The Case Against High School Sports Analysis

Improved Essays
Athletics and Academics: The Perfect Companions In “The Case Against High-School Sports”, author Amanda Ripley argues that public high schools are spending too much on their sports programs at the expense of academics. While athletic programs can be costly, they pay back what they cost in their benefits to the school and the students. A school without its sports teams is a very dreary place. High schools should keep their athletic programs because of what they bring to the school and the students. Good sports programs teach valuable lessons to players, unite a school, and encourage academic performance in players. Students who participate in a sport learn lessons and skills that …show more content…
Ripley argues that sports take precedence over academics, the purpose of school, in high schools (74). While this is a valid view, findings by the University of Arkansas’s Daniel H.
Bowen and Jay P. Greene suggest otherwise. They examined the athletic participation rate and schools’ sports winning percentages in comparison to graduation rates and standardized test scores in Ohio’s public high schools over a five-year period. Their study found that participation rate and winning percentage are positively related to higher test scores in addition to lower rates of high school dropouts (Bowen and Hitt). Roger L. Whitley of Currituck County Middle School performed a survey of North Carolina high schools over a three year period. He found that the educational performance of athletes is better than that of non-athletes. His findings held true for both genders and across all races (229). In light of this, schools should be pushing for more athletic involvement. The evidence points to the fact that athletes tend to outperform non- athletes. As both these studies show, sports improve academic performance, not hinder
…show more content…
Athletes are also required to pass 5 of 6 classes per semester and be on track for graduation to be eligible to play. Alcovy gives out a scholar athlete award to the student with the highest GPA in each sport. A major advantage of athletics is that it gives students the opportunity to earn athletic scholarships. This provides some students with the only way they will be able to afford college. Also, to get a scholarship, they have to have good grades.
When teachers have problems in class with a student, whether it be grades or discipline, a lot of the time the coach is the first person they go to. Coaches are the best form of discipline for any Davidson 3 student; no one wants to run laps around the football field until even his or her coach gets tired.
Athletes are given all this extra help because of the extra time demanded of them by the sports they are involved in. Players that do not meet certain academic standards will not be able to participate in the sports they love to

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Summary and Critique In Amanda Ripley’s article, “The Case Against High School Sports,” she insists that sports have an insignificant role in schools and, consequently, harms students, their performance in school, and the schools themselves. Ripley believes that students without sports programs benefit from the exclusion of sports and schools can also benefit or improve with the excess funds from sports (1-3). While Ripley’s argument has some merit, at least at first glance, the main ideas are lacking solid evidence and are cherry picked. Ripley believes that schools in the United States that have a sports program are immediately behind other schools academically and the students are more likely to focus on sports than they are academics.…

    • 744 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Nick Satan Research Paper

    • 1353 Words
    • 6 Pages

    On January 11th 2016, Alabama football coach, Nick Saban, won his 4th national championship for Alabama. The University of Alabama is projected to make well over $100 million dollars, solely from the success of the football team this season. Commonly referred to as Nick Satan and the Nicktator due to his charming personality, Saban is scheduled to make more than $7 million dollars just this year. Derrick Henry, the Heisman winning running back who carried the ball over 400 times this year will be paid nothing, even though he is the one risking his life every Saturday. This injustice is what plagues the NCAA, and collegiate athletes all over the country.…

    • 1353 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    College sports has gained some serious popularity among Americans these past several decades. This has led into increased profits for the National Collegiate Athletic Association and the participating colleges which have fueled the debate if these college athletes of today should be compensated in other ways other than their athletic scholarships. College athletes being compensated for their on the field performances is quite absurd since they are receiving a free or nearly free education at a higher learning institution. Paying these college athletes would undermine the main role of universities which is to offer an education and present golden life opportunities. The lifetime skills and education that athletes receive while in college cannot…

    • 968 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In her article, “The Case Against High School Sports,” Amanda Ripley argues that sports should not be connected to high schools in America. In her argument, Ripley argues that sports lack economic efficiency, increase violence and lower learning levels in American high schools. While Ripley’s argument is well researched and explained, her argument ignores several key factors that also influence American high school sports. Firstly, Ripley compares the American attitude on sports with that of other countries.…

    • 1211 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    College Athletes Paid

    • 1246 Words
    • 5 Pages

    How will sports help later in life when so little of these students do not go into professional sports. What would help them even more is a college degree. It is noted that the college sports are nothing like the high school sports. There is an increase in intensity and demand for the players time, it tries to mimic a professional sports environment. A professional sports model will not blend in with the school environment (Gerdy 63).…

    • 1246 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Is free education enough to college athletes? Do colleges and universities exploit their athletes without even give them compensation? Years ago, being chosen from a university for being an outstanding athlete was a dream for most of the students wanting to have a sports’ career and a good education, but nowadays the debate over whether the student-athletes should be paid or not has been ... In fact, a group of former players “has filed an antitrust lawsuit alleging that student-athletes are entitled to some of the money the NCAA makes off of using their names and likenesses on merchandise such as jerseys and video games.” () Critics of the schools’ system argue that student athletes do not obtain the sufficient benefits from their universities,…

    • 812 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Students that have been privileged with an athletic scholarship to play in collegiate sports have to understand that it is not a profession but a linkage to develop contacts with influencers and gatekeepers that will impact their future success into the national leagues or other areas of interest. These student athletes should not be concerned with receiving an annual salary or monthly stipend but focused on the most important component of obtaining a higher education which is to achieve academic success in a sound environment and develop professional skills to become an informed, efficient graduate and integrating those educational experiences into their profession as they make the transition after graduation. Any athletic student given…

    • 816 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Over the past 30 years the cost of college has constantly escalated and grown to the point where it’s becoming more and more unaffordable and less and less of a realistic option for Americans, leaving many students and parents wondering why does college cost so much? Tuition is the amount of money students pay to attend college. There are various fees inside tuition. Sports and clubs the cost to stay current and build new infrastructure factuality salary the money paid to teachers to compensate for their excellent work and to ensure the school runs well colleges hire administration, which includes presidents, deans, and etc. every year over twenty million Americans walk through the doors of college seeking a better education and a chance at…

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Introductory Paragraph For many years, schools have to ensure fitness for students. According to many universities schools have had decreases in money because of school sports. Therefore, schools should cut school sports to reduce loss of money, to relieve stress they will have more time to do homework instead of having to go to long games and practices so students don’t have to stress about their grades, and gain as much knowledge as possible gain much knowledge while enjoying it. Body Paragraph…

    • 478 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In today’s world, sports are embedded in American school districts more than ever before. Although many students rely on physical activities to relieve their stress; studies have concluded that they are blocking the study time for tests, causing intelligent students to fail their classes. Therefore, districts should get rid of after class sports because athletic programs put a heavy financial load on the community, physical exercise causes distraction from learning, and students will have more time to get their homework done. The immense costs of physical activities have made many districts conclude that they should be spending their money on better education rather than sports.…

    • 472 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Casues of the Rising Costs of College Many parents have the dream of their children graduating high school, and continuing on to graduate with a degree from a college or university. They believe that with a college degree, there child will find a well-paying job and be successful in life.…

    • 721 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    As an American society, the nation has accommodated to the presence of sports, both in the household and in the modern school system. Everyday students hear of the triumphs of their classmates through sporting and even some teachers participate in conversations about sports during a class period. No matter how you look at the spectrum there is no denying that sports are important to the day to day lives of most students. The real question is, is it really affecting our educational system negatively? Some believe that high school sports have an adverse effect on students because it takes away from academics however, sports should be affiliated with school systems because they teach students teamwork and competitiveness that assists one to excel…

    • 125 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    When the term “student athlete” comes to mind what are some of thoughts that pop across people’s heads? Do they see someone who is always lifting weights, the popular kid in school, or a so called “dumb jock”? These are some of the stereotypes that we have of athletes. Sports have more of a positive impact on children that can improve many aspects of their lives. “The potential for sport participation to improve graduation rates, keep students in school longer and increase daily attendance should lead administrators to adamantly support interscholastic sport.”…

    • 1498 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ripley also stated that when sports in the Premont Independent School District in Texas were cancelled, “during the first semester, 80 percent of students passed their classes, compared with 50 percent the previous fall” (11). This shows that after school sports should come to an end because students are doing better in classes when they are not preoccupied with their after school activities. If students want to receive higher grades, schools should eliminate their sports so children can focus on academics.…

    • 470 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Being a student athlete is a wonderful thing in high school, despite a lot of people only acknowledge the athlete part and not the student part. I believe that academics come first and if a high school student wants to be an athlete, then getting good grades should be a requirement. It should be mandatory for teachers and coaches to check the grades of student athletes weekly to determine whether students are performing academically well or not. The students that aren’t doing well should be dismissed from any further games and practices until their grades improve. It is important that student athletes maintain good grades because the work that they put into their school performance carries with them through life, putting too much of an emphasis…

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays