The Pros And Cons Of Roosevelt's New Deal

Improved Essays
Even the country which cannot be imagined as poor as before now, the USA has suffered under a great depression in 1929, enduring poverty and completely lost confidence. Especially Hoover’s ‘do nothing policy’ made the economy worse. Franklin D. Roosevelt was elected as president in 1933 and promised to end this depression. He introduced the New Deal as one of his main policy and aimed the goal of relief, recovery, and reform in the society and the economy. The democrats and the supporters of the New Deal says that it played a significant role in reducing a great number of unemployment and improved women’s right. However critics including the republicans state that the New Deal did not helped America to recover economy. As the controversy …show more content…
The republicans argued that Roosevelt had too much power in the federal government and acted as if he was a dictator. They claim that Roosevelt attacked the American system of government and was no different from Hitler. Also the Supreme Court had been shaken by Roosevelt’s actions and was less obstructive in the future. However supporters of the New Deal, Schivelbusch argues that “Hitler and Roosevelt were both charismatic leaders who held the masses in their sway—and without this sort of leadership, neither National Socialism nor the New Deal would have been possible.” He asked the Congress to give him the power to appoint other Supreme Court judges. This was because Republicans were dominating the American Supreme Court who were opposed to the New Deal and denied democracy by throwing out laws that Roosevelt had been elected to pass. Also it was not that he took over the power and used it for his own, he used it to settle down the US depression as soon as …show more content…
For example, Eleanor Roosevelt became an important campaigner on social issues that shows that women achieved prominent positions. Nevertheless critics of the New Deal says that the new deal itself did not affect women’s position. The reason being is that the New Deal programmes were aimed to help male manual workers such as the CCC which only about 8000 women were involved. In contrast, WPA program, the National Youth Administration (NYA), provided opportunities for young girls. NYA offered educational opportunities, work training, and financial aid for youth between ages sixteen and twenty-five. This shows that not only the new deal helped the women but also in a long term cultivate talent out of youngsters. ER was determined to change this and from the start of the Roosevelt Administration, she began be in charge of the federal employment relief programs to make sure that opportunities for labour were made available to women. As a consequence of her efforts, FDR’s closest advisor, Harry Hopkins, not only agreed to create a special woman’s division within the Federal Emergency Relief Administration, but also to appoint a woman to head it. Hopkins asked Ellen Woodward to do so. Under her direction, the whole approach to the problem of unemployed women was completely revitalised. With

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    Anthony and Betty Friedan were two of the most influential people in the world when it came to women’s rights. Anthony blazed the path that led to the Nineteenth Amendment in 1920, allowing women to vote everywhere across America. She also helped women attend college, have rights to their earnings even after marriage, and have more professions besides teaching. Her toil for her cause led her to be the first woman ever to be minted on an American coin, thanks to the advocacy of Friedan and the National Organization for Women. Friedan, her books, and her activism put the modern feminist movement in motion.…

    • 1170 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Fdr New Deal Essay

    • 1139 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The Liberty League was “founded to defend the Constitution and defend the rights and liberties guaranteed by that Constitution” (Who attacked the New Deal). These businessmen accused Roosevelt for “betraying his class”. The supreme Court went against Roosevelt and “ruled that some of his programs were illegal because they took away the State 's’ powers”. The Supreme court ended up “reversing their decisions” after Roosevelt threatened to “force old Supreme Court judges to retire and to create new ones”. Finally the State Governments “opposed the New Deal, saying that the Federal government was taking their powers” (How successful was the New Deal?).…

    • 1139 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The American Revolution was fought to escape the hand of an overpowering monarch. Many Democratic - Republicans were afraid of a powerful federal government because they did not want to be at the mercy of a monarchy again. Jefferson deemed the country too large for a single government, and also believed that a single government would lead to corruption. In general, the federal government was oppressive in his opinion, and it gained power at the expense of the people. Jefferson wanted states to be independent within themselves, but united when dealing with foreign affairs.…

    • 1205 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    These acts also gave the president the power to deport any foreigner he believed to be dangerous to the U.S. The sedition part of the acts was to eliminate the amount of extreme satire and any article or really any piece of writing that goes against the government. This sparked a huge outrage with the Democratic Republicans, they thought that the Sedition acts were unconstitutional because it directly against the First Amendment. The Federalists argued that the acts were only applicable to immigrants not citizens, so by a technicality, it was Constitutional, and not only that, the Federalists made the point to mention that there are limits to the First Amendment, as national security is more important than the amendment. The Republicans also thought the Alien acts were unconstitutional because it was never written in the Constitution that the president can deport immigrants.…

    • 1382 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Jeffersonians were very pro French while the Federalist had been very pro British. The Federalist hated when the embargo of 1807 was passed because it greatly hurt relations with Britain and also the economy and the trade with them. The Federalist had like England because trade h to pay off the war debts and without it this plan could not be continued. The embargo was one of the largest uses of presidential authority. Even though Jefferson had claimed to be for small government he was willing to go above this if it meant protecting the country.…

    • 1006 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Roosevelt and his advisers had to settle upon a strategy to bring back the economy like the early 1920’s before the Stock Market Crash. Second, the president had to face and relieve the agony of the millions of people negatively impacted by the Great Depression. Franklin D. Roosevelt was very direct and did not hide any details, he clearly stated that there is high rates of poverty and unemployment.…

    • 747 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Progressive Movement Dbq

    • 1054 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Jane Addams was a prominent women’s rights activist who help found the settlement house movement and published works such as, “Why Women Should Vote”, dedicated to improving the lives of women and the poor. Women like Jane Addams, backed by the Progressives, were able to greatly influence the public opinion. With the onset of World War I, the large demand for support and workers for the war provided an opportunity for women to work which revealed their capabilities and the Progressive movement enabled women to become politically involved, voicing their ideas for improvement. Prior to this, women such as Susan B. Anthony argued that the advancement of household responsibilities had increased female capability which in turn, has improved the way in which the home is managed. (Doc A) Susan B. Anthony used this argument, and other similar arguments, to imply that these household management skills could be applied to the nation to help reform and improve society.…

    • 1054 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    New Deal Women

    • 1264 Words
    • 6 Pages

    At some point, it played mainly a big part on minorities and women for taking up their mark. A part of its stated, “One of the most notable changes during the New Deal was the naming of several women to important government positions.” (The Americans page 710) The New deal created a big significance for women playing governmental roles. It was the first time that women were given the chance to prove that they could also rule the government and not only men. The woman who became the first cabinet member was Frances Perkins and she even played a major role in creating the Social Security system and supervised labor legislation. As the consequence of the New Deal, it helped Frances Perkins to advocate also for promoting women’s life.…

    • 1264 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She was a huge public icon and very appreciated by her peers. She was also the first woman to become a founder of the Anti-Slavery Society. “Her contribution in helping free the gifted and eager mind of Elizabeth Cady Stanton was an invaluable one, for the younger woman was destine to be the leading intellectual force in the emancipation of American women.” (Flexner, 67) Cady also believed, like Mott did, that women could achieve more than men. Cady grew up in Albany and spent a lot of her time in her father’s office. She was a bright young children who would listen to her dad’s clients talk about legal issues.…

    • 1494 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It overall really supported social reform. It came about during the Age of Enlightenment Era, in which this social reform became prominent. In simpler terms Progressivism can be defined as the support that was given behind the social reform. This was very important in shaping America as well. Through women having their own specific role and breaking down their goals piece by piece we will be able to unfold the intentions of progressivism.…

    • 728 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays