Compare And Contrast The Neo-Classical School Of Criminology

Improved Essays
The Classical school of criminology has been associated to philosophers Marchese Beccaria and Jeremy Bentham (Irving & Mendelsohn, 1985). The Classical school of criminology was a body of thought that majorly impacted the criminal justice system through the transformation of crime and punishment. Beccaria believed that the best solution for crime was punishment (Taylor, Walton & Young, 2003). The main solution to crime is the use of punishment. Consequently, responsibility was given to the government. The Classical school of criminology encouraged social control (Taylor, et al., 2003). The Classical school encouraged the state to react and be responsible of the criminal. The state was accountable for punishing the offender and providing public …show more content…
The new school of thought now considered the state of mind of the offender. The Neo-Classical school of criminology considered if the offender was mentally ill, a minor and or insane/incompetent would be considered in determining the offenders state of mind (Taylor, et al., 2003). Evaluating the circumstances of the criminals’ mindset were used in confidence to reduce complete responsibility. The state of mind for each criminal made the courts consider how punishment should be applied. Moreover, courts were now encouraged to treat irrational offenders leniently. The motive for this was that these offenders were incapable of telling the difference between right and wrong (Taylor, et al., 2003). Irrational offenders were perceived as individuals that lacked normal intelligence. The Neo-Classical approach outlined the need of psychological treatments. The reformed school encouraged the legal justice system to evaluate the state of mind of criminals which involved the use of psychologists. The school of thought acknowledged crime was out of the control for selected offenders’. The theory encouraged the state to acknowledge the offenders past …show more content…
Rational choice theory best explains why crime occurs. Hayward (2007) explains that this theory considers offenders to be rational individuals that plan their crimes. Offenders take into consideration the pain and pleasure he or she may have to deal with. The offender evaluates the risks before he or she decides to break the law.
There are many factors taken into consideration when individuals commit crimes such as, the punishment one would receive, the success they would receive and who it would benefit. Crime is broken for personal reasons, it is a cost benefit analysis (Hayward, 2007). The offender determines the advantage of criminal behaviour. Rational choice theory assumes that an individual is egotistic (Boudon, 2003). It is perceived that an individual who commits an unlawful act is mainly concerned with only themselves. When considering the current news story selected I argue that the 32-year-old man who decided it was okay to rape a 10-month-old infant was rational and aware of his

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Over the years, criminologists have endeavoured to explain the causes and suggest solutions for youth criminal behaviour, through the use of criminological models. Pre-modern explanations were rejected by new theories because these theories fundamentally believed in rationality and humanitarianism. The purpose of pre-modern explanations was to identify, a connection between the individual and society; the reasons for disorder and an implementation of sanctions of those individuals who breached the existing norms of behaviour. Most pre-modern explanations relied upon spiritualism and naturalism. The modern models were criminological theories which were developed during the period of industrial modernity to explain offending behaviour.…

    • 154 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Over the course of five years, the Jodi Arias capital murder case and trial captivated a country. The salacious nature of the case, the relationship between the victim and the perpetrator, simultaneously mesmerized and repulsed the public, and attracted intense media coverage. The details of the actual crime are grisly; the physical evidence and crime scene photos make several facts perfectly clear; this murder was intense, brutal, and vicious. The level of violence in the commission of the crime was mercilessly cruel and excessive.…

    • 925 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For many decades and centuries there has been a debate within the criminologists population about the causes to become a criminal. Throughout time, people have tried to come to a conclusion about what could be the cause for crime. It was perceived that there was one single cause for someone to commit a crime, whether it was robbery or murder. The reason in the 17th century would be that, the accused is possessed(Causes of Crime). As technology and society advanced, many criminologists began to have a different perspective.…

    • 1172 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Cesare Beccaria and Jeremy Bentham were the founders of the classical theory phenomenon (Piliavin, 1986). The concept was based on several principles, which entailed three main ideologies; free will, where actions are based on one’s own rationality (Burke 2014), more so punishment should apply to the crime as opposed to the criminal, as the theorists believed that a certainty in punishment would deter both the public and criminal (Akers 1999). The perspective adopted throughout will focus on the theories inability to justify the actions of violent homicide offenders, such as Jeffrey Dahmer, and how the high recidivism rates fail to support specific deterrence, even when making the punishment fit the crime. Free will assumes that all individuals…

    • 1622 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Positivist Theory Positivist theory was created from positive philosophy and the influences of practical science (Bohm & Vogel, 2011). Positivists rejected the established philosophy of Enlightenment thinkers (Bohm & Vogel, 2011). When society went through significant changes during the American and French revolutions as well as a middle class that united in strength and the Industrial Revolution is when positive philosophy took its roots (Bohm & Vogel, 2011). Saint-Simon was a socialist who has been referred to as the founder of the positivist theory.…

    • 2460 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In simple terms, rational choice theory is the view that crime is a function of a decision making process, in which the potential offender weighs the potential costs and benefits…

    • 721 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Philosophy Of Punishment

    • 1032 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Beccaria suggests, each person has the “Free Will” to make a choice on whether or not to commit a crime. Additionally, Beccaria examined the effects of “Hedonism,” in which a person determines their course of action to be the most pleasurable versus the most painful (Seiter, 2014, p. 15). Examining the Classical School of thought, which dominated our way of thinking, when dealing with criminals, until Cesar Lombroso created the “Positive School” in the nineteenth century. This particular thought process suggests, “People commit acts beyond their control"; it also . “linked criminality and physical traits” (Seiter, 2014, p. 15).…

    • 1032 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The two classical writers were focusing on the reform of the legal and penal procedures rather than explaining criminal behavior. In the process, the two came up with a theory that has huge relevance in today’s criminology. The drive of the classical writers was to change the prevailing law systems, penalties and courts in European countries since they were marred by whimsical and biased decisions. The common feature was use of torturous procedures to get confessions and cruel punishments such as mutilation, inappropriate whipping and public hanging (Jeffery, 1959). They aimed to establish a better and fairer system in the legal and judicial sector.…

    • 1445 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    This idea of crime and criminal acts is what we know as ‘Neoclassical or Economic approach’ to crime today. As mentioned above, people choose criminal over non-criminal alternatives in the same way as they choose some economic activities over other in the market…

    • 1364 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “A surge in killings has moved Hamilton up to the fifth highest murder rated metropolitan area in Canada as of 2013” (The Hamilton Spectator 2014). According to Statistics Canada, there were 15 homicides in Hamilton that year (Statistics Canada 2013). One of the 15 murders in the Hamilton area was that of an Ancaster man by the name of Tim Bosma. Mr. Bosma was murdered on May 6th, 2013 during a test drive of his truck by Dellen Millard and Mark Smich after his truck was offered for sale on Kijiji. Many biological, psychological and sociological theories of crime could be applied to explain the desire to commit murder but in this case, Social Learning Theory and Rational Choice Theory offer the best rationalization (O’Grady 2014, 81-83, 99).…

    • 1294 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In: NEWBURN, T, Criminology. 2nd ed. Routeledge, pp. 170-176. The crime in which an individual commits will have strong negative effects on the healthy minds of society. It almost disturbs their feelings and consequently triggers a need or desire to fight back or seek justice in order to restore them back to their healthy state of…

    • 1262 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Summary Criminology studies the reasoning and factors as to why individuals engage in criminal activities. In classical criminology, social philosophers Cesare Beccaria and Jeremy Bentham developed a theory of crime that criminologist and theorist still use today (Akers 2017). In classical criminology, an individual commits a crime by making a rational decision. That decision is based off of whether the benefits that one might receive by offending outweighs the consequences such as being caught and cited or sentenced. Individuals base their decision to offend or not offend on what they have seen others suffer, their knowledge of what consequences they may endure and their own personal experiences.…

    • 1142 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This essay will be an extension to the short answer question that will compare and discuss, two theories within criminology, these are Classicism and positivism. Starting it with a brief introduction to each school of thought with the theories and their theorist. Throughout to discussions about what are their key differences are to the end conclusion. Positivist and classicism approach to the theory of criminology were both very powerful in their definition and approach with how to deal with crime and criminal punishment. These two theories are rather different, however they contain similarities, such as bout of them influence criminal system, share same idea that criminal behaviour could be controlled or that they both focus on punishment…

    • 1411 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This essay will discuss classical criminology, commonly referred to as classicism. The first part of this essay will clarify the main features and concepts of classicism, including rational choice theory, free will, social contract theory, deterrence, and proportional punishment. This essay will then further analyse these theories and identify any limitations and problems associated with them. This will give a better understanding towards the concepts that surround criminology. Classicism emerged and developed in Europe in the late eighteenth century (Lilly, Cullen, & Ball, 2002).…

    • 1268 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In criminology, there are three main schools of thought-classical, positive and conflict. Each school of thought has a different viewpoint from one another, almost drastically so. Classical criminology believes that crime is committed when the benefits of committing a crime out weight the risk, such as imprisonment. Positive criminology theorizes that other forces, such as their psychological traits and social status, affect criminal behavior. The conflict view of criminology believes that wealthy and high ranking people in society use their power over those less powerful to control their lives.…

    • 790 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays