From What Went Wrong Summary

Good Essays
From What Went Wrong: the clash between Islam and Modernity in the middle east by Bernard Lewis, the foundation myth of different religion is one of the most important factor that result the clash. The Foundation myth of Islam and Christianity have difference on progress of preaching in founder’s life time. This difference cause separation of state and church are hard in Muslim. It also prevents the change of rules and social aspect. It has also change the coverage of the religious law. The Foundation myth have one of the greatest impacts on difference of history of religion. First, the foundation myth between Islam and Christianity have difference on progress of preaching in founder’s life time. From Chapter of the Book, the author describes the difference. Jesus was murdered in his preaching and crucified. However, Muhammad have win the battle against the old government and able to rule the society before he died. The author said that, “In a word, he ruled, and the story of his decisions and actions as ruler is sanctified in Muslim scripture and amplified …show more content…
the Christianity have division of state and religion in the bible. Because Islam have found a country before Muhammad died, the religion structure and state are fused. The clergy also have sociological sense, and the priest is also a teacher. However, Christianity did not have state, since it is found in the Roman Empire, they have to divide the state and law. This is author called “native secularism”, lay a foundation for the secularism and separation of the state and church later. Author wrote that “Muhammad was, so to speak, his own Constantine.” This later make all secularism attempt fails. The author wrote “the attempt to impose what one might call ecclesiastical constraints on political and military authority failed, causing the retreat of the pianist into either radical opposition or quietist withdrawal, accompanied by a certain disdain for public

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    The Great Awakening Essay

    • 868 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Separation of church and state is essential to avoid preferential treatment to any one religion. Even today, we are faced with challenges of religious sects trying to impede on the moral and civil liberties of men. In Lund v.Rowan County, the commissioners have made derogatory remarks towards non-Christian believers creating a atmosphere that harasses religious minorities. We can look across the world see the damage tyrannical followers of religion can do. Religious uniformity takes away our religious freedoms and impedes on our civil liberties.…

    • 868 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Consequently the Christians began the Crusades which ravaged through the land and still have a lasting impact on the region. Perhaps the most influential examples of disunity in Islam is the split between Shi’a and Sunni Muslims. This conflict roots back to the death of Muhammad, and who should have control over the caliphates. Sunni’s believe that the rulers of the caliphates should remain in the family,…

    • 1705 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Effects Of Islamophobia

    • 1492 Words
    • 6 Pages

    It was obvious that that the Christian’s would make Islamic religion sound terrible since their goal during that time period was to convert as many people to Christianity. Historian Karen Armstrong talks about the misconceptions about Islam, “‘The West misunderstands Islam largely because we 've got a deep cultural prejudice that is as deeply ingrained as our anti-Semitism, which developed alongside it from about the time of the Crusades. We 've got into the habit of projecting our own shortcomings onto Islam, just as we did upon the Jews.’”( Russell Gonzaga, Americans Misunderstand Islam, http://www.galegroup.com). What Armstrong is saying is that getting the same treatment they gave to the Jewish people. In the twenty-first century race is no longer a factor in determining if someone is Muslim since a lot of people of different color can convert to any religion.…

    • 1492 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Religion's Role In Wars

    • 1081 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The Bahai practitioners were persecuted by the Muslim hierarchy because the Bahai believed Muhammad was not the last prophet. Although their religion has expanded, they have been particularly persecuted in Iran. Although the Bahai faith was essentially the same as the Muslim faith, their contradicting beliefs is Muhammed led to their persecution. A country with a strong belief in Islam could not accept a differing ideology. Passionate religious practitioners have commonly believed that it is the will of “God” to wage war in order to spread their religion.…

    • 1081 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In his writing he clearly indicated that it was the war of Christianity against Muslim. He sees this bitterness between Christians and Muslims which left behind by series of crusades was because of the invade of Christianity to suppress the faith of Islam with series of brutality. In his writing,…

    • 345 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Colson says that, “On the surface this shortcut might seem an appealing answer to America’s declining morality. It is, however, simplistic and dangerous Grider 3 triumphalism”(Colson 343). The conflict between the power of God and man show in our politics, the ability to successfully introduce and intertwine religion and government would take time to work. However, sadly I believe we are too far for a new system, but I know with this new presidency things will change, whether better or good. After reading Colson’s view I wonder what he would of thought about this upcoming residency, but I believe that he would see it as a good step away from liberalism.…

    • 735 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    After the Crusades ended, the Protestant Reformation commenced. During the Protestant Reformation, the Roman Catholic church split into multiple denominations and, consequently, led to the foundation of the modern western civilizations. Christianity also has unethical believers that are deemed domestic terrorist. These groups include the KKK, the Westboro Baptist church, and the Army of God. In Islam, there exists a similar past of holy wars known as Jihads.…

    • 825 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    It was because the battle for Jerusalem had been motivated by religion and those who fought believed it was mandatory to fight for the Lord. Pope Urban had also described Muslims in his speech to be a “wicked race”, a “vile race” and those who “worship devils” (Urban 1095). Those against Christianity only angered the Crusaders since Muslims and non-worshippers were against the Christianity. The rewards of fighting in the war and religious fanaticism for Christ had led to what we know as the First…

    • 1426 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Uncertainty In Iraq

    • 3356 Words
    • 14 Pages

    Contemporary Salafi (sic) Sunni Islam is more like the militant brand of Protestantism of the late 1500s that denounced intermediaries between God and the individual and actually attacked (sic) and destroyed shrines to saints and other holy figures, where pleas for intercession were made. The Sunni Muslim are mainly to the north and east while the Shiites Muslims reside mainly to the south and west of Iraq splitting the country into two (Fisher). One can imagine the tensions between the two while they both struggle for power of the state. Additionally, units must use special consideration of the majority of the populace and the Soldiers have different religious beliefs. The argument, my God or belief is better than your God is or belief will be a common rally point to both the Iraqi and the unit Soldier and it is imperative that a commander does not get caught up in this and…

    • 3356 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    However, Paul the apostle, illustrates his power and commitment to produce an impact on Christianity though vigorous teaching. The teaching to the gentiles results in the rise of martyrdom and legalization of Christianity during the Roman Empire. Furthermore, his teachings affect Christianity for the past two millenniums. For instance, Muhammad, the creator of Islam, shows interactions with Christian and Christianity in his early life and his ruling of the Muslim. Even though others may argue other apostles, Jesus, or other characters has the most influence in Christianity history, there is no one who has the influence that Paul has, his teaching during the Roman Empire spread across the world to different culture groups, and still maintain a huge effect…

    • 1153 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays

Related Topics