Samuel Huntington Clash Of Civilizations Analysis

Improved Essays
Samuel Huntington's "Clash of Civilizations" is one of the most influential articles that is used by policymakers in formulating foreign and international decisions. However, It is also one of the most controversial articles at the time for it claims that a religion will be the main reason for future conflicts. This article has attracted a lot of criticism from many different academics and scholars, predominantly from fellow Harvard academic Edward Said, who is the speaker of the lecture " the myth of the clash of civilization."The speaker criticizes the "clash of the civilizations" because it is a recycled version of the "cold war" theory, oversimplified the classification of different civilization groups and, it separates the culture from …show more content…
The speaker has raised some valid points in pointing similarities between the article and the cold war theory, but has failed to grasp the concept of civilization conflict and competition. He ignores other examples of other civilization conflicts such as China's rush to economically colonize Africa, for he focuses only the west and the Islamic civilization standoff, being that he is from Palestine and the time when article was written is filled with a lot of anti-western sentiment in the Muslim world caused by key events such as the western aid to Israel, the growth of the mujahedeen in Afghanistan ,the Yugoslav breakup wars and etc. The speaker has also used straw man fallacies to support his claim, for example, as Huntington is a partisan, he automatically labels ever other civilization as anti-western civilizations. Also, the speaker has used a genetic fallacy to strengthen his position for since Samuel Huntington used news journals and not academic sources of information, he automatically shows prejudice because news articles are subject to being sensational and biased to suit its audience. Another example of …show more content…
This is a valid point but, the speaker has failed to understand the importance of religion in determining your cultural identities, which shall lead to the creation of fault line wars, for example Yugoslav breakup is mainly attributed with the rise of cultural identities. The speaker has yet again used a red herring to talk about how official culture is different from actual practice of culture, for their many rebel cultures that disregard official cultures practices. In conclusion, the criticisms put forth by Edward Said is raises a lot of valid points such as ''clash of civilizations" being similar to the cold war theory, arbitrary in its classifications and unfair for separating religion from culture. However, the speaker has failed to grasp several key points such kin country syndrome, inter-civilization conflict and cultural fault line wars. The speaker has also resorted to using various fallacies to strengthen his claims, but has failed to address the article itself

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Huntington and supported by Fouad Ajami in his latest view. These flaws are discussed by Edward W. Said in The Clash of Ignorance. In this article, Said mentioned that the notions of “civilization identity” and “the interactions among seven or eight [sic] major civilization” that are introduced by Huntington are vague. Said also disagrees with the methodology that Huntington uses in deriving the facts as Huntington just relies on the article by the veteran Orientalist Bernard Lewis in The Root of Muslim Rage. Besides, Said believes that these two articles intensity the small spark of problem between the major entities which are Muslim and the West as if it is the most complicated issue in the modern culture.…

    • 886 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Religion's Role In Wars

    • 1081 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The Bahai practitioners were persecuted by the Muslim hierarchy because the Bahai believed Muhammad was not the last prophet. Although their religion has expanded, they have been particularly persecuted in Iran. Although the Bahai faith was essentially the same as the Muslim faith, their contradicting beliefs is Muhammed led to their persecution. A country with a strong belief in Islam could not accept a differing ideology. Passionate religious practitioners have commonly believed that it is the will of “God” to wage war in order to spread their religion.…

    • 1081 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, by doing so, ecclesiastics had to build a complex argumentation to avoid mention the principle of the Devil and became lost in it, creating more confusion than clarification. Additionally, it meant that God was now responsible for evil, a theory that thinkers had been trying to discredit since the beginning of the religion. Despite all their efforts to maintain Christianity afloat, it just could not be done, skeptics soon had the upper hand and Satan bite the dust; the Devil suffered the blunt of the attacks as people began to think that evil came directly from humanity and not from an external source tempting the…

    • 709 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Effects Of Islamophobia

    • 1492 Words
    • 6 Pages

    It was obvious that that the Christian’s would make Islamic religion sound terrible since their goal during that time period was to convert as many people to Christianity. Historian Karen Armstrong talks about the misconceptions about Islam, “‘The West misunderstands Islam largely because we 've got a deep cultural prejudice that is as deeply ingrained as our anti-Semitism, which developed alongside it from about the time of the Crusades. We 've got into the habit of projecting our own shortcomings onto Islam, just as we did upon the Jews.’”( Russell Gonzaga, Americans Misunderstand Islam, http://www.galegroup.com). What Armstrong is saying is that getting the same treatment they gave to the Jewish people. In the twenty-first century race is no longer a factor in determining if someone is Muslim since a lot of people of different color can convert to any religion.…

    • 1492 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Evil In Religion

    • 1666 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The rise of evil in religion has been documented in many ways and forms throughout the years. in recent years’ different religious groups claimed terrorist attacks. Tensions have been building for quite some time, and we have arrived at a crossroad. We can either choose peace or war. In this day and age, it is more important to understand religion than in the years past, because if we do not we will undermine religion entirely and cause further divide between cultures.…

    • 1666 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    The British did not agree for a reason, the founding fathers were not clear. Dershowitz claimed that Keyes insulted so many individuals that fought against cruelty, those who may have been Christians, Buddhists, Shintoists, or atheists. Keyes is attacking great individuals thinking somehow religion has a correlation with human rights. “Look, I don't know whether God exists. I don't know that.…

    • 1371 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In fact some of the worst catastrophes during the last century were carried out under commandments of religion in the name of native socialism (Huntington 1993). Basically, humans will have confliction about anything they feel firmly about from politics to who has the best sports team. Religion gives a place to confrontation because of so many questions on which one is right. The only way to reconcile between the two is to recognize that, at most, religion contains two very different aspects. One clearly separates humans and the other might be able to make humans come together.…

    • 1036 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Meaning Of Jihad

    • 2259 Words
    • 10 Pages

    The words and its meanings have been twisted and misinterpreted by Muslim scholars stating it as a law that refers to struggle against all those who do not believe in the Islamic god often referred as Allah and do not acknowledge the importance of Muslims. There have been a lot of debates of over what people believe the meaning of Jihad is. In this debate of stating which definition of Jihad is correct, the very true meaning of Jihad has been lost. The true meaning as the Quran states, Jihad is a practice of eliminating evils or evil practices of Islam and educating people about Islam. Today this has changed to believing that Jihad has a military meaning.…

    • 2259 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As religions grow, many interpretations come up, particularly during a time of crisis. However, many contend that organizations that have a theology which is founded on hate do not represent any of the traditions in Islam. Many devotees of Islam argue that Islam is a religion of peace. The truth of this assertion may not be entirely accurate; this is because many militant groups carry out their activities through based on a puritanical strain of Islam that is known as Jihadi Salafism. It can be described as a medieval interpretation of Islam that developed when the Arabs were not in good terms with the Europeans as well as the East Asians.…

    • 830 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There are so many stories and news reports about riots and fights around the world with religion and gays. It’s sad to think that a person can shun and disrespect another because of who they classify themselves as. They think that everything in their religion is true, so they decide to corrupt society instead of making everyone happy and wanting peace in life. Most of the wars start because of religion, because others don’t believe in that, or that they think they are the right ones following the right…

    • 1319 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays