Bell Curve Tolls Summary

Improved Essays
In “For Whom The Bell Curve Tolls,” Robert J. Sternberg reviews The Bell Curve and gives his input on points such as the nature of intelligence, job performance, and IQ tests. The Bell Curve was one of the works by Richard Herrnstein and Charles Murray that showed the public a deeper view of psychological science. It begins with the topic of the general factor of intelligence and how it represents all the tests around intelligence. There were two disputes that followed along the general factor. These were established as statistical and psychological disputes. In the statistical sense, it is said that the unrotated factor solutions raise the probability to a maximum of obtaining the general factor. In the psychological sense, Gardner argued …show more content…
Murray and Herrnstein for instance believe that IQ scores line up with what people mean when they say intelligent/smart in our ordinary language. IQ scores reflect a great deal of verbal ability, but it is questionable if the scores display the ability to problem-solve. Its reflection on social competence is out of the question as well. Steinberg shares the views on intelligence of many other researchers and concludes back to the idea that Murray and Herrnstein’s statement on intelligence is incorrect. Steinberg claims that IQ tests are only capable of measuring a part of what people mean when they refer to intelligent in our ordinary language. Something seen as intelligent in one culture may not be seen as intelligent in another culture. There is a cross-cultural difference between …show more content…
I think Steinberg does a great job at breaking down his points and focusing on specific parts of The Bell Curve that he wishes to criticize. He set up a great format in the beginning to middle where he would include quotes and ideas from The Bell Curve and then brings up his own research to counteract their points. The structure that he organized his article in made it simple to follow along with the topic of discussion. I found it slightly amusing how we would always conclude one of the authors’ points by stating that it was “factually incorrect.” One interesting point that intrigued me in the reading was the idea of intelligence and how the factors that compose it are still confusing. It is not as simple as intelligence being how smart somebody is or how well they do on tests. There are multiple things that make up intelligence and the IQ tests are not enough to measure a person’s entire range of intelligence. I find this topic relatable with the standardized testing that most schools go through. These standardized tests are given out to assess students on their knowledge and understanding. For the most part, students must pass these standardized exams to proceed onto the next grade level. I feel as if this type of examination is very similar to the IQ tests and its assessment of an individual’s intelligence. Some individuals may be extremely intellectual but lack the test-taking skills. This is why I strongly feel

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Gerald Graff's work, Hidden Intellectualism, is a display of hidden intellectualism in everyday life. In other words, education does not always come from schooling but is also taught from the world around us on the smallest level. In the article, Graff draws attention to what the typical view of what intelligence is often considered to be and why this is wrong throughout several repeated forms. A key strength of this article is presented right away through the debut.…

    • 839 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Another important factor is that the test was given at a mean age 27.2 years of age so all the subjects have gone through the same amount of mandatory education(kindergarden-highschool). 2. Reserchers used verbal and performance test markers using the Wechsler adult intelegence scale to measure and quantify intelligence scores. The study is both empirical and valid due to the fact it was quantitative and they used a common and up to date scale. 3.…

    • 289 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The IQ test is the test in which intelligence can be measured. In the last few centuries test scores have changed, or even increased. Psychologist and scientists are uncertain about why this is happening, either we’re getting more intelligent, or the IQ tests need to change. In the field of psychology there's one psychologist who is ready to show the world what human intelligence is really about, his name is Professor Flynn. Intelligence is an indirect process that humans use to explain the different degrees of adaptive success in people’s behavior.…

    • 240 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mike Rose, the author of “Blue-Collar Brilliance,” argues that intelligence is not something that is defined by formal education, but rather the use of critical thinking and experience. In his essay, Mike Rose uses a plethora of examples ranging from personal experiences, historical examples, and visual content to support his assertion. The argument that education does not equal intelligence leads to an important question: how can intelligence defined and quantified? Mike Rose disputes the notion that blue-collar jobs are simple and mindless in his essay.…

    • 1000 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    a) My thoughts to “IQ: History of Deceit,” was nothing really. It was informative and insightful on how the testing for IQ came about. It also showed how IQ has been abused throughout the years from the time of its inception to now and that it has happened in different countries; countries that were considered intelligent and respected for their accomplishments as well. IQ also seems to be effected by the interaction of both genetics and the environment in which one is nurtured and their surrounding stimuli. Now, the idea that IQ is predetermined by genetics is kindly understandable when genetics was first being broken down into what genetics was like in the early 1970s.…

    • 621 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Introduction Definitions of intelligence vary among scholars, theorists, and laypersons, due to its multidimensionality. However, intelligence typically involves an individual’s ability to learn from experience and adapt to the environment in which they live. I believe that the construct of intelligence should encompass an individual’s ability to effectively communicate in both written and verbal form, to think logically, and to express creativity. Two intelligence tests in which I recently had the opportunity to take and score included the Shipley Institute of Living Scale-2 and the Wonderlic Personnel Test.…

    • 1684 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Bell Curve Summary

    • 624 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Solutions designed to solve or mitigate any of these problems must accommodate, even be focused towards, the low cognitive ability profile if they are to have any hope of succeeding” (Herrnstein & Murray, 1994) the authors seem to place blame on races with lower IQ scores for the social issues of society. Furthermore, there are claims that immigrants with lower than the United States average IQ scores are less brave, less hardworking, less imaginative, and possess less initiative thus working as a detractor of the cognitive ability of the United States. Although many people rallied their opposing views of the book, several authors published articles, books and theories rebutting the theories on race and…

    • 624 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Malcolm Gladwell in the third chapter to Outliers, "The Trouble with Geniuses, Part 1", argues that those who have higher IQ (whom those have the higher intelligences than the average IQ standardization bar), are the onlookers for society, "[for] we must look for production of leaders who advance science, art, government, education and social welfare generally.(75)", Lewis Terman said to believe in. Gladwell supports his arguement by demonstrating both examples from given IQ test in the passage(s) by also describing how most geniuses and "Termites(74)" manage successfully in life by having a mindset that is far beyond most margins and commonly, outside the box. The author's purpose is to point out that, yes, most geniuses have a more "robust"…

    • 304 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Outliers Persuasion

    • 975 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In our world today, we place a lot of emphasis on innate intelligence and high IQ. However, in his book, Outliers, Malcolm Gladwell challenges our mythical idea of success. He argues that “the relationship between success and IQ works only up to a point”, and that other factors can play a greater role. I agree with Gladwell’s argument that IQ alone does not determine an individual’s success because I believe that qualities like economic status, work ethic, and mindset can be equally, or even more, important. I also believe that it is important that we move away from our old ideas of success because they cripple many aspects of our society, most notably our education system.…

    • 975 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Robert J. Sternberg and Howard Gardner are two incredible psychologists whom have had much success in their work. The fact that these two psychologists took an interest in the intelligence of others and break it down into a more knowledgeable frame, is outstanding. If you look at the main point of view, intelligence, you will see an interesting correlation to each other’s work and theories, but also, you will see a divergence. I would like to talk about Robert J. Sternberg’s Triarchic Theory of Intelligence and Howard Gardner’s Theory of Multiple Intelligences. There are many interesting concepts, similarities, and differences in their theories.…

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    These standardized assessments do not always assess all of what it is that make each individual special and unique. They should not be the determining factor of an individual’s true knowledge. Ho expresses how “smartness means…

    • 1722 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    How does one define success? People have different viewpoints on success. Some people usually think success is all about how much money you some people think success as you are being happy. In my opinion success is being able to support the ones you love, the ones who make you happy, and the ones who support you in your time of need. Many people strive to be successful however not everyone becomes successful.…

    • 1337 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The evolution of intelligence tests continues in order to find the ultimate way of measuring intelligence without aspects such as cultural bias, invalidity, and unreliability. Though it will always be met with arguments against any form of intelligence testing as intelligence is multi-dimensional and many feel it cannot be measured by a test. There is both positive and negative aspects of intelligence testing in schools but as Diane F. Halpern (PhD of Claremont McKenna College) perfectly states “We 're not all the same; we have different skills and abilities. What 's wrong is thinking of intelligence as a fixed, innate ability, instead of something that develops in a context." (apa…

    • 1112 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    As a society, when we define things such as intelligence in a cookie-cutter fashion, we are only hurting ourselves. When our school does this, we are only hurting our students into becoming one-size fit all members of society. As a culture, we should move away from these ideas into a more fluid education where we can teach students on an individual level rather than telling them to do things that might not be fit to their set of skills. In order for a more intellectually diverse society, our education system and the idea of intelligence needs to…

    • 1491 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    She also emphasised ‘g’ real-world correlates, particularly in work settings, and its predictive power of work performance, which, according to Gottfredson, the triarchic model of intelligence failed to do. Furthermore, Brody (2003) re-analysed data collected from the intelligence tests that are based on Sternberg’s triarchic model and found a strong support for the presence of ‘g’, which was not indicated by Sternberg. Furthermore, similarly as with Gardner’s theory, Sternberg’s supposedly independent intelligences were…

    • 1477 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays