Arguments Against Compatibilism

Great Essays
Joseph Parker
Philosophy 101
Prof. Hughes
May 14th 2015
The Compatibilist’s Greatest Defensive Arguments The issue we find between the Libertarian and Hard-Determinist is in perspective. You may be looking at lineage and be a hard determinist from that perspective or the Libertarians view from the persons own journey but if the Compatibilist’s are right then we can find an assurance in the understanding the whole picture rather than just part of it. In the event we look at social structures we are normally born into a class and our parents decisions of the past will be reflected somehow during the lifetime of the child. This child is usually going to be held by society to be like their parents no matter it be a good parent or a negative
…show more content…
Career decisions are usually based upon prior actions and decisions. It can be that even family line has held into the decision of career in one’s life. Going back to education for a consideration we find that the boards of universities can hold an effect on a career journey just based upon the decision to admit or not. The family one is in can also determine the kind of career one leads towards as well. This topic as does the relationships relate to a total historic analysis even though we usually don’t knowingly address the analysis. Each time we see this we must consider the setting and motives that may drive the decision but as it is it is strongly determined as a whole. We may think we are deciding on a career when we already have it made for us well in advance due to our own history. This directly relates to how we identify ourselves. Some will have problems as time goes on with employment due to identity and personal history were others may find it easier to achieve the goals they are seeking in the career life. This is something we find that happens all the time and is in practice as we read this. Not one person is in their current job of their own free will. This is something that is decided before we were even born as the idea of socialization would imply. Family plays a deep part in how we make up the ideal career choice and also deals in the …show more content…
Some will be born with defects while others are born with little complications. Some will face learning difficulties as will some excel at academics. These determined factor as well as race, and social standing of the family are things none of us choose ourselves. Let’s think to the answer to the question why someone would choose a life that is filled with more struggle and the convincing answer is that they wouldn’t. Biology is one area we can clearly see this act of determinism played out but it does not exclude consequences. This is not some obscure thing but one that can be observed in the practices of the sciences. In politics there is the trends that lead out of the past decision thus we find a need to address the failures and enhance the successes. This concept by its whole definers are of the compatibilist persuasion. This is one where we must hold the accountable for their short-comings for the lack of addressing some needed issues. In our modern time we can see the swaying shifts between the two major parties. One must not expect that we are to exclude accountability but that we understand the impact of the past upon the present. This is a necessity to keep us in forward momentum in our

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Without passion, people just go through the motions. I partially disagree with Dekalb Walcott’s outlook on success in his professional career. Just like Alore, Walcott is passionate about his work. In fact, he loves it so much that he is “looking forward to pass this torch down” (Isay 59) to his son if he is “fortunate enough to have one” (Isay 59). Although there is nothing wrong with multiple generations sharing the same passion for one occupation, I do see a problem with dictating where your future child will be in the workforce.…

    • 874 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Fiorina suggests that this technique seemed to work well for parties prior to the reforms in the 1960s and 1970s and notes how the system is faltering today without it. Thus, he upholds it as the necessary vehicle of political participation in the United…

    • 1655 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Before delving into the positions, it is important to understand the red and green filters on the model. These filters represent the how the individual is relating to others in this proposed theory with the internal voice represented as green and external voice represented as red. These filters are based on Baxter-Magolda’s (1999) theory of Self-Authorship, which explain the concept of by listening to the external, such as family or teachers, and following formulas based on what these external factors expect. As an individual moves through Baxter-Magolda’s (1999) stages, they begin to think and perceive the world according to their internal foundation. As the positions are explained, it is critical to consider how external and internal factors…

    • 1818 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this article, W.T Stace defends the view of compatibilism, which is also known as “soft determinism.” He argues that every event in one’s life is inevitable and is the result of past affairs, which also leads him to the belief that free will is indeed consistent with determinism. Near the end of the article he also explores the notion of moral responsibility and it’s compatibility with free will. Stace begins by briefly outlining the significance of free will because if someone has no control over their actions how can they be punished or rewarded for the way the act? He believes that many people entirely deny the concept of free will.…

    • 1040 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    When I chose to enrol in philosophy 1000, did I choose freely ? There are many arguments that say different things. The thing that sucks is that there is no clear answer, which is the same with most things to do with philosophy. But there are some with stronger arguments. Throughout this essay we will cover free will, Libertarianism, Determinism/Fatalism and compatibilism/soft determinism.…

    • 1630 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Raising a Radical Child In some situations, it appears as if a parent makes a carbon copy of themselves in their children. The children are raised with the traditions of the family and taught to behave a certain way, therefore believing and standing firmly behind their family’s values. Each family has their own ideas about what is right and wrong and see different ways of taking on tasks. As children grow up, they learn to like or dislike the same things their parents do. The way a parent feels about certain issues or treats certain people generally makes the children feel and act the same way.…

    • 762 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Essay On Som Determinism

    • 1415 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Throughout my adolescence, I was raised, taught, and encouraged to believe that I have free will and I am held responsible for my actions. On the other hand, not many people were raised, taught or encouraged to believe the way I was. Most people believe they are not held responsible for their actions. There are external factors in which we have no control of and our ability to do things differently is limited. This means that if an external factor is causally determined, then your ability to do something differently in a situation is nowhere near your control.…

    • 1415 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Compatibilism Essay

    • 448 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Compatibilism is a response to the problem of freedom and responsibility in a deterministic world because it is able to successfully reconcile freedom and determinism. Compatibilists accept what determinists say about evety event being the direct result of another event; they just include our free will because although some parts of our nature are determined for us outside of our control (likes, dislikes, temperament, etc.), our ability to make moral decisions depends on nothing but our own free will and ourselves. Many compatibilists accept the view of a causal chain of events going back indefinitely in time, consistent with the laws of nature, with the plan of an omniscient God, or with other determinisms. As long as our own will is included in that causal chain, we are free, they say. And they think causality in nature is related to the very possibility of reason and logic.…

    • 448 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Reflection On Genograms

    • 3729 Words
    • 15 Pages

    Reflection The career and educational backgrounds of my family members are topics that have often been discussed with my parents and I over the years. Therefore, the most difficult aspect of constructing the genogram was illustrating it in a word document. However, the project did give me an opportunity to further reflect upon the differences between my parents’ families, such as differences in work roles, life roles, and the importance of education. My mother’s family placed a greater emphasis on education and was more progressive regarding the importance of higher education and careers for women than my father’s side of the family.…

    • 3729 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Everyday Americans are challenged with the choice of making the right decision, whether one person robs a bank and kills an individual along the way, a police officer risking his own life to protect the lives of innocent citizens, a couple accused of murdering their new born child and dumping the body on the side of the road, the choice is yours. Americans are blessed with the power of free will, you are in charge of the choices you make and the consequences that come along with them. You are the master of your own fate and you are responsible for your future. You are in charge of yourself, the choice is yours on how you plan on living your life. Everybody wants to be free and everybody intends on creating the most extravagant life they possibly…

    • 1076 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Are we free? On one hand most of us have the clear mindset that we are, we feel and act free, we feel like we make all sorts of decisions, good or bad that lead to both beliefs (that we are and that we’re not free) but it has yet to be proven that somebody can just decide to change his or her beliefs in any which way. But, consider knocking someone out, or, for another example, I donate wheat to a third world country on a whim, just because I feel like it. This view that humans are more than capable of making entirely free actions is known as libertarian free will, or in other words the belief that some human actions are freely chosen by the person. To be perfectly clear, libertarian free will is nothing like political libertarianism, however, people who accept libertarian free will could be anything from political libertarians to socialists, they just think that we can act freely.…

    • 913 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    My Family Life

    • 2110 Words
    • 8 Pages

    My dad’s career when he met my mom he work in the steel factory in Chicago he became a carpet layer and after that he began a government job as an electrician, he worked until the day he died. He was successful in my eyes taking care of us. Our parents encourage us to work and listen to what we had to say about or career not they did not say much about our choices they would make suggestion were never disappointed in what we did.…

    • 2110 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A decision that changes a course The guiding quote on this essay was uttered by Robert Frost, “The Roads Diverged in a Wood, and I Took the one Less Travelled by, and that has made all the Difference.” This quote really triggers my mind and resurfaces some past memories about the decision I had made. As a poet, Frost wanted to show how a unique and isolated decision can help transform our lives. From my point of view, this quote acts a summary of my teenage life depicting a hard and a challenging decision I had to make in order to reach this far.…

    • 740 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the unit “States of Consciousness”, we discussed the concept of conscious will, and whether our everyday actions are determined by the choosing of our own free will, or if our conscious experience in making choices is merely a delusion of grandeur. It’s difficult to distinguish between voluntary and involuntary actions, especially if we are unaware of the extent to which we have free will. The idea is that we are already in motion of preparing for action before we even realize or actively decide we want to carry out said action. I couldn’t help but think of my Theory of Knowledge class back in high school, comparable to that of an introductory philosophy class. Similarly, we talked about free will, and to what extent we were capable of making choices based on our own consciousness.…

    • 420 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dangers Of Career Passions

    • 1302 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In this day and age new job seekers need to find a job in order to support themselves. A job is a short-term way to work for money, whether that person chooses to work at McDonald’s or go to find a job in an office. A career is a field in which one gains new skills and adapts to the job market in order to sell their services and have a prosperous life. An example is a doctor or lawyer; both going to school to develop the skills needed to practice their field. When picking a particular career each person must make sure that the field in which they devote so many years of their lives is meaningful and well payed, or else they take the risk of feeling regret, and a melancholy view on life as if they could have done something better with their…

    • 1302 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays