The Abuse Of Illegal Drugs Should Be Treated As A Matter Of Public Health

Improved Essays
AFFIRMATIVE
I affirm: Resolved: The abuse of illegal drugs ought to be treated as a matter of public health, not of criminal justice.

I define the following key terms:
Treated- to act or behave toward (a person) in some specified way to consider or regard in a specified way, and deal with accordingly:
2. to consider or regard in a specified way, and deal with accordingly
3.to deal with (a disease, patient, etc.) in order to relieve or cure. (dictionary.com)
Public health- health services to improve and protect community health
Criminal justice- the system of law enforcement, involving police, lawyers, courts, and corrections, used for all stages of criminal proceedings and punishment. (dictionary.com)

It is important to remember that
…show more content…
Legalization of drugs would decrease the amount of harm done non-users in society.
Instead of just telling people that drugs are bad and arresting them if they use them, we should create places where they can go to get help and do as least amount of harm to themselves and others.
A good example of this is the needle exchange program, which provides clean needles to be injected in drug users. These clean needles dramatically halted the spread of HIV throughout the communities of drug users. Programs like these should be used to help the struggling ones and get them the help they need.

3. Using the justice system does not solve the problems of drug users.
Going to prison often times does not help drug users stop using drugs. This is proven with the statistic that two-thirds of prisoners reoffend within three years of leaving prison accordin to The New Times. This proves that the majority of prisoners who go to jail do not learn their lesson while being there. Instead of sending them straight to jail we should establish programs to rehabilitate them. Instead of making jail a place of complete punishment lets amke jail a place of education where we caninform the lost drug abusers and help them get their lives together
…show more content…
The negative will now prove the treating of abuse of illigal drugs should be a matter of criminal justice because first of all the absense of punishment will lead to an idea of acceptance among drug users. Secondly, locking up drug abusers is an effective way to keep them from harming civilians. Thirdly, the only way a drug abuser can quit is only if they want help and want change themselves.
This issue adresses not only the U.S but also the rest of the world The legalization of drugs will lead to an idea that since its legal everyone should do it. It will increase in use not only in adults but also in youths, according to Former New York City Mayor Ed Koch. People will start to use and abuse drugs like never seen before.
When something is illegal it is much harder to find than when it is available to all. The same principal applies here because not only will more adults be abusing drugs but their kids might just as easily get a hold of it and ruin their lives at a young

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The only exception has been alcohol and prescription drugs. Should drugs be legalized or stay illegal? Drugs should be illegal due to what it can cause. Drugs can cause people to hurt themselves, it increases public spending on health, addiction, and high prices of drugs means that less people will do it. The first reason to keep drugs illegal is because people may harm themselves.…

    • 1050 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Punishment, especially punishment on those caught doing drugs, should be evaluated through Deontology this because it focuses on the rights, duties, and consequences of drug punishments rather than only focus on the consequences. Since the War on Drugs was established the amount of incarcerations also heavily increased. It is the governments right to protect citizens from drugs and drug users, however, it is also their duty to use the drug punishment to deter others from doing them and rehabilitating offenders. Yet, the War on Drugs has not done that. Instead of having less drug offenders and incarcerations, we have increased the number of incarcerations and the recidivism rate.…

    • 834 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Do rehabilitation programs work when it comes to prisoners? Could it be possible that we can mold a violent offender into a productive member of society? This paper offers insight to the criminal justice policy when it comes to successful rehabilitation programs in the United States and how it benefits prisoners once they are released. The main goal of developing successful rehab programs in prisons are to prevent recidivism in inmates. Statistics found that 37% of people who participate in these programs did not return to prison within the first three years.…

    • 2109 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Feinstein (2005) suggest that there needs to be more research to “help define a population that would benefit from the program” (pg. 44), this makes the most sense since the film and interviews with the juveniles demonstrates that it did help some of them and continues to do so twenty years after, Sheri Bouldin, a probation officer, noted that out of the three hundred and eighty four juveniles she has taken into the program only fifty-seven are still participating in criminal activities. As well Sandy Shevack, a social worker, mentions that out of about three hundred children he has taken to the prison, eighty percent have turn their life…

    • 1175 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Drug addicts will be able to obtain proper treatments without fear of arrest. They can obtain clean needles, thus lowering incidence of HIV/AIDS. It can lower deaths due to overdose caused by designer drugs, which are laced with dangerous substance that make them more lethal. Evidence…

    • 1178 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Another principle would be that every addiction whether it’s an addiction to a licit or illicit drug should all be treated the same. Another principle includes giving those who have used drugs and currently use drugs a voice for when they create programs and policies designed to help serve and protect them; and of course treat The program’s overall, goal is to promote public health as well as finding new ways to drug treatment and policy that are based on science and research. Harm reduction programs have also, proven to lower HIV risks, hepatitis transmission and death from overdose. Harm reduction is more of a rehabilitation center made to meet the needs of those who want to rid of such…

    • 1256 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Introduction: The abuse of illegal drugs should be treated as a matter of public health instead of criminal justice. For years, jails have failed at providing efficient solutions for the rehabilitation of drug users. This is why it is necessary to provide better alternatives within the public health system. I believe that exploring the decriminalization of illegal substances would not only help stop the war on drugs, but also help protect society as a whole. My value: Public and individual health Definitions Decriminalization: the lessening of criminal penalties in relation to certain acts.…

    • 1441 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This overcrowding though, is forcing prisons to let go of real criminals because of lack of space. If drugs were legalized this could reduce those drug users sentences, and allow more space for people that commit serious crimes. It is safer to let go of drug users because they are less likely to cause harm to other people. Drug users are only hurting themselves, their health. If violent criminals like rapists are being let go of, there is a high chance they will do a crime like that again.…

    • 1671 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    The criminal justice system is coined a “revolving door”: the same people come in and out. Studies in the Los Angeles area show that up to 26% of youth commit a subsequent crime within the first year after being released (Ryan, Abrams, Huang, 2014). This can be credited to overcrowding which leads to lack of resources and a poor living environment. If the necessary resources are not made available to an individual, they will not be able to properly rehabilitate. Those who are unable to overcome drug addiction habits while incarcerated are significantly more likely to be given a prison sentence for any drug related crimes compared to a first time offender (Lurigio and Loose, 2008).…

    • 1551 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Incarceration Experience

    • 1482 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The use of incarceration in this country seems to be overused, especially for offenders who need to be rehabilitated, not incarcerated. Jensen, Gerber, and Mosher ( 2004) note that the “war on drugs” has changed the criminal justice system greatly. Prison populations drastically increased due to drug offenders. Special drug courts have been created due to the massive overload of drug related cases in criminal courts. The problem with incarcerating drug offenders is that they rarely receive proper treatment, and are given harsh sentences when what they need is rehabilitation.…

    • 1482 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays

Related Topics