The Case Against High School Sports?

Improved Essays
Many people around the United States believe that high schools sports are a much needed activity for kids. On the other hand, some people argue that sports in America have too many conflicts with a kids life. In October 2013’s Atlantic cover article, “The Case Against High School Sports,” Amanda Ripley argues that American student-athletes became less educated while playing a certain sport. Low test scores and sports have no correlation to each other; American student-athletes gain many benefits from playing sports after school including increased test scores and lower dropout rates, decrease in risky behavior, and having a competitive attitude in everything they do.
Amanda Ripley writes that many countries outperform the United States on international
…show more content…
If sports interfere with the academic side of school in America, then we would see a negative relationship between academic achievements, and athletic commitment. A study done by the University of Arkansas’s Daniel H. Bowen and Jay P. Greene shows us different findings. These two professors examined this relationship for five years in Ohio public schools by analyzing student-athletic participation as well as sport winning percentages compared to graduation rates and standardized test scores. The study showed us something very interesting. When different schools committed more time and money to their athletics, there was a significant and positive impact on test scores. Also, there was a positive impact on dropout rates (Greene). Kelli Anderson, author of “The Power To Play,” states that “Girls who compete in sports get better grades, graduate at higher rates and have more confidence.” This study goes to show that sports have a huge positive impact on not only people’s academic life, but also social life. Confidence is a huge key to success. It can open doors and give a person opportunities they might not have ever had before. When a person has better grades and more confidence in themselves, then anything is truly …show more content…
Susan Degnan, author of “Our Children Our Future” recorded a study done by coach and police officer, Bill Hawley. Hawley is a police officer in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, and he runs a truancy program for a Juvenile Intervention Facility. When kids are caught skipping class, the school brings those kids to him. One of the first questions he asks the kids are, “What do you do for extracurricular activities?” In his findings, about 70 percent of the kids are not involved in any activities. “If you don 't allow them the time to hang out, they don 't have as much time to get in trouble," Hawley said (qtd. in Degnan). Hawley’s study gives us an idea that sports are very much needed to keep kids out of trouble. Also, sports give a person the ability to let out expression and controlled aggression. By letting these emotions out of your body during sports, a person may seem less stressed out at home or school. The teenage years are the hardest on a human. Sometimes kids make the wrong choice. The teen years are an age when some children turn to drugs and alcohol, and many of them turn away from sports. With the study of Bill Hawley in mind, it is important for a child to stay in sports, and stay away from the risky

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Summary and Critique In Amanda Ripley’s article, “The Case Against High School Sports,” she insists that sports have an insignificant role in schools and, consequently, harms students, their performance in school, and the schools themselves. Ripley believes that students without sports programs benefit from the exclusion of sports and schools can also benefit or improve with the excess funds from sports (1-3). While Ripley’s argument has some merit, at least at first glance, the main ideas are lacking solid evidence and are cherry picked. Ripley believes that schools in the United States that have a sports program are immediately behind other schools academically and the students are more likely to focus on sports than they are academics.…

    • 744 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sports and School? Sports and School? Which one weighs the other one more? Many people would say it’s not even close school and academic is so much better for a kid than participating in a sport in high school. In the article “Have Sports Teams Brought Down America’s School?” Elizabeth Kolbert is urging for schools to out sports, so there will be no distraction when it comes to academic learning.…

    • 878 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Districts and schools across the country are debating whether or not they should have competitive sports. Some people say organized sports can build self-esteem. Others argue competitive sports can lower it. Schools shouldn’t support organized sports for young children. Competitive sports can injure undeveloped children, stress kids, and become expensive.…

    • 620 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    By the end of their first year, most athletes acknowledged that their athletic- related activities affected their academic performance” (Adler and…

    • 1053 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For some time, schools have been debating whether they should get rid of sports to help students improve their education. Many studies have found that schools that provide after school athletics are shown to have a lower academic rate. Therefore, school sports should be cut off because they are a distraction from school work, cost a great deal of money, and cause fatigue. Many student athletes know that their extra-curricular sports may take away from their education.…

    • 391 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    After school sports are taking away several kids opportunities for their future. Although a lot of people think after school sports are great for students education and physical health; many studies have shown that after curriculum sports will distract them from their school work. Therefore, schools should get rid of after school sports because campuses will save money, kids would not be distracted and students will get higher grades. Many schools are spending so much money for after-curricular sports, when they could be spending this money on academics. According to an article by Amanda Ripley; she interviewed Ernest Singleton of Premont Independent School district who said that “he realized they could save 150,000 dollars when getting rid of after-school sports’’(10).…

    • 511 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Amanda Ripley argues in her article “The Case Against High School Sports,” that sports interfere with a student’s life in a negative way. Ripley believes that schools are not putting enough focus towards their educational aspect. She focuses heavily on the fact that the cost of keeping these sports funded is far too high for them to stay in place. She believes that if America is to remain competitive with other nations, sports must be taken out of high schools. Although Ripley provides new insight on the issue that schools are too involved with athletics, she does ignore some of the factors that make them worthwhile to keep.…

    • 1341 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Of all the aspects of high school, participating in sports is a mutual interest of the students. High school sports are events where students can showcase their talents, learn valuable life lessons, and stay active in their years of adolescence. “In The Case Against High School Sports,” Amanda Ripley argues that high school sports should be terminated because they are expensive and prioritized over education and safety. The author argues that high schools should get rid of sports because they are too expensive.…

    • 725 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The first article I read was “The Case Against High School Sports.” The author, Amanda Ripley, explained how high school sports are minimizing the school budget, and causing there to be less money distributed towards academic funding. Another main point is made around how students are not being as successful due to the level of involvement in sports. This article discussed logos such as the cost of education versus sports. A student pays $328 for a math education whereas a cheerleader will spend more than 4 times that much by paying $1,348.…

    • 872 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Around the world many would say that American sports are taken much more serious and are much more involved than other countries. Some critics argue that the superiority of sports in America conflict with other issues such as in “The Case Against High School Sports” by Amanda Ripley. She makes a bold statement arguing that high school sport students become negligent in education within the American society. However, there is no correlation between low test scores and participation in sports in America; after school activities such as sports keep students out of trouble, and being involved in sports teaches students the lesson of balancing major conflicting events. Amanda Ripley argues that sports in America is why education in the United States has lower test scores than other countries such as South Korea and Finland.…

    • 826 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Research done by The University of Missouri compares the GPA of an athlete vs. non-athlete. The group of athletes was determined to have a higher GPA, averaging 3.25. “The non‐athletes averaged a GPA of 3.01, significantly lower than the athletes” (Stegall “A Study In the Grade”) .To continue to participate in a sport, most teens have to maintain a certain grade…

    • 803 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    At first glance many people think that sports are too time consuming. Many experts have done studies that show the positive impacts sports have on children. Sport participation in school does not worsen academic results despite taking time away from class (Maximizing the Benefits of Youth Sport). Athletes know that they don’t have as much time to do schoolwork, which makes them more motivated to use their time for school. Students that aren’t athletes don’t use their free time for school which makes them less likely to do quality schoolwork.…

    • 1498 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Sports takes away that extra time that the teenager could be getting into trouble and instead gives them a chance to make lifetime friends, raising their self esteem or focus more on their academics. Organized sports can give teenagers a chance to be involved in something and to feel included. 1. Context and Assumption of the Dispute a. After reading many articles about the subject of sports and how they keep teenagers out of trouble, I begin to see both sides of the argument.…

    • 1585 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Sports in Schools: More Than Just a Game When the purpose of high school is broken down, it is easy to determine that it is developed to prepare us for the next stage in life. For some it’s college, others it’s working in retail, some start their own companies and others it’s playing professional sports. While that list barely scratches the surface of possible routes one may travel after high school it illustrates the vast options that are available. So it is the duty of the school to prepare each student to the best of its ability no matter what path they may lead after graduation. The Author, Amanda Ripley, is someone who strongly disagrees.…

    • 1079 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Sports In Education

    • 2037 Words
    • 9 Pages

    In American schools for example, sports play an important role in academic success. Therefore, American education system has included sports in education system for the development of scholars’ social interactions, physical, emotional, and mental health, as well as for attaining academic success. According to Gems and Pfister, sports have a direct effect on academic success (172). Equally, Basch study supports the role interscholastic sports in social, cultural, and economic development (629). The value of sports in American education system is not…

    • 2037 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays