Essay On Utilitarian Theory Of Punishment

Good Essays
The utilitarian theory of punishment fully supports disregarding the origins in sentencing the rioters. The theory specifically focuses on the future with respect to how punishing benefits society. Punishment is justified if society benefits more than the harm caused by punishing the criminal. There are four goals in utilitarian theory. These are specific deterrence, general deterrence, reform and incapacitation. The Bradford Riots produced great social harm. For the sake of the community, it is crucial that a riot of the magnitude that occurred does not happen again. In its fragile state, it is hard to imagine how much worse it can get if more businesses are destroyed and the economy further worsens. The unemployment rate is already staggering, (Look up what paper cited it to be). General deterrence is necessary to prevent this. To accomplish this goal, punishment to the rioters should be constructed harshly enough to deter the general public from rioting. Specific punishments? Others may argue that general deterrence ultimately will not deter the people of Bradford from rioting again because the social conditions that led to the previous riot have not been resolved. Therefore, it is foreseeable that overtime the oppressed will be pushed to their breaking points and riot violently again. It could even be argued …show more content…
Peaceful protests have an important role in society in exacting positive change, and these weren’t what Judge Gullick criticized. He criticized extreme violence that transpired during the riots. Sentencing is a method used to deter some crimes more than others. The court would punish the worst offenders so harshly that a significant portion of the general public would be deterred to enact the violent acts that the punished committed. Peaceful protestors will either not be punished or they will be punished

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    They will feel humiliated and will act out by blaming others. She believes instead of shame punishment, they should do community services which is better for them and the community. It won’t make the people feel horrible about themselves. In Dan Kahan’s essay, he believes that shame punishment is much cheaper than incarceration and that it will be less embarrassing than community service and jail. There are many ways on finding alternatives to incarcerations for nonviolent crimes but I disagree because a person receiving shame punishment won’t help them change their behavior and will negatively affect future decisions.…

    • 1518 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    All believed in the principle of rationality and that human’s act upon self-interest. Thus meaning they weigh up the costs and therefore deterrents should be created to outweigh what would be gained from the crime. For example the death penalty viewed by classical thinkers such as Beccaria and Bentham is seen as pointless as there is no deterrent (Brown, S. E., 2010). They gave an alternative perspective to the spiritualistic view that had dominated the European justice system centuries beforehand (Vold, G. B. et al., 1998;). This view was justified through the theory that people who commit a crime, commit a sin against God.…

    • 1195 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Baltimore Riots

    • 784 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The riots were simply the respective communities expressing their feelings that black men are often mistreated by police officers. I think that both riots had the positive intention of bringing more awareness to this issue and trying to get the national media talking about the issue but I think that there are better methods that might lead to better outcomes. At the time a riot can seem like a good way to show the government that people are seriously upset about an issue, however the aftermath can leave a city in shambles. Many businesses are destroyed during riots, some of them are small businesses where the owners don’t have the financial backing of a major corporation and it can be incredibly hard for them to rebuild and restart their business. Many riots may start out relatively peaceful, considering it’s a riot, but often they have no leader and people feel that they can do whatever they want because a riot is going on then the city is forced to recover which can take years sometimes.…

    • 784 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Criminology Theory Essay

    • 1147 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Or another example, what a person committing a white-collar crime which is extremely overlooked and is occurring as we speak but once again the problem of our criminal justice policies and the way our world works we care about more of the heinous crimes that involves murder, robbery, arson and theft. Whereas a white-collar crime can completely destroy a country as you see which is going on in America now and we are a debt and unemployment reason extremely high that is just an example of how social control theory would best explain the criminology theory and how it would inform the criminal justice policy. In conclusion some may say the juvenile system is horrible whereas…

    • 1147 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    I feel this way because there are crimes in this would that if anybody thought of doing that being sentenced to death should cross there mind. The utilitarian theory is a perfect example of how I feel capital punishment should be looked at. I feel this way, because of the reasons behind the theory. Since it is forward-looking and hopes to deter further criminals from committing the same act it shows that the main focus is not the killing itself, but the future criminals who might commit the same act. Anyone can give their own opinion on which theory is morally right, but when it comes down to which theory is best for society utilitarian theory is by far the best.…

    • 817 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Since we have established that these offenders are making rational decisions, we should be able to sentence them appropriately, all the while, they understand the consequences for their actions. Secondly, by understanding their actions and theorists understanding why crimes are committed under the rational choice theory, we are better able to analyze reason by the offender for why they choose to do what they do. This helps us better deter crime in the future. “Unlike other approaches, however, which attempt to impose a conceptual unity upon divergent criminal behaviors (by subsuming under more general concepts such as delinquency, deviance, rule breaking, short-run hedonism, criminality, etc. ), our rational choice formulation sees these differences as crucial to the tasks of explanation and control.…

    • 1616 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The use of violence against masses is a common way to diffuse protests. However, is it an effective way? While it is quite common for police brutality to be enacted in order to stop protesters, it is neither a safe solution nor a permanent one. Protesting is one of the most basic rights of citizenship. Therefore, stopping a protest before it happens is not the answer, but stopping it before it gets dangerous.…

    • 867 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    One reason is because this law, among may others, are not being enforced. People can break minor laws with no consequences, so they begin to think it is acceptable to do so. Another reason is because people are becoming more and more carless. They are beginning to think that laws to protect others don’t matter, if it doesn’t effect them. The combination of these two things result in more people breaking minor laws; which in some people’s eyes is wrong, because breaking minor laws only leads to more chaos in the future— for if people can break minor laws with no consequences, surely breaking major laws, such as grand theft, is…

    • 659 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    #BlueLivesMatter is defending police by granting them protection from a hate-crimes as put their lives on the line every day and deserve protection, but the job is expected to come with many dangers but still the government prefers to protect them instead of the citizens. The #whitelivesmatter campaign comes across as racist and inconsiderate and may never count as a true campaign however it’s still a threat as it destroys the entire purpose of the #blacklivesmatter movement. All these campaigns caused the #blacklivesmatter to be negated and is now starting to disappear. Although the activist won’t let the movement die off, however, it is already disappearing. When will this movement finally succeed?…

    • 1818 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    New penology ideologies have removed the notion of ever living in a crime less world, which is understandable unrealistic to live in a world without crime. Though it is important to understand and always be trying to reach for a goal and if that goal is just to try to mange crime and of certain populations and areas in hopes of reducing crime, the results are going to what they have been lately with lots of tension between police and citizens. Which should not be the case citizens should not be afraid to go the the police, because if they are they what is point of having police. The ideology of just trying to mange crime instead of trying to remove it needs to be changed in order to see more positive changes in our correctional faculties, and with our…

    • 759 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays