The Astonishing Life Of Ota Benga Analysis

Improved Essays
In order to successfully pursue a career in the field of anthropology, one must possess an open mind and be prepared to dismiss all traces of ethnocentrism. Cultural anthropologists attempt to understand different cultures through the utilization of ethnography which enables anthropologists to obtain qualitative research through mechanisms such as participation and observation where they not only observe and record individuals of different cultures but may even participate in their ongoing activities. Additional methods include the use of key informants and interviews. While this field is significant in understanding human behavior in order to collectively solve pressing matters, some anthropologists fail to comprehend the damage they are …show more content…
The corruption associated with anthropological work is demonstrated in the discrimination against people of foreign culture. This is subsequently a result of a lack of comprehension and tolerance of deviations from the norm. In the article “The astonishing life of Ota Benga” by Pamela Newkirk, Newkirk demonstrates the injustice and unethical behavior that Ota Benga, a native inhabitant of the Congo was subjected to. Anthropologists and scientists disregarded his humanity and concluded that his analogous peculiarities to an ape were a direct result of the evolutionary bridge between ape and man. Ota Benga, a human, with equal autonomy, emotions, and thoughts to that of any human, was placed into an iron cage like an animal and sold for exhibition to the Bronx Zoo after first appearing at an anthropology exhibit. He was an object of observation and humiliation and was forced to endure the horrendous stenches that ejected out of his neighboring monkey’s bodies. All this for what anthropologists considered “the perfect example of culture and civilization” (Newkirk, 16). Ota Benga was confined to a cage because at the time anthropologists were highly fixated on what made people different and were evidently convinced that individuals such as Ota Benga indisputably exhibited the characteristics and capacities of those at the bottom of the ladder of cultural …show more content…
The article examines how natives become living specimens used for scientific study and display. In the case of Ishi, after surviving a series of atrocities committed against his tribe, he was later found and taken into the Museum of Anthropology where visiting anthropologists would come and study him. He also voluntarily served as the key informant of anthropologists though Schepher-Huges argues that he may have felt obligated to fulfil these services due to his illness, age and his uncertainty of security and welfare anywhere else. Additional harm may be portrayed by the work of anthropologists through the depiction of the astronomical amount of times Ishi was sent to perform as a living exhibit despite the evident knowledge of both his psychological and physical issues. Among these issues included Tuberculosis, PTSD, and an intense and penetrating terror of crowds (Schepher-Huges,16). Visiting anthropologist were overworking him despite his apparent weakness in order to once again benefit from his condition. Anthropologist and scientists also demonstrated extreme malevolence through their deceit in providing Ishi with proper cremation. Instead, selfish as they were once Ishi had deceased they took full advantage of his death and resorted to performing an autopsy on him and removing his brain for

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    While doing researchers, many anthropologists use the tool of ethnographic fieldwork. Instead viewing a culture from a bird's eye perspective, anthropologists insert themselves into the culture they wish to study. This is known as participant observation. However, when entering an unfamiliar culture and encountering unknown people, anthropologists first have to gain the trust of the people around them to learn about their lives. This is called creating rapport.…

    • 1642 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Anderson explains that as an ethnographer, he tries to represent his knowledge in a way that others will be able to comprehend. Through the use of his detailed field notes and interview excerpts from real life people, Anderson was able to clearly demonstrate this level of the…

    • 1200 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sofia Samatar’s “Ogres of East Africa” chronicles Alibhai Moosajee’s quest to collect information about East African ogres for his British employer. Samatar skillfully alternates between Alibhai’s official accounts of the ogres, intended for his employer, and his personal accounts etched into the margins of his catalogue. Samatar creates a two-sided story—one side intended to reach Alibhai’s employer and one side that will never be deciphered by him. The two sides of Samatar’s story represent the two opposing stories of imperialism in Africa. The imperialist’s story was one of conquest, power, and disregard for the indigenous people, while the indigenous people’s story was one of resentment and disillusionment.…

    • 1283 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Ape and the Sushi Master was written by Frans De Waal to get his beliefs across, as well as open people’s minds to the subject of animal culture and to get people in the mindset that there may not be such a large divide between nature and culture. De Waals goal within the book is to also get readers reflecting on themselves in a cultural aspect. It is very evident that people have a habit of separating things into ‘good’ and ‘evil’, and many people wouldn’t want to see animals as equals to us. An example of this was brought up by De Waal in the text when he talked about humans using apes as a source of…

    • 1009 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Brushing Away Bias In his article "Body Ritual Among the Nacirema" Horace Miner analyzes the exotic practices of the tribal society Nacirema, developing an intricate persuasive social commentary on the prevalence and effects of cultural prejudices and ethnocentrism on the sociological imagination. In addition to utilizing kairos, ethos, pathos and logos to exhibit that language shapes perspectives generated by cultural relativism. By writing from a different cultural perspective in a traditional manner of an anthropological study, Miner attempts to divulge the consequences of stereotypical American viewpoints on humanity’s ability to see from the outside in and bestow upon the reader a broader understanding of one’s own ethnocentric judgments…

    • 672 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Hortense Powdermaker, a world-renowned cultural anthropologist, spent her life studying the lives of others. She wanted to gain insight into cultures and societies different than hers. Throughout her lifetime, Powdermaker strived to give those who can’t always speak for themselves, a voice of their own. Powdermaker’s book, Stranger and Friend: The Way of an Anthropologist, highlights four different cultural contexts in which she did fieldwork over the course of her life as an anthropologist. Powdermaker conducted ethnographic research in Lesu, Mississippi, Hollywood, and Zambia, all of which are outlined in this book as well as other books dedicated to each specific project.…

    • 1902 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Kennewick Man Facts

    • 1782 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Americans Indians always questioned archaeological investigation because of their cultural values. On the other hand, archaeologists, moved by professional goals, regard skeletal remains and cultural items as educational tools (Peterson:116). However, it is essential for archeologists to consider ethical and cultural issues when doing research. There must be inclusivity and collaboration with the indigenous community during the process.…

    • 1782 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Most Native American tribes do not want burial remains to be studied or even removed from their location. The archaeologists and other scientists want to study the remains to fill the holes in history. However, the wishes of affiliated tribes should not be ignored. During the early 1980s, “…the scientific importance of excavating and retaining human bones outweighed any concerns of minority groups,” (Pearson, 2008). In fact, some archaeologists did not understand why the tribes were offended and not thankful for the scientific analysis.…

    • 811 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ethnographers contemplate human societies and social orders by living among the general population they consider, by overwhelming themselves inside the subject gathering in a procedure called participant perception. Although meeting and ethnography are frequently lumped together as "qualitative techniques," by comparing investigations of "culture in real life" considering verbal records with ethnographic examination (Shamuskhan, 2013). It has been demonstrated that the last routinely attempts to clarify the state of mind conduct issue" was consistently overlooked it. Since significance and activity are overall arranged and setting subordinate, we fight that self-reports of mentalities and practices are of restricted esteem in clarifying what…

    • 309 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    We are exposed to so much information and dependent on sharing this with those around us, and so the risk of lying becomes more prominent and therefore, the feeling of doubt, preceding to epistemic vigilance. It becomes difficult for anthropologists to have a rounded perspective of things via close observation. We may shy away from telling the truth, due to the worry of how we may come across, or what will be documented about ourselves. Likewise, the questions asked may be rather abstract, resulting in a vague answer. Consequently, ethnographic data is often flawed and inefficient, with the answers they acquire being motivated by the framing of the experiment and other uncontrolled variables, making it difficult to attain a scientific rigor, due to experimental bias, placebo effect, demand characteristics and confounding variables.…

    • 1691 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Observation is the most straightforward and convinced method in anthropology. When study the behavior of human beings, we want to figure out how friends communicate with each other without any conflict and how people get in touch with someone strange. By observing five people playing basketball on the court for 15 minutes, taking notes of their behaviors and conversations and making hypotheses of their thoughts and feelings, I get some gratifying feedback. People would like to get involve with others who have same hobbies, positions and characteristics to resonate. The strategy used by human beings forms different groups and, furthermore, various…

    • 102 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Kalow And Runaways

    • 1072 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Kalow’s fieldwork to develop a documentary is common in the collaboration in interdisciplinary modern anthropology (Seymour-Smith, 1986). Kalow’s central premise was to show the underlying causes of child homelessness and the day-to-day life of the runaways. Kalow’s fieldwork uncovered the elements of normalcy in the children’s lives rather than demonising the runaways through a focus on teen prostitution, drug use and adolescent alcoholism (Kalow, 1996, p.60). Both Kalow and Malinowski’s research endeavoured to remove unnecessary exoticism in their final publishing.…

    • 1072 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    It is these ideas that force us to question the subject of anthropology as a whole, extending our anthropological view ‘beyond the human’. Through his exploration of social dynamic of the Avila and their neighbouring villages in the Napo Province…

    • 1461 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The “Body Ritual Among the Nacirema” is a sardonic piece by Horace Miner that exposes Western civilization’s misconceptions of the behaviour and way of life of other cultures. He demonstrates how an etic or an outsider perspective can influence the perspective on the undetected culture. Miner introduces the Nacirema tribe who are to be perceived as an uncivilized culture with barbaric rituals. He highlights a few of the Nacirema body rituals which include the focus on the appearance and health of the human body, the holy mouth men, and medicine men. One of the main body rituals performed by the Nacirema is what Miner describes as “the focus of this activity is the human body, the appearance and health of which loom as a dominant concern…

    • 763 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Kohn’s approach benefits the study of anthropology and the process of obtaining ethnographies by placing importance on other living selves in addition to humans. Kohn expands the discipline by moving past the restricted and limited observation of human life. Kohn details the beneficial aspects of the anthropology of life, “The approach I advocate seeks to be attentive to the dander-fraught, provisional, and highly tenuous attempts at communication—in short, the politics—involved in the interactions among different kinds of selves that inhabit very different, and often unequal, positions” (Kohn 18). The majority of ethnographies focus on humans within an indigenous group but neglect their interactions with non-human lifeforms. By invoking Kohn’s approach, the study of anthropology is more encompassing of reality rather than interpretations alone.…

    • 839 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays