The Cost Of Multilingualism Analysis

Improved Essays
These postulations are answered in the following paragraphs titled with The Cost of Multilingualism and The Dis-United States. The author illustrates two major reasons, which are reducing the cost of the federal spending and avoiding a series of severe constitutional crisis. First of all, the author states clearly in paragraph 11, “The federal government has spent over $100 million to study the effectiveness of bilingual education, only to discover that it is less effective at teaching English than English immersion programs are.” It means that even though the United States fund bilingual education with a tremendous amount of money, the outcome is still not as effective as English immersion programs. In other words, instead of providing bilingual education or environment, it is better for the US government to choose to English as the first language to save billions. …show more content…
In paragraph 21, the author assumes “Unless the United States changes course, it is clearly on the road to a Canadian-style system of linguistic enclaves, wasteful government expenses, language battles that fuel ethnic resentments, and, in the long run, serious ethnic and linguistic separatist movements.” Simply out, bilingual environment will harm its own nation within either short term or long run, because it is hard to assimilate people who are has deeply rooted in their own culture, even they live on the same piece of the land as others. Therefore, keeping English as the only official language would stabilize the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    To ensure success for both English-speakers and English-learners, schools should implement a bilingual education program like Dual-Immersion. Some other bilingual programs, such as Early-Exit or ESL classes, do not support the student’s native language; instead, the goal of these programs is to use native languages as a bridge to English to have students enter English-only classrooms as soon as possible. Dual-Immersion programs are different because they enroll both native English-speakers and English-learners, who can learn from each other. The goal of Dual-Immersion programs is for both English-learners and native English speakers to become bilingual (Morales & Aldana, 2010). The Dual-Immersion program works by combining translation support for immigrant students with education of foreign languages and cultures.…

    • 1596 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The author assumes that his audience is very likely to have a negative attitude towards bilingualism. He mentions that he is aware of American common bilingual separatism: "general disdain of bilingualism and bilingual education..." (260). Hence, probably one of his most desired objectives is to change this attitude. Fallows is unwilling to adapt and stick to this perspective on bilingualism; he wants to convince American people that bilingualism is valuable. Moreover, the author assumes that his audience needs information on both American and non-American positions on the topic.…

    • 1358 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In the article “Beyond Survival English” by Tamar Jacoby the author presents her opinion and explains how english is good but being bilingual benefits you even more. Immigrants come into the United States because there is more success in America. Learning academic english is important because of the popularity of the english language. In addition being bilingual benefits you even more by giving you a higher salary, helps you translate for other people, and helps you on interviews and finding jobs etc.…

    • 82 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The article “English Only” Laws divide and Demean by Warren J. Blumenfeld states the author’s view against enacting a law making English the official language of the federal government. Mr. Blumenfeld’s premise in "English Only" is that the law is unnecessary and divisive in the United States. He is seeking a call to action in his home state of Iowa against the “English-only” law because he believes that it will negatively impact the beliefs that our nation is founded upon, rather than celebrate and promote our uniqueness as a nation of people from different cultures seeking the freedom to be individuals. He is an opponent of this law since he believes it has the potential to create prejudice and discrimination toward our citizens because they speak a different language.…

    • 1376 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Peter Temes article appears to have a great deal of bias present. As the piece progresses, the bias falls away in favor of providing some interesting commentary on what bilingual education is, and why it should remain a part of the American education system. Temes brings in items that could be connected to the multiculturalism debate and he claims bilingual education “doesn’t work because it’s just a bad idea, supported only [by] ethnic blocks” (Temes 346). Temes even manages to go a step further and connects the “ethnic blocks” to a demand that has been created “for Spanish-speaking teachers and education workers” only (Temes 346). He does not elaborate about the need for teachers to be multilingual; however, he claims “that good bilingual…

    • 236 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He also mentioned the backlash by proponents of “English Only” in education who viewed bilingualism as a threat to American identity, but dressed it up as a concern for the Latino community educational disparities (pg. 140). This topic reminded me of the program “Spanish for Fluent Speakers” that I was part of for three years. The program was often undermined, as some saw it as means for Spanish speakers to evade the language requirement and take an easy class. I often received questions such as: “Why are you taking a Spanish class if you already speak it?” Despite those negative perceptions, this was a program that allowed me to reconnect with my Hispanic roots and recognize the social capital of bilingualism.…

    • 749 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Brandon Brice illustrates in the article “Why English should be the official language of the United States”, that the direct cost of translators and bilingual education alone averages from one to two billion dollars annually. This problem arises because the government of the United States is responsible for the costs of interpreters in schools, police departments, and hospitals, as well as dual-language driver’s license exams, tax forms, and voting ballots (2). If the United States agrees to constitute an official language, government spending will decrease greatly. If the United States establishes English as the official language the government will not have to print multiple copies of information in different languages, as well as financing for the many translators that the United States services every day. These services the government provides all come from the American citizen’s taxes.…

    • 1237 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    All students of the American education system should be fluent English speakers. Martin Espada and Richard Rodriguez, two revered essay writers both possess conflicting opinions about how bilingualism should be handled. Espada believes that language has ties to culture, and they should all be preserved; however, Rodriguez’s view of bilingualism is more methodical, he thinks learning the language used for public communication is the most beneficial method, regardless of any cultural ties that may be abandoned. Martin Espada’s view of bilingualism can be explained through his usage of a metaphorical analogy, wherein his essay he wrote, “English and Spanish are like two dogs I love. English is an obedient dog.…

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Rodriguez grew up in a Spanish speaking family thriving and eager to expand his education and vocabulary in the “loud, booming with confidence” English language. According to Rodriguez, bilingual educationists have strong disbelief in the idea that schools should be assimilated with bilingual education because the students lack “a degree of ‘individuality’” This sense of individuality is absent in public society because often your heritage sets you apart from most others around you.…

    • 73 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Introduction Prior to the Bilingual Education Acts Prior to the Bilingual Education Act of 1968, the U.S. government had a change in attitude towards bilingualism and bilingual educations. At times, there was this permissive attitude that allowed teaching through the mother tongue acceptable. As long as it was within the jurisdiction of local towns and districts, schools were allowed to teach in the child’s native language. However, there were times in which higher authorities were strongly against languages other than the English. This hostile climate would culminate in the some of the nation’s most drastic changes in the public schools resulting in the reduction of any type of bilingual instruction offered by some states (Nieto, 2009).…

    • 1102 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Even though one common language is important in the connection of this country, the other languages must not go without value. Even though there seems to be a popular “American” culture, the other cultures and values must not go without consideration. All deserve fair representation and opportunities within the public schools as well as in everyday life. As Herschel T. Manual states, “We must courageously attack the difficult problems of building a united community and adjusting education to the needs of children who come to us with differences which challenge our best efforts” (Manuel 639). Through bilingual education, students can feel value in their native language and culture while simultaneously learning English.…

    • 1720 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Lopez, in his dissertation, measures success of bilingual education students not necessarily on whether or not they achieved acquisition of the language, but on how their standard of living has increased by moving to the United States. Specifically, Lopez contends that language acquisition at a higher rate should indicate and correlate to higher wages for these first generation ELL students. Conversely, lower acquisition should indicate lower wages among these first generation ELL students. However, Lopez has found these differences to be statistically insignificant. If the goal of the EOEA is to provide equal opportunities, and yet students are making significantly less money as compared to non-ELL students, then ELL education and the money spent on that education is not producing positive results meant to increase the standard of living for those ELL students.…

    • 1836 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    is so far behind in advancements academically and socially. Every other country encourages and supports bilingual education. In each claim and argument Rodriguez presents there are harmful consequences that the reader takes away from them. He believes that one’s native language and the public language are unable to coincide, not based on research or statistics, merely based on his own personal experience with not being able to handle the two. The takeaway from this belief is that there should only be one language in America, the public language.…

    • 1405 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Aria” by Richard Rodriguez is an essay that shows the readers a part of life that many have never experienced. Rodriguez uses this essay to show how he fights through his childhood tounderstand English. He faces society while forfeiting his happy home life trying to become a typical English-speaking student. He establishes a connection with the audience through his personal experience as a child. He uses imagery and narration to clarify his opposition to bilingual education .Rodriguez…

    • 758 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    My mother had to put me in school, find a job, living situation wasn’t so great she had to find a house, it was just an abundant of work that she had to get done and on top of that she is trying to learn a new language. There are many Multilanguage organizations for people who are in my mother’s situation since my mother had not mastered the English language, she needed a helping hand, having someone to translate important documents, give suggestions on where are the finest places to stay, eat, and put me through school. All of these Multilanguage organization are necessary and I don’t see them as a tragedy.…

    • 1042 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays