The American Revolution: A Grand Mistake

Great Essays
My book, The American Revolution: A Grand Mistake, was written by Leland G. Stauber. Prometheus Books published the 276 page book in 2010. In this book the author described four main consequences of the American Revolution. His four main points are the dilemma of slavery, legislative union vs. purely voluntary federation, the American System of Government, and the mindset of Americans about the role of Government. Stauber wrote this book so that Americans can understand that the American Revolution was not as perfect as it may seem and had many dire consequences. In the book there areas many facts and evidences provided but it is clearly seen that the book was very opinionated and bias. Stauber began the book with an Introduction which briefly …show more content…
The American Revolution is a topic that many Americans have knowledge on and assume they know the whole story. The upcoming topic was written about in both the HIS-131 textbook and the book The American Revolution: A Grand Mistake. In the topic Stauber argued that maybe America could have had less slavery had they not revolutionized so early. He made this argument because after the Revolution the British went from pro-slavery to anti-slavery. When people think about slavery in the United Sates they do not think of the British as affecting that but they played a large role. America has a long history of violence between African Americans and whites because of slavery and racism. It could have all been ended earlier but we did have the American Revolution which separated us from the British. Also the invention of the cotton gin increased slavery from 700,000 slaves to 1.5 million slaves in about 10 …show more content…
It is very diverse from most books about the American Revolution. I found Staubers four main points interesting because when you learn about the revolution you go over the bad consequences but mostly focus on the positive consequences that came out of it. The book did use some diverse vocabulary such as “relinquished”. The chapters were well organized with subtitles.. I learned a lot from reading this book because it shows you another side of history that other books will not show you. I do feel that the author could have put less of his own opinions in the book. He used many facts and information but also a lot of opinion and it took away from the learning aspect of the book and was harmful to his credibility as a writer. In one part Stauber wrote “While the American Saga focused on triumph and success, was the American Revolution, rather, a case of premature full independence that resulted from the intervention of France in the context precisely of failures of statesmanship on both the British and the American sides?” which really gives the reader an input on how he feels about the subject .
The books greatest strength is that it is diverse compared to other American Revolution books which only say the positives or only the negatives of the Revolution. The biggest weakness of the book is that there was only four chapters, I feel that there could have been more information. The author also should

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    (Reader, p. 450) The extensive listing of grievances to the king just went to show how fed up the colonists were, and made the revolution seem justifiable under the circumstances given. In contemporary America, specific ideas from the Declaration of Independence may not appear to be of any importance to human rights today, as the natural rights – life, liberty, and property (also known as the pursuit of happiness) – are only briefly mentioned in the beginning of the document, but without it, America would not have been able to move towards developing its own rights for their citizens that would later be documented in the Constitution and its eventual…

    • 1152 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ellis’ main focus is towards the people’s reaction of the American Revolution and how it affected their ideology. Ellis is more interested in the social history of America. Ellis concentrated on the social ideology by including quotes from Jefferson, Hamilton, etc. The quotations are so effective because they come directly from the American leaders themselves and are seamlessly blended with Ellis's additional commentary. Unfortunately, by choosing to focus on only a few events, Ellis's book fails in that it lacks somewhat of a scope.…

    • 1060 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Why Is History Important?

    • 811 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Winning in the American Revolution meant no longer being ruled by the British monarchy, which gave the newly established government the ability to make their own choices, but was this freedom for everyone? No, although, it was a step in the right direction. I used to think history was the study of past events and the causes or consequences that led to the present. However, I failed to realize that history also pertains to recognizable patterns and human behavior, in other words, history is the study of people. I could say that the events prior to the American Revolution are important because it pushed people to steadily set in motion a change in the status quo.…

    • 811 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A major argument among historians is whether or not the American Revolution is justified or unjustified- the overwhelming evidence suggested throughout history suggest that is not. Yes it may be true that Britain started to act very overprotective over their colonies, limiting the control and freedom that can be exercised throughout the region, but they were mostly looking out for the colonists best interest at heart. The problem was that they were so invested into the colonists lives which they were trying to avoid this whole time. But throughout history, the British has been there for the colonists throughout everything. Any protection, good, money, etc.…

    • 1177 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The civil war was probably one of the most deadliest battles in American history, but what could of brought people to such hatred towards each other? Many things have been accused of causing the civil war like Uncle Tom 's Cabin or the Dred Scott decision, but at the top of the list is slavery, which effected economic, social, and political stability of the country. The North is more industrialized than the south, hence why they wanted higher tariffs so that they could compete with foreign nations. While the South was more agricultural and many owned plantation growing cotton. They preferred lower tariffs so that they could buy and sell to foreign nations.…

    • 714 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Republicanism is saying that they do not want just one ruler to lead the country because that installs too much power to just one person. The new settlers were accustomed to this kind of leadership back in the homeland but were not fans of it so they wanted something new and that is where republicanism came into play. The British wanted to have their established leadership to be installed in the new world while the people that were currently living there did not. This was one of the main things that sparked the revolution. Other things that did was the fact they signed the declaration of independence without Britain know and they considered this treason and that is another thing that sparked this war.…

    • 762 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This also matters today because we would not have this story in our history that makes so many people proud to be Americans. This also matters today because it shows how many people had to be provoked to fight a country that had helped them so much and that they had been loyal to for a very long time. The American Revolution was inevitable because the crown was trying to take control of a group of colonists who did not want them to take control of them. They were an “island” trying to control and manipulate a “continent” of people (Paine). They were trying to get a group of people who disliked them to work for them which made some of the colonists dislike each other and the crown even more.…

    • 1325 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Starting from when America was still the 13 Colonies under the rule of Great Britain, slavery still existed until the 1800’s when President Lincoln signed the Emancipation Proclamation declaring all slaves to be freed. However, before the war, there were many debates on the morality of slavery and whether or Constitution supported this practice. Being a plantation owner in Mississippi, slaves was part of the defintion of “property” since they were owned by someone. He saw it as an overstepping of it’s power by making decisions no in their power. People have disagreed on how government should be ran since the birth of this…

    • 1601 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    At the end of all the fighting and the cruel taxes being imposed by Great Britain, the colonists got tired of being treated unfairly and declared their independence from Great Britain. Thomas Paine played a big role in America’s History because he spread the idea that Britain shouldn’t be ruling America, we the people should be independent. Thomas Paine influenced Thomas Jefferson whenever he was creating the Declaration of Independence, which states why America is now an independent country. Due to both Paine and Jefferson creating the two documents that they made, those two documents created a solid foundation for America to grow…

    • 1022 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Americans wanted to solve their own problems. This is what angered them in the sudden taxes imposed by Britain. Americans were fond of salutary neglect, where the British allow the Americans to govern their everyday affairs while Britain manages the international affairs. The new taxes, which went to fund European wars, threatened this way of life the Americans had grown accustomed to. Even this, Neo-Whigs argue, was not the whole cause.…

    • 1016 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays