Prenatal Genetic Testing Research Paper

Great Essays
Prenatal Genetic Testing: A Technology of Normalization Prenatal genetic testing is a technology made available to more accurately determine whether or not a child could have a birth ‘defect’. The most common birth defects tested for are Down syndrome, Trisomy 18, or an open neural tube defect (Government of Canada, 2013). This paper asserts first that prenatal genetic testing is a technology of normalization, which labels disability as abnormal and a feared outcome, and second that normalization creates unwarranted notions of human identity and happiness. To do this, I begin by providing background information on the work by Michel Foucault on biopower, disciplinary power, and normalization. The purpose of this section is to show first that these …show more content…
Hall points out that the problem of the vile sovereign, according to Foucault, is that it is ‘inevitably’ a normalizing force (Hall, 11-2) The three components that make up a vile sovereign are it firstly, claims authority over questions of life and death, secondly it has undeserved status, and thirdly promotes a discourse of laughter or disbelief (Hall, 13-4). To briefly sum up how Hall sees the connection between the vile sovereign and transhumanism: transhumanists claim authority over questions of life and death as they “entertain the question of what lives are worth living” through a hierarchy of human capability, it has undeserved status because of the “puerile preoccupations and utopianism” because of its fantasies of power, and lastly engages in a discourse of laughter and disbelief as transhumanists argue that mortality is a moral problem, which Hall argues can cause a discourse of laughter (Hall, 13-5). So if Hall is correct, then the transhumanist perspective would inevitably normalize because of its status as a ‘vile

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Perception In Gattaca

    • 512 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Discuss the interplay between how individuals perceive themselves and how they are perceived by others. In his film Gattaca Andrew Niccol explored this dichotomy of people’s thoughts of us and our thoughts on ourselves. We would like to pretend we do not care how others perceive us; however, we have all secretly yearned to fit in somewhere, be it at work, school or at social gatherings. The way in which we see ourselves is heavily influenced by other people’s perceptions of us.…

    • 512 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    D’ Souza introduces Jeremy Rifkin’s idea “that we are heading for a nightmarish future where people are identified, stereotyped, and discriminated against on the basis of their genotype” (D’Souza, 2001, para. 7). Today, a person’s genotype does not cause discrimination, but when genetic engineering in humans becomes mainstream, the criticism will damage society. A child will experience more discrimination if their parents choose genetic modification during pregnancy. Rifkin believes this action causes humanity to lose its sacred value: “Living beings [cannot] be considered sacred if they are treated as nothing more than bundles of genetic information” (D’Souza, 2001, para. 7). If human beings value nothing more than genetic information, a new set of stereotyping will form from genetic engineering, which will disrupt natural relationships between human beings.…

    • 610 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In McMahan’s article, he proposes four objections for testing for a disability. The first objection is that screening for a disability in a fetus would discriminate against the fetus. He argues that it leads to people wanting “perfect” children and then discriminating against those with…

    • 567 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ross L. Jones’s article investigates a society that practiced eugenics during the last two centuries. Eugenics was a major school of thought based on science and accepted as true by upper-class people (165). Eugenics played an enormous role in Australian society by denouncing those who had “inferior genes”, which was approved by the medical community and the politicians of that era. The main motivator for eugenics was the educated class and politicians. Pro-eugenicists sought the “maximising of an individual’s potential” as long as the individual represented people they believed were like themselves and stripped those who were seen as “inferior” of their rights as human beings and citizens (166).…

    • 395 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In society, there are many different individuals in the world that suffer from some sort of disability. Not everyone gets the chance to live a normal life because they might have a problem or sickness that they have to overcome. In the article “Victims from Birth” founding Editor Wendy McElroy, provides the story of Gauvin Hughes McCullough, whose deaf parents deny him a hearing aid, hoping he would grow up and be just like them. The lesbian couple were delighted to have Gauvin, their child to be born with a hearing disability because he would most likely be involved with the deaf culture. We see how parents want their child to be exactly like them but that isn’t right.…

    • 644 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The author talks about how the conversation around eugenics is similar to the Pro-Choice movement in the 1960-70s. She explains how there is a stigma behind the word “eugenics” and questions whether it’s wrong to use new technology to improve the human race. She concludes the article by talking about the political opposition of eugenics. This article will be useful in the paper because it provides a different perspective of the ethics behind biotechnology.…

    • 74 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis, potential discrimination against patients, and no guarantee of disease development are a few of the disadvantages of genetic testing that have helped develop my stance. This does not mean we are to ignore the benefits of genetic testing. However, after taking into account both the advantages and the disadvantages discussed and weighing them with each other, I have come to the conclusion that the disadvantages of genetic testing outweigh the…

    • 1792 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Wrongful Life

    • 718 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Reproductive Genetics, Wrongful Life, and Wrongful Birth: A Summary Analysis of “Bill S-201: An Act to Prohibit and Prevent Genetic Discrimination” by Jennifer Ann Rinaldi Summary: Rinaldi’s (2009) article provides legal evidence of various cases involved in litigation related to ‘wringful death” and wrongful birth” issues in genetics reproductive rights. This article provides evidence of the negative biases of disability cases that can be harmful by devaluating the life of the disabled individual. A focus on various legal cases, such as R.H. v. Hunter, [1996] and Arndt v. Smith, [1997], that the burden of wrongful life and wringful death inordinately shift the shame of ‘existing” onto the disabled person in the Canadian court of law. A…

    • 718 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I will be analyzing Laura M. Purdy ’s essay on “Genetics and Reproductive Risk” and Jeff McMahan’s essay “The morality of screening for disability”. It is now possible to check for genetic disorders by looking for changes in the person’s DNA. It is known as the power of genetic testing, which now includes over a thousand tests designed to detect disease, a number that is projected to increase by the hundreds in the next few years. If this process is not chosen the person with the disease may be subjected to genetic discrimination.…

    • 691 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Ethical Dilemma Essay Everyday life can lead one into territory that will change them for the rest of their life. As such, a mother-to-be receiving news that her child will likely be born with a disability is one of those situations that can plunge that mother-to-be into an ethical dilemma. One will normally approach the ethical dilemma with much trepidation because the implications of the decision rendered could perhaps affect several individuals’ other than the mother-to-be and the unborn child.…

    • 1532 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When genetic disorders are discussed, both in popular culture and in medicine, they are viewed as negative ways, and for obvious reasons: many genetic disorders, like the one Sierra has, can easily kill or seriously inhibit a person from living a “normal life.” Throughout recent medical history, there has been a lot of focus on learning new ways to control or treat certain genetic conditions. In fact, the entire discussion of how to treat genetic disorders can be brought back to our class discussion of the legacy of eugenics. With this project, I wanted to depict two specific things: I wanted to analyse how Sierra’s life plays into the idea of leading a “normal life.” In addition to that, I wanted to examine how new ways of treatment are replacing old ideas of eugenics, and whether eugenics plays into Sierra’s experience in any way.…

    • 807 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In his article, “Disability, Identity, and the “Expressivist Objection”,” author S.D. Edwards sets out to disprove the expressivist argument, or as he calls it the “expressivist objection.” The expressivist argue being that prenatal testing for specific genetic illnesses and disabilities is morally wrong as it sends a harmful message that being disabled is undesirable to the point that the disability outweighs other aspects of quality of life and thus termination of a pregnancy in response to disability is warranted. Edwards uses several areas of ethos, pathos, and logos some which strengthen his argument and others that weaken his argument. Edwards is qualified to speak on the subject of the ethics regarding prenatal testing as he is currently a part of the philosophy and ethics in healthcare at Swansea University in Wales, United Kingdom (website), and university ranked 45th in the world…

    • 491 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Disability and the justification of inequality in American History by Douglas C. Baynton The main idea addressed by Douglas C. Baynton is that disability has never been a focused upon and its is often overlooked and used as a justification for inequality in American History. Disability is ignored and not questioned or treated as a cultural construct. It is viewed as personal tragedy, instead of something that produces social hierarchies. The author goes on to describe how disability functions to justify inequality for disabled persons, as well as for women and other minority groups.…

    • 894 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Prenatal genetic sequencing is a scientific procedure that predicts the risk of developing an illness later in life, and/or shows potential traits such as athleticism and intelligence in an unborn child. These predictions of illness and potential traits come from analyzing fetal DNA found in a sample of the mother’s blood. A very important and main concern for prenatal genetic testing is for preparation of treatment for a predicted illness in a child. Also parents are often interested in these predictions simply for having an indication of what they are getting themselves into. Prenatal genetic testing is a rising topic in present ethical conflicts.…

    • 2208 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay #2: Disability or Enhancement? In this essay, I will argue that Gauvin’s parents were not morally justified in their decision to permanently make their son born and remain deaf because by doing so the parents are treating the child as a lesser equal and are inflicting psychological harm. The role of parents is to ensure the wellbeing, safety, and support of their child in hopes that they can become stable, independent, and functional individuals in the near future. However, choosing a sperm donor with a history of deafness or any other disabilities is morally unjust because it is specifically taking a trait and implanting it upon a child causing them a life of hardships that they have to endure.…

    • 782 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays