Cognitive Dissonance And Behavior Case Study

Improved Essays
1. Cognitive dissonance is "the tension produced by a conflict between attitudes and behavior" (Nelson & Quick, 2015). In my present position, I have encountered a conflict with the district manager, who is not my direct manager but definitely my superior. She is very abrupt, loud, high energy (to the point of causing chaos in the work environment), and disrespectful to her employees. Even though she has this type of personality, she expects her employees to be positive, upbeat, and to not question or ask questions if we have them (as she is always right). I used to be somewhat like her in the way of causing a feeling of chaos in my life, due to high anxiety and other psychological issues; however I no longer act like this and try very …show more content…
Groupthink according to Nelson & Quick (2015) is "a deterioration of mental efficiency, reality testing and moral judgement resulting from pressures within the group" (pg. 161). I worked in a hospital medical information department years ago. Our director was what some in the department called a push over. She didn’t like confrontation, therefore she went to a few employees within the department, and she thought she could trust, for advice. I say trust, because due to the culture within the department, everyone knew of her conundrum by lunch time. This part of groupthink, cohesiveness that Irving Janis refers to in the textbook, caused many problems within our department (Nelson & Quick, 2015. pg. 162). "Cohesive groups tend to favor solidarity because members identify strongly with the group" and "they are likely to have shared mental models; that is, they are more likely to think alike" (Nelson & Quick, 2015. pg. 162). Due to this shared outlook on problems within the department, problems were confronted using one form of opinion or model. Therefore, problems weren’t always solved. I, along with many other employees, was very disgruntled with this approach to problem solving. I believe as the table 10.1 on page 162, shows, there were many symptoms of a groupthink scenario within our department (Nelson & Quick, 2015). These included rationalization (using their ideas of change with proof they will work because they believe them), stereotyping the enemy (or coworkers), self-censorship (one or more persons never doing against the group even if the groups ideas were preposterous), and peer pressure. After many years of this happening, many employees had had enough and wanted change. Monthly meetings with all employees were started and all ideas were heard, this enabled group decisions. In table 10.1, it also gives guidelines for preventing groupthink. Many of these types of guidelines were put into place. Some of these changes were: asked an

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Groupthink In Mean Girls

    • 1346 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Some researchers claim studies with group think “often using poor ―modes of measurement‖ – provided recommended approach. “(Park, 1990). Conclusively, groupthink studies have consistently shown to have an impact on group dynamics. In Mean Girls, Regina, who recently gained weight, wore sweatpants which is against the rules of the “Plastics”. She then was not allowed to sit with the group.…

    • 1346 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Cognitive dissonance theory is the theory that states that an individual attitudes and actions do not match each other. It is the tendency for an individual to seek balance among our cognition (beliefs, opinions, etc) when there is a discomfort or a buffer (dissonance/inconsistency) between our attitude and our action. To solve this problem, he or she may change something to eliminate or reduce the dissonance. Attitude is the way we feel about a particular way towards an object, people, and events. A real life example is when I was in high school…

    • 213 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay On Groupthink

    • 1170 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Groupthink is “the practice of thinking or making decisions as a group that discourages creativity or responsibility”. When everyone within the group believes in and acts the same, problems will emerge. This contributes to why they 're ridiculous goals will never be met. Part of the reason groupthink is Bad a success is due to the lack of outside perspective. In a way it 's compared to an old philosophy that Opposites attract.…

    • 1170 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Answering the above questions we can proceed to the next step which is how to implement the proposal. The groupthink is a result of bad processes, isolation and a desire preserving at all costs of group cohesion. All these factors however, can be addressed positively so that collective decisions can be improved and have only positive effect on business and its…

    • 631 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The main challenge of this group situation is that there was a sudden rise of conflict among members at the beginning to mid phase of the project. This resulted the possible development of groupthink (Janis, 2008). As a leader in this situation, I would firstly feel lousy and disappointed in myself that I didn’t take note of group’s division and how the meeting could be more inclusive of everyone’s opinion (Chadha, 2016). However, at that point, I would also probably feel confused but yet curious as to why it was suddenly voiced out, hence thought that I should facilitate to explicit the thoughts and feelings of each member to better understand as well.…

    • 436 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Politics cognitive dissonance is often used as a strategy to persuade voters. Cognitive dissonance is when a action conflicts with beliefs or preferences, as a result people change their beliefs or preferences to match their actions; “But precisely how to move voters successfully is a matter still not fully understood—and the raison d'etre for political strategists and pundits” (Paragraph 1). Harvard and Stanford universities have concluded that political attitudes are often a result of one’s own actions. These political attitudes can change as a result of cognitive dissonance, “…people adjust their political preferences in order to downplay cognitive dissonance…”(Paragraph 7).…

    • 641 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Hi Dawn, I agree that cognitive dissonance can be positive or negative depending on how it is handled. I love your positive attitude but confused at the same time about the situation of doing your work and incorporating your supervisor work also. I can see that being challenging because it is a lot but you prioritize and made it work for the good of both. This is what makes a healthy work environment when you are able to help one another and work together as a team. We may question ourselves about doing certain things on a job but you never know the great award that lies a head therefore it is always good to try and keep a positive attitude.…

    • 121 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In her article, What is Groupthink?, author Kendra Cherry discusses the concept of majority opinions in order to have multiple groups of people have agreements. People argue that groupthink occurs when a group of people work together and one opposes an idea and one person does not agree with the idea. This is helpful to the group because other ideas should be brought to the table. The concept of groupthink is related to the early settler’s experience because they had to work together in order to survive the obstacles they went through. Effects of groupthink on the settlers can be seen when they had to work with the natives to survive a harsh winter.…

    • 209 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Rhetorical Analysis

    • 1180 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Groupthink “occurs when highly cohesive groups fail to consider alternatives that may effectively resolve group dilemmas. Groupthink theorists contend that group members frequently think similarly and are reluctant to share unpopular or dissimilar ideas with others. When this occurs, groups prematurely make decisions, some of which can have lasting consequences.” I chose this theory because is a theory that is very important to understand on both an individual and organizational level. You need to understand groupthink so that you can be self-aware and avoid falling into it.…

    • 1180 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Groupthink In The Crucible

    • 1134 Words
    • 5 Pages

    When we work together we are able to get so much more done than we would be able to do just by ourselves. In contrast, some negative effects of groupthink is the fact it discourages individual responsibility and creativity. When we work alone we are able to focus on strengthening and carrying out our own ideas, but when we are in a group we are influenced by other people’s ideas and how them might be better or worse than our own. Also when we work alone we must be responsible to get the task done or find a solution for something in a timely and neat manner. Also when we work as a group this could create fighting such as when Hathorne says, “Why do you hurt these children?”…

    • 1134 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There is nothing better than people of the same interest, goals, and characters working as one. When groups of people are challenged with a question, the response from collective ideas is more likely to be…

    • 1326 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Imagine placing yourself in a situation where you see someone getting stabbed or raped and somewhere in the back of your mind, something is telling you to not believe it’s actually happening, what would you do? Would you immediately take action or dismiss the situation and not believe it’s happening? After reading chapters four and five of Lauren Slater’s book, Opening Skinner’s Box, it explains both the meaning of the diffusion of responsibility and cognitive dissonance. The connection between these two chapters show the human mind can be such a powerful and curious thing, but can be dangerous as well. We as human beings may not realize the psychological traps that our mind can play on us when facing certain situations that we may not believe…

    • 1468 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Groupthink can be detrimental. The Columbia space shuttle disaster from 2003 is an example. There were concerns that foam had broken loose during the launch and had possibly damaged tiles on the nose. Engineers informed NASA officials suggesting that the crew should do a “space walk” to examine it. However, the team in charge did not listen to the warnings.…

    • 195 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Kirst-Ashman states that groups progress through unique stages as they cultivate (2011). The unique progression of groups occurs in five stages which include “composition, beginnings, assessment, stabilization and working, and ending stages” (p. 101). Groupthink may occur in the beginnings stage. This stage allows for group members to discuss the reasons they are a part of their particular group. Individuals in their respective group are still getting accustomed to one another (Kirst-Ashman, 2011).…

    • 221 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As Robbins & Judge (2009) note, group decision making is often more time consuming than individual decision making, and can open the door to the phenomena of groupthink and groupshift, which can degrade a group’s ability to objectively arrive at a quality solution (p. 302-304).The nominal group technique, the use of electronic meetings, and the inclusion of the idea of covenant in forming groups are several tools available to help mitigate some potential pitfalls of the group decision making process. Nominal Group Technique The nominal group technique allows individuals come up with their own ideas…

    • 766 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics