Cask Of Amontillado And Barn Burning Analysis

Improved Essays
Me, Myself, and I. Judge, Jury, Executioner. How far would you go to receive the justice you thought you deserved? Would you simply just go to the police or would you take matters into your own hands? Would you commit a crime in order to bring someone to justice? Most citizens would just go the police and let the law provide the justice, however there are many instances in which citizens, being dissatisfied with how the law serves its justice, take matters into their own hands. These citizens however are often providing justice to a crime with more crime and are often not in the right state of mind. Both Edgar Allan Poe’s “The Cask of Amontillado” and Willian Faulkner’s “Barn Burning” deal with crimes that essentially go unpunished and with the emotions that accompany these crimes. The narrator’s point of view in each of these short stories shapes determines how much the readers know about the motives for the crime, the crime’s basic circumstances, and the extent to which the crime is justified. In Poe’s “The Cask of Amontillado”, the protagonist, Montresor, has long puzzled readers with his motives for his murder of his rival, Fortunato. Montresor claims that Fortunato insulted him and dealt him a …show more content…
The narrator’s point of view in each of these short stories shapes and determines how much the readers know about the motives for the crime, the crime’s basic circumstances, and the extent to which the crime is justified. Overall, it seems that serving justice yourself can be a risky business, leaving you either feeling guilty the rest of your life or almost dying trying to prove a point. It is ultimately just better to refer to the law to serve its justice and to let more responsible, level headed people deal with the situation at

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    With this in mind, the producers of Dexter make both a idealistic and realistic claim: the ideals of modern justice are catching criminals and penalizing them for their crimes, yet because the legal system and the people who serve it are flawed, the producers seek to critique the definition of justice and who has the right to enforce justice. This claim is most prominent in a flashback scene wherein, the…

    • 784 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Not only is the judge thinking about the victim during sentencing, but the jury can be sympathetic to the victim, as well. According to Zaykowski, Kleinstuber, McDonough (2014), they state that “although the Victim’s Rights Movement has led to advances for victims of crime, the use of victim impact evidence in criminal trials remains controversial due to the suspicion that such evidence enhances punitive attitudes and arbitrariness in capital sentencing outcomes” (p 1). The article continues to discuss the Victim’s impact on the case. If the judge or jury can sympathize with the victim, the sentence will be harsher. They explain that a victim who can be considered an Ideal Victim, can influence the judge and jury to the point of sentencing.…

    • 786 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This awareness is the root of mercy. Criminals are just like everyone else in the way they make mistakes. What’s different about criminals who are held accountable for their crimes (and there are many criminals – especially on Wall Street – who are not held accountable) is that society defines criminals by their worst mistakes. Our worst actions should not define who we are. Although it makes sense for safety reasons that violent offenders are incarcerated, we should make incarceration more humane.…

    • 701 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    With convicting people, there is the fact that authorities’ job is to find the criminal. This seems to be equal to having the need to blame someone for the situation. If a bystander appears to be near the crime scene and has a record as well as a specific race, he or she would, unfortunately, have the fault. People believe this is very common today, although there is no certainty that this is the case. Society thinks the worst of a person when given the opportunity, we are known to become subjective, which is normal although it leads to a false verdict.…

    • 1069 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Rehabilitation perspective believe that all criminal behavior is caused by some factor in your life. They believe that the choices criminals make are based on there surroundings and how they live there personal life. They believe that when people are characterized as being exposed to delinquents and lack parental support they are more likely to become criminals. There point of view doesn’t deny that everyone makes there own decisions but they absolutely don’t go into a irrational choice of pure “free will.” In order for someone to change the way they view things they would need to have been in a circumstance where two perspectives where demonstrated . This perspective views crime as a something that is rarely free willed and that is why particular individuals can be rehabilitated.…

    • 1645 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The problem with this is that the Criminal justice system, which many people in society respect, hires the people who convict the innocent alleged suspect (MacFarlane, 2008, p. 2-5). These same people under the Criminal justice system are the same people who, society sees as people who should protect and serve us. The Criminal justice system is a system of law enforcement with the responsibility of prosecuting, defending, arresting, and punishing those suspected with committing criminal acts. However, police and lawyers only want to fulfill their duties and they lack the knowledge and process to thoroughly gather evidence and convict the right criminal. The issue pertaining to how wrongful convictions affect the criminal justice system is thereby hurting the integrity and breaking the trust between society and the system.…

    • 1699 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Anomie Theory

    • 1515 Words
    • 7 Pages

    It is certain that crime is in a current society today, is difficuilt phenomena that has puzzled researchers for many years. Theories that aim to explain the cause of crime and understand the criminal behaviour of an individual are often evaluated for being biased in their research studies. Many has been of big influence and seen to explain the cause of crime but none has fully interpreted the reason of why people commit crime. Merton anomie theory discovered how social structure exert pressure upon certain individual in this society to engage in certain groups, in other word his goal was to see whether low working class commits crime because of how they were categorize by social standard. Criminal behaviour is build a cohesiveness role within society.…

    • 1515 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this essay the two criminolgy theories that will be compared and contrasted is the Self- Control theory and the Routine Activity theory. These are two extremely well known and popular theories in the field of criminology today. The Self- Control theory refers to the lack of self-control a person or offender has which can lead that person to commit different crimes. Offenders will commit crimes without even thinking about the consequences. The Routine Activity theory refers to the fact that daily activities or routines people have create perfect chances for crimes to be commited against them and their property.…

    • 1330 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many theories can be used to explain or even excuse criminal behavior, but in the end Eric Smith had the final say in whether or not to commit murder or not. Criminologists have developed many theories to help explain why juveniles commit crimes. Theories are not concrete solutions to why crime occurs, but it helps to give an understanding to why juveniles commit crimes and who may be predisposed to a life of crime. In the case of Eric Smith, Eric can be associated with a variety of theories developed by professionals in the fields of criminology and human…

    • 1062 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The idea of a trial is for a victim to get justice and for a criminal to be punished for his or her crime. The way that the punishment is decided depends on the jury and on the judges chosen to listen to the case. The novel The Stranger by Albert Camus is based on a man who is charged with premeditated murder and sentenced to death by guillotine. The book starts off with the death of the central character, Meursault’s, mother. In the very beginning of the book we are introduced to Meursault’s peculiar behavior.…

    • 1490 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays