Double Effect Case Study

Superior Essays
In regards to the Anna Pou case, I think that I would have made a similar decision with the information that Dr. Pou had at the time. In our textbook, it states that the remaining staff after Hurricane Katrina believed that “no further evacuation or help was coming to them (Pence 56).” Therefore, the staff decided to euthanize the remaining nine patients to avoid any unnecessary pain and suffering. Prior to making this decision, I would have contacted the administrators of Memorial Hospital and the parent organization of the hospital (LifeCare) in order to find a way to accommodate these patients without euthanasia. The lack of communication between the parent organization and the hospital staff seemed to be a defining factor with this case …show more content…
Even if the person thought that this bad effect could possibly occur, it is still an ethically sound action because that person was not intentionally aiming to cause harm. The bad effect was simply the unintended result of a good act. Some factors that are involved in the doctrine of double effect include: the action must be good or indifferent, the good action must not intend any evil, the good effect must not be produced by means of the evil effect, and there must be a proportionate compensation for allowing the bad effect to occur (McIntyre …show more content…
Overall, it seemed that Dr. Pou’s intentions were not to kill her patients, but instead to ease their mind and bodies during this stressful/dire time. Therefore, since she intended to relieve distressing symptoms from her patients and not to intentionally harm them, then her good action to help these patients would be ethically sound. When she chose to administer the morphine to the remaining patients, she may have foreseen that this could shorten the patient’s life, but her action was ethically sound due to the fact that she was not directly aiming at killing these patients. According to the factors that were discussed in the Stanford article on the Doctrine of Double Effect, the action was considered good, the bad effect was not intentional, and the good effect was a direct result of the good action. Although her actions cover three of the four conditions discussed in this article, I am unable to judge whether or not the good effect was sufficient enough to compensate for allowing these patients to die. I think that her intentions were very good, but I don’t know if the good effect compensates for these patients dying due to the fact that they could have been saved. If there was more communication between the hospital staff and administrator/parent organization, it is possible that this all could have been avoided, so I am unable to judge the last condition. Overall, I

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Physician—assisted suicide is when a physician provides a prescription for a lethal dose of medicine to a terminally ill patient upon their request. (http://depts.washington.edu/bioethx/topics/pad.html). It all started in 1906, when Ohio drafted a euthanasia bill, but failed. Since then Oregon, Vermont, New Mexico, and Washington have made it legal, and set protocol that allows terminally ill patients to choose when they die. Oregon’s law requires the patient to be at least 18 years old, a resident of Oregon, have a terminal condition with six months to live, and must be able to make the health care decision for themselves (http://public.health.oregon.gov/ProviderPartnerResources/EvaluationResearch/DeathwithDignityAct/Documents/faqs.pdf).…

    • 2292 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many wonder if euthanasia is right and moral and if it is not what should be done when being faced with this situation. I think the best way to look at physician-assisted euthanasia is through consequentialism and deontology. It’s important we look at the consequences of physician-assisted suicide because they are literally the difference between life and death. A patient that is gravely ill or in a coma may be diagnosed and given a time limit until death, however, some patients have surprised their doctors.…

    • 770 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For those of us who have not experienced such a thing, we cannot really know what our decision would be. Later in the study, Emanuel and Fairclough found that, 68.2 percent of oncology patients reported that they agree with euthanasia because of “unremitting pain,” while 49.7 percent also said they agree with euthanasia because of “functional debility.” The general public’s opinion also reflects about the same numbers as the oncology patients (Emanuel & Fairclough). It is pretty clear that euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide is a serious thought among terminally ill patients and their families. The public’s perception of physician-assisted suicide would be impacted if they knew the reasons why patients considered physician-assisted suicide to end their own life.…

    • 1539 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For this doctor, his personal thoughts came up following a lethal morphine injection. The uncomfort he felt after “helping” this man showed in the panicking tendencies, seeing the IV pole with watching eyes and saying he was innocent for not killing the man. Although the doctor was uncomfortable, he did exactly as the patient and family asked. So did this doctor murder his patient? In the doctor’s eyes he did, but it was for a medical reason, not a personal one.…

    • 686 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Could lives have been saved if patients had been transported to a building that had power to work ventilators also the ability to keep their core body temperatures lower? That we will never know. Some very bad decisions were made at Memorial during hurricane Katrina but euthanization was not one of them. As patients are rescued from Memorial they were not taken anywhere safer instead patients were abandoned on high ground such as on the side of the road and on the I-10 freeway cloverleaf. Five Days at Memorial is a must read for everyone.…

    • 431 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Ethical Dilemma in Nursing Regina Johnson Community College of Philadelphia Ethical Dilemma in Nursing An excerpt from Five Days at Memorial: Life and Death in a Storm Ravaged Hospital by Sheri Fink, depicts the events that occur during Hurricane Katrina as it unfolded for the individuals at Memorial Hospital. The authors write about the experiences of a group of health care professionals from both Memorial and Life Care, their patients, and patients’ family during hurricane Katrina. Many nursing professionals may have conflicting obligation when it comes to reporting to work during a disaster, however, it is the moral and ethical understanding that as a nurse they have a duty to their patient above themselves that compels them…

    • 1046 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    It is clear that the utmost importance in any medical context is the relationship between the healthcare practitioner and the patient. The duty of a physician is to adhere to certain principles of medical ethics namely the principles of respect for autonomy, beneficence, nonmaleficence, and justice. By examining the case study involving Dr. Nancy Morrison, one can observe that these principles are often ambiguous when referring to the issue of whether she committed voluntary active euthanasia or nonvoluntary active euthanasia. Thus, the thesis will aim to exemplify that ultimately Dr. Nancy Morrison was culpable for her actions. To give some context to the issue, Paul Mills was a 65-year-old individual suffering from terminal esophageal cancer.…

    • 1467 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Physician assisted suicide can be a morally and ethically conflicting topic. The act of a physician helping a patient die can be seen as an act of murder, or as an act of mercy. In John’s case, he has just discovered that he is terminally ill and only has six months to live. Ava, his counselor, is concerned he is not informed enough to make this decision, and she fears he may not be emotionally stable. These are common concerns when dealing with a dilemma like this.…

    • 1048 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Imagine you are going by your day as always. You are married, have children, and you are enjoying your life. Nothing seems wrong, but a checkup with the doctor leads to devastating news. You are diagnosed with cancer. That was the case of Janet Planet, “I was first diagnosed with breast cancer when I was 42.…

    • 1542 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Most often only the patient is discussed in the evaluation of the case for euthanasia. The physician also has rights as to perform the act they are being asked to perform. Physicians have a right to make the decision to agree with euthanasia or not. The physician has great moral and ethical decisions that need to be weighed. The physicians role as healer would ultimately be questioned.…

    • 770 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Assisted suicide or the right to die is an extremely controversial topic that has been talked about for decades. Assisted suicide is for terminally ill patients that know they will never win their battle and want to pick when and how they die, which is often used before their disease becomes intolerable. Over the last couple years this controversy has had a lot more media coverage because of people working to give it the attention that it needs. In the United States more people have been on the side of passing laws so that people who do assist do not get charged for the crime. One major story that was in the news that seemed to bring back more coverage of this topic was a young woman having to move to a different state just to have an assisted…

    • 1554 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Kevorkian Assisted Suicide

    • 1219 Words
    • 5 Pages

    A controversy in nursing I believe that is starting to come around to more people is the right to die law. There are many people that have been suffering in pain due to an incurable medical condition that comes to a point of not wanting to live. Since Kevorkian MD, there have been many people with medical conditions that are incurable. These people are those that are suffering in pain as their family watches. They feel helpless as there are currently no ways to help besides giving them more pain medicine to make them comfortable.…

    • 1219 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Case Study Nursing Ethics

    • 1692 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Nursing Ethics Nurses are obligated to have moral courage and to make ethical decisions daily, which is not easy to do. According to Vicki D. Lachman, moral courage is the individual’s capacity to overcome fear and stand up for his or her core vales and ethical obligations (Lachman, 2007). ANA stands for American Nurses Association; ANA developed the Code of Ethics for Nurses. " The code of ethics is the philosophical ideals of right and wrong that define the principles you will use to provide care to your patients" (Potter, Perry, Stockert, Hall, 2013, p. 4). Which nurses use as a guide to carry out nursing responsibilities.…

    • 1692 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Decision Maker Would you be able to “pull the plug” on a loved one? No one should be alone when making such a massive decision like this as well as when experiencing a death. When we think of children, we do not usually think about death. The article “When Living Is a Fate Worse than Death” by Christine Mitchell argues that doctor’s should have the control over deciding life or death for a patient. The author’s argument is ineffective because the text lacks in facts, is one-sided, and gives a negative tone.…

    • 798 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    On the morning of November 1, a young woman named Brittany Maynard ended her life in Oregon. Her diagnosis was brain cancer; doctors told her she had several years to live. Unfortunately, after further tests doctors informed her that she had about 6 months to live. She decided that she would choose to end her life after the pain of her condition became unbearable. She stated that being able to choose when to die allowed her to live (Slotnik).…

    • 1603 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays