Tax Preference Theory: Tax Preference Theory And Bird In Hand Theory

Improved Essays
4.0 Tax Preference Theory
Tax preference theory and bird in hand theory are two main different theories with exactly different view on shareholder preference. According to Ehrhardt and Brigham(2008) tax reference theory states that shareholders prefer retain earning rather than pay as dividends. It is because taxes on dividends must be paid immediately once you received the dividends and most of the countries dividends tax rate higher than capital gain tax. However, taxes of capital gain can be deferred into future. Damodaran (1999) states that bird in hand theory implies that cash dividends are considered like a bird on hand but the retained earnings are like a bird in forest.
In short, tax preference theory believes that shareholder prefers
…show more content…
With this data he found that decision of investor can be influenced by the tax treatment of capital gains and dividends. In contrast, Lewellen et al. (1978) found quite a weak supportive evidence of the clientele effect hypothesis by on the database used in studies of Petti(1977)
Besides that Eltoon and Gruber (1970) also show empirical evidence about the relationship between share price and ex-dividend day. However, what they found was that the stock price decrease and it is less than the amount of dividend on ex-dividend. Besides that, they also found that the relationship of stock’s dividend yield on ex-dividend equivalent size of its ex-dividend price decrease is positive. Therefore, they use this consequence as a proof that differential taxes made a preference for capital relative to cash dividends. Thus, they support the clientele hypothesis.
There is nothing wrong between views of bird in hand theory or tax preference theory. There just a conflict between these two concepts because in the real world, different countries have different tax rate on dividend and capital gain. There is an evidence can be supported by the research of Alliance company (Appendix) . After reviewing the data, it can be realised that there are three major types of countries. Firstly is the dividends tax rate higher than capital gain tax rate. Second is the capital gain tax rate higher than dividend tax rate. Lastly are countries without capital gain tax rate
…show more content…
Auerbach and Hassett (2003) states that the dividends are taxed immediately if the dividend tax rate always higher that capital gain rate. It will result what the tax preference explanation suggest that a low level of dividend payout is preferable as to maximize the value and wealth of shareholder. A company will be more likely to use stock repurchases or otherwise retain earnings as a way to return corporate earnings to the shareholder.
Favorable treatment for capital gains over dividends would lead to an over-investment of firms financing new investment through retained earnings. This may be more heavily concentrated in certain sectors of the economy, thereby distorting the allocation of resources.
Accordingly, French has 44.0% of dividend tax rate which is significantly lower than 60.5% of capital gain tax rate. Based on research of McDonald, Jacquillat and Nussenbaum (1975), they stated that when dividends are taxed, companies are expected to defer them until the present value of payout taxes are zero, or opt for share buybacks that are subject to capital gains taxes if they are lower than the taxes on dividends. Besides that this concept also supported by DeAngelo et al (2008), Auerbach and Hassett (2003). Black (1976) concludes that corporations are the only investors with a tax preference for dividends, a view which is now widely

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    This diagram demonstrates the relationship between the size of a tax and tax revenue. A tax is a wedge between the price buyers pay and the price sellers receive on a good; it raises the price buyers have to pay for that good, and lowers the price sellers receive on that same good. Tax revenue refers to the amount of money received from taxing a good (Mankiw, 2015). The Laffer Curve illustrates that initially, as tax size increases, tax revenue increases. After a while, though, when tax size keeps increasing, tax revenue actually starts to decrease at some point.…

    • 1219 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Previous researches showed the correlation coefficients of firm leverage and ROA is significant. The measurement of firm leverage is total debt divided by total asset. Makori and Jagongo (2013) suggested that the level of leverage is negatively impacted on corporate profitability. It can be explained by if firms earn more money that increase their profitability, the firms will use the retail earning to pay off their debt leverage. Therefore, the higher the profitability, the lower the debt leverage.…

    • 1494 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    With the increase in debt marginal benefit of further increases in the debt declines while the marginal cost increases, so that a firm which is optimizing its overall value will focus on the trade-off when choosing how much debt and equity to use for financing. As, using equity is initially more expensive than debt because it is ineligible for the same tax savings, but becomes more favourable as compared to the higher levels of debt because it does not carry the same financial risk. Another trade-off consideration to take into account is that the interest payments can be written off, dividends on equity that tare usually issued by a firm cannot. Combine with the fact that issuing new equity is often seen as a negative signal by the market investors, which can decrease value and returns of a firm. As further capital is raised and the marginal costs increase, the firm must find a fine balance in whether it should use debt or equity after internal financing when raising new…

    • 719 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Earnings Quality Analysis

    • 796 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Are they controllable? And are they liquid (have a future cash value)?” McClure (2004). McClure (2004) highlighted the key factors which determine the quality of reported earnings, it argued that in some periods earnings may be high due to special circumstances such as sale of assets; this form of revenue cannot be repeated so it is of low quality as it is not informative of the financial performance of the firm. The Controllable feature of earnings quality outlined by McClure (2004) indicates that macroeconomic factors may also have favourable effects on a firm’s financial performance by raising earnings. An example of this may be inflation or favourable movements in the exchange rate (for businesses based in one country but operate in another).…

    • 796 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Fifo Vs Lifo Essay

    • 1501 Words
    • 6 Pages

    While in the market where prices are rising rapidly, value of inventory goes up resulting into gain in net profit. Thus, if prices increase, inventory profit is maximized and total earnings increase as well. And if prices decrease, costs are maximized and thus profit is minimized (Merjos, 1974). According to Merjos (1974), from corporate’s standpoint, advantages of LIFO far outweigh the drawbacks. LIFO method reduces tax liability.…

    • 1501 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    If Mr. Schwarzman’s ideology of this concept were to be challenged, he would most likely firm up his belief even if correct factual evidence was presented to him. In reality it is the lower classes who are paying more taxes. Income taxes that all individuals pay are regressive, which basically means the more income one makes, the lower the proportion of their income they have to pay; so it is the individuals of the lower and middle classes who are bearing the brunt of the stick. To top this off those who make money find little loopholes to avoid giving back even more of their earnings. Those who are able to will acquire their income by capital gains, instead of salaries; which significantly lowers their income tax- rate by up to 10%.…

    • 1260 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Then according to Fisher Equations, when the nominal interest rate fixed, the lower inflation will affect to a higher real interest. Therefore, the debtor bears a heavier burden than before, and the real wealth of debtor will fall. Considering of the inflation, deflation is even worse. According to the Keynes conjectured, the debtors have a higher marginal propensity to consume than the creditors. Because the creditor tends to consume less and save more, in order to invest the money in debtors, as a result they have a large proportion of savings.…

    • 1183 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Tobin’s Q is pointed out by the American economist James Tobin(1969) and is measured by dividing the market value the firm by the replacement cost of assets in place(Dadson, 2012; Mustafa and Osama, 2002; Aburub, 2012). It reflects future expected profits of the company, while the stock price factors are included in the calculation of Tobin 's Q. Under perfect capital market conditions, Tobin 's Q can fully reflect the historical value of the enterprise, the current value and future value. Therefore, it plays as an important role in measuring corporate value in Western countries. Although many factors such as capital market imperfections and lack of mature market mechanism in China reduced the effectiveness of Tobin 's Q, it is still appropriate and meaningful to combine the use of Tobin 's Q with ROE to represent the enterprise…

    • 1108 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    There is evidence proving that agency conflicts exist in firms having abundant amount of cash and overinvesting (Jensen and Meckling, 1976; Fazzari et al., 1988; Stein, 2003). In firms with agency conflict problems, managers are likely to use the available cash flows to invest in projects which may have negative NPV for their own interests following the empire-building model rather than for maximizing shareholder value (Jensen and Ruback, 1983). The empire-building may lead to over-investment issues with higher-than-expected level of free cash flow over investment opportunities (Stein, 2003). On the other hand, firms can face underinvestment problems when they have financial constraint (Kaplan and Zingales, 1995). Underinvestment due to asymmetric information may lead to the cases when some positive NPV projects are not taken into account while the management decides to invest in lower quality projects which may need external financing sources (Myers and Majluf, 1984).…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Capital Gain Tax Analysis

    • 1035 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Also, for inflation to be deducted, the interest expenses should be indexed. Interest expense would also be indexed, so only the excess of interest above inflation would be deductible. This will be benefiting since they could result to the taxpayer gaining a pure arbitrage dividends by subtracting the nominal interest at the same time recognizing real gains. Variations on a consumption tax such as the flat tax or David Bradford’s X-tax could protect low-income taxpayers from the burden of a consumption tax, but that simply means that more of the burden is placed on middle-income households, assuming revenues are to be maintained (Burman et al,…

    • 1035 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays