court 's discretionary authority in individual cases should be expanded or restrained continues to be debated for all types of cases before the court , because these courts make decisions regarding so…

    • 719 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Parens Patriae Case Study

    • 2290 Words
    • 10 Pages

    The ultimate goal was to not focus solely on the crimes committed by the juvenile, but to assist to their needs and provide the appropriate rehabilitation. In Edward Humes’ book, No Matter How Loud I Shout: A Year in the Life of Juvenile Court, we are able to witness the downfall of such a once, promising system. Throughout the book, the author forms a numerous amount of observations about the disorganization within the system, evaluates those who work for the system, and mentors the juveniles whose lives were spent in and out the…

    • 2290 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Over 100 years ago the United States established the Juvenile Justice system. In most states, a person who between the ages of 10 and 18 charged with a crime is considered a juvenile . The juvenile justice system main goal is to help rehabilitation rather than punishing the individual and held youths who commit crimes responsible for their action. Where adults who are accused and found guilty of a crime, the criminal justice courts focus on punishments. There are many debates over the juvenile justice on whether or not the system should need to focus more on proving rehabilitation or punishment like the adult criminal justice system .…

    • 853 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Old enough to do the crime, old enough to do the time,” Not only is this a catchy phrase that is gaining popularity, but it also represents a departure from the purpose with which the juvenile justice system was originally created over one hundred years ago‒to protect and rehabilitate young offenders. In an ideal world, counseling and rehabilitation would be enough for juvenile criminals, but oftentimes for repeat or violent offenders, this is just not enough. In the majority of cases involving violent crimes juvenile offenders must face the consequences of their actions and be tried as adults. Violent crime rates among juvenile offenders are increasing. Juveniles now are more likely than ever before to be the perpetrators of serious and deadly…

    • 1073 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays