Analysis Of Dave Barry's 'Guys Vs. Men'

Improved Essays
Masculinity’s Crossroads The article “Guys vs. Men,” Dave Barry uses satire to explain the problems with masculinity and a new approach to how males should be classified and judged. The article “The Crisis of American Masculinity” by Eric Garland discusses his view of how the traditional image of manhood is dying in today’s society. Each of them give their opinions on what manhood is; the manner that society should treat males with, the importance of masculinity in males, and their opinion of the necessity of these masculine characteristics. Although they share a similar topic, they differ greatly in their views of males and masculinity as a whole. The authors give their perspective on males, society’s view of them, what role women portray …show more content…
Barry talks about the male need to compete in pointless challenges he writes, “Not long ago I was sitting in my office at the Miami Herald 's Sunday magazine, Tropic, reading my fan mail when I heard several of my guy coworkers in the hallway talking about how fast they could run the forty-¬yard dash” (918). He proceeds to talk about how they even went as far as actually competing in a race to see whom the fastest was running the forty-yard-dash. While Garland seems to suggest a level of discontent males seem to face working in an office job, with presumably no chance to prove their masculinity. He states very cynically, “Ooh. Manly. In fact, I’ll go out on a limb and say the last thing we want is for you to act like a man, defending his territory, irreverent toward authority, protecting his pride, willing to brave the elements of nature rather than go mad in captivity. Maybe that works in the movies, kid, but it’s not something for the office” (Garland 1). He feels men cannot find a sense of pride in their work when they are not in a position to show off their manly abilities. While Barry suggests men are content with proving themselves even through seemingly childish races. Garland belief that men may be feeling worthless due to their perceived …show more content…
When discussing the moral code of guys Barry goes as far as comparing guys to dogs in his article, saying that like his dog they know rules but do not know why they should not do things. Barry explains this as, “Guys are aware of the rules of moral behavior, but they have trouble keeping these rules in the forefronts of their minds at certain times, especially the present” (920). He is very light hearted and condescending of males, which help to show, he is comfortable with himself and his gender. Garland states his fear that without masculinity and men taking pride in their own manliness it could lead to many consequences. Garland writes, “But for men in crisis, men with no hope of power, no spirituality, no internal peace, no heroes, no past and no future- violence may be the least worst option” (1). He blames men acting out with violence on the loss of masculinity in our culture and concludes that a revival of masculinism is what will curb the tragedies he believes are a result of this. He urges men to find pride in the traditional traits that make them inherently

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Male Role Models Vastly Shape Young Men’s Views on Masculinity Where does one’s masculinity come from? This is one of the key questions addressed in Wes Moore’s book The Other Wes Moore. This book contains the coming of age stories of the author and another man named Wes Moore, who begin in similar circumstances but ultimately have two vastly different fates. The masculinity portrayed by Wes Moore and the Other Wes Moore’s male role models as they grew up led them to develop very different views of manhood, and their stories show that in the United States familial male role models play a large role in the construction of young men 's masculinity.…

    • 1206 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Madison Stine Calloway-Baxter Composition I 19 September 2016 Summary/Response: “Guys vs. Men” Dave Barry uses this essay to explain certain characteristics of guys and their behavior. Barry introduces the idea that “men”, is a term that holds guys to a higher standard by giving them more responsibility, having certain expectations for guys, and liking certain things or being a certain way in turn won't automatically make them men by doing these things. He continues on with providing examples of manhood and its unfortunate stupidity, as well as, providing a few positive aspects to guys. Barry describes specific characteristics with “Guys Like Neat Stuff”, “Guys Like a Really Pointless Challenge”, and “Guys Do Not Have a Rigid and Well-Defined…

    • 258 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Rod Ewdish 12/13/16 English 120 Professor Progar Men in Society Men go so far to prove what they fear than acquire what they truly desire. Throughout life, men are taught to be tough and to not express their true thoughts or emotions. The article “Bros before hoes,” written by Michael Kimmel, an American Sociologist specialized in gender studies, goes along and asks a number of men from different campuses and states what it simply means to be a man. What sorts of phrases or thoughts come to mind when someone instructs them to be a man. Richard T. Evans, a researcher of interdisciplinary studies, in “Faggots, Fame and Firepower” describes how most male shooters have been dismissed by their classmates/peers, both before and after their crime,…

    • 1909 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Barry Man Vs Man

    • 222 Words
    • 1 Pages

    Barry’s stance is to make the reader understand that there is a difference between being a man and being a guy. Barry introduces the idea that the term “Man” or “Men” is associated with many negative qualities in males (“aggressive macho dominators; not as sensitive, liberated, hugging drummers”) (940). The term “guy” allows guys to freely indulge in stereotypical characteristics; guys are simple beings that like doing neat things, doing pointless challenges, and do not have rigid and well-defined moral code. In his article, he mentions about young coworkers talking about which one of them can run a forty-yard dash in the fastest time. His coworkers were also bragging about how fast they can run and when he finally got sick of them talking,…

    • 222 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The depiction of masculinity between scholars can sum into one word, seen as not a real role, or even just an illusion for males to act a certain way. In the text A Man's World? Political Masculinities in Literature and Culture by Sauer and Starck was an analysis to decide argues the bases of how masculinity is an invisible barrier but has various depictions in literature and in politics. Sex, Paranoia, and Modern Masculinity by Kenneth Paradis states that masculinity is a social contract for a manhood with melodrama. Slaughterhouse Five by Kurt Vonnegut writes an anti-war book that describes masculinity, but he makes the characters not so beautiful, so people can’t copy it and make a movie of what they think war should look like.…

    • 1396 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    The article, “Men, Masculinities, and Feminism” explains that men can be privileged in society but still lose privilege because of certain characteristics that oppress them. The authors, Christopher J. Greig and Barbara A. Pollard (2017) elaborate this explaining that even though men have power based on their gender, their privilege is challenged and ranked within their sex. This can be seen by a social hierarchy that oppresses those who aren’t considered to be as masculine as other Men. Men are pressured by other men to perform actions that are masculine, such as displaying dominance by being aggressive, to secure a higher status. Throughout their life, they are constantly fighting to prove their masculine standing in society so that they…

    • 1285 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    While masculinity may vary in culture, there is a general consensus that all men must live up to being competitive, successful, and desirable. However, the ideology of masculinity is not inherited in ones genetics, it…

    • 1452 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the reading “Bros Before Hos: The Guy Code”, Michael Kimmel critics what it means to be a man and the “Guy Code” they are expected to follow. According to Kimmel, masculinity is a problematic social construct that invokes behaviors that men tend to follow unconsciously. The unconscious behaviors that men tend to follow is know as the “Guy Code” that is passed down to them when they were young. Kimmel claims that boys follow the “Guy Code” at a young age because they don’t want to be considered gay or in masculine.…

    • 1228 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Masculinity in The Kite Runner Gender roles have been the perforated lines within our society for centuries, holding us together while simultaneously possessing the ability to tear us apart. We’ve had these ideas of what it means to be masculine and feminine so engrained into our society for such a long period of time that even as we enter a much more progressive era they still seep into the way we raise our children. Traditionally, masculinity can be seen as a combination of three common attributes: strength, honor, and action. Strength is generally referring to emotional toughness and independence, honor to loyalty and generosity, and action to competitiveness and risk-taking.…

    • 1326 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As their expectations vary, men do not consider having power, what women think makes a man masculine, as masculine. Men have a “code”, known as “The Guy Code”, which holds “the collection of attitudes, values, and traits that together compose what it means to be a man” (Kimmel, 807). They uphold these attitudes, values and traits because homophobia puts their masculinity at stake. Homophobia is the fear that people might misperceive them as gay.…

    • 401 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Blues and Hip Hop are two styles that have vastly different cultures and are not always mentioned in the same breath. Blues songs are famous for their 12 bar format with sorrowful lyrical content, while hip hop songs have a free flowing form lyrical subject matter can range from street life to political issues. Although many consider these genres to be completely different, there are commonalities between the two genres that can bring them together. From the heavy, powerful drums to the sometimes painful and reminiscent lyrical content: the similarities are often surprising, but nevertheless evident. The similarities between blues and hip hop music are something that is not discussed nearly enough.…

    • 1975 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It discusses the importance of young boys having father figures to teach them about masculinity and the effects this guidance will have later on in life. It also discusses the ways in which the media influences societal ideas of masculinity and how these toxic ideas of masculinity can result in mental health issues like…

    • 852 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Alexandra Duma Professor Helen Kapstein LIT 316 Defying the Gender Binary in Luna Gender identity is the subjective understanding of one’s gender (Morrow 7). The way in which an individual forms a gender identity relies heavily on the socio-cultural environment in which one lives. Gender identity is different than biological sex and sexual orientation. Luna by Julie Anne Peters follows the coming of age story of Luna, a boy who struggles with gender roles and expectations imposed on him by his family from a young age.…

    • 1717 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Masculine Identity Essay

    • 1347 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The idealized form of masculinity in a given place, time, and culture is intentionally used to connote the hegemony involved in the patriarchal system of gender relations. Moreover,…

    • 1347 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is simply naïve to disregard the overwhelming influence that the media and literature has had over the public over the past century and more precisely, in our youth. As a society, we constantly twist ourselves to fit the mold presented to us through various media outlets (e.g. TV, movies, magazines, advertisements, etc.) and in literature we encounter in our lives for a multitude of reasons. Throughout time, men have been presented to fit very traditionally masculine traits based on a preconceived narrative as to what it means to be a man and how to present oneself in order to be perceived as manly by others. Media and literature have branded a hyper-masculine image of men that has in time become what is expected for young boys to follow––be it relayed to them or not.…

    • 1001 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays