Taking The Least Of You Analysis

Great Essays
Synthesis
There are many issues about informed consent that are located within the articles “Deal Done Over HeLa Cells” written by Ewen Callaway and “Taking the Least of You” written by Rebecca Skloot. In “Deal Done Over HeLa Cells,” it notifies the readers about the cells of Henrietta Lack’s and how they were taken away from her body without her or her family’s consent. In “Taking the Least of You,” it states the issues about informed consent that Ted Slavin, John Moore, and William Catalona have had. Both of these articles strongly agree that medical researchers and taken and used information and parts of the body without the consent of the person from which it was taken from or the family. [What should be done about informed consent?]
Within the article “Deal Done over HeLa Cells,” there are many reasons that explain the major issues with the subject of informed consent. “Taking the Least of You” is about a woman by the name of Henrietta Lacks. Henrietta Lacks had cells that were immortal. The effect of her cells being immortal is that they would reproduce much faster than what the average human cells would. Henrietta Lacks went to Johns Hopkins Hospital on January 29, 1951( Biography.com Editors. "Henrietta Lacks Biography.") At the hospital,Lacks was experiencing very odd pain . Henrietta’s
…show more content…
Early on, Dr. Catalona began asked his patients early on if he could use the tissue that he removed during his patients for research. At the time, the university that Catalona worked for was Washington University in St. Louis. Washington Univeristy realized that these tissue samples that Catalona removed from his patients could earn the university money. Dr. Catalona wanted the tissue samples to be sent to a biotech company, but the university did not agree with this idea. As a result of the anarchy between Washington University and Dr. Catalona, Catalona’s practice was moved

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In 1951, it was not illegal to use human tissue cells for research without consent but, publically identifying Mrs. Lacks as the HeLa line source was. Therefore, Mrs. Lacks identifiable health information was transmitted to the world. Today, this breach of privacy is known as a HIPPA violation, The Health Insurance Portability Privacy Act.…

    • 868 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One topic that I think is worthwhile to discuss is that whether doctors can take patient’s cell or tissue to do research or make profit from them. In this case of Henrietta Lacks, she signed the operation consent that allows doctors to conduct whatever procedure they think is essential. Therefore, Jones took some part of Henrietta’s cells and shared them with George Gey. In this case, some people might argue that without taking her cells the world will be completely different, whereas others will insist that this action lacked a clearly informed consent and violated the basic human rights. Another issue that I think is interesting to talk about is other people’s opinion’s on HeLa cells.…

    • 1321 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1951 September 24 Henrietta is in the hospital, her body covered in tumors and since…

    • 1311 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Secondly, any major hospital close by was for whites only and they would just kick her to the curb to die. Once the pain became so unbearable, Henrietta visited a local doctor who referred her to the closest colored hospital which was John Hopkins in Baltimore, Maryland. The gynecologist Howard Jones, was on call and was the first to examine Henrietta. Jones took a sample of the lump that Henrietta complained about to be tested and noted that the growth of the lump must have been rapid since the there was a lack of one three months prior during her birth and…

    • 1457 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Henrietta Lacks Sacrifice

    • 1361 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Henrietta went to Jon Hopkins Hospital, which is a teaching hospital and a biomedical research facility, to undergo an exam and have biopsies taken…

    • 1361 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Henrietta children and their children have suffered greatly with no health insurance and living in poverty. Although her cells have had attention and money it was still no help to the family. It raises questions about bioethics on who should benefit from scientific research and how should it be conducted. Deborah daughter did say “If our mother cells done so much for medicine, how come her family can’t afford to see no doctors?” (Skloot 9).…

    • 857 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Henrietta Lacks Benefits

    • 278 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Henrietta Lacks at the age of 31 died of cervical cancer; however, scientists across the world were using her tissue for medical advancement sixty-two years later. The problem is neither Henrietta Lacks or the family after she passed gave consent to these studies that occurred for years. The HeLa genome provided many discoveries in the fields of cancer, vaccines, viruses, and cells in general. Henrietta Lacks and her family did not have the rights to potential earnings from these discoveries made from her tissue (Zimmer 2013).…

    • 278 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Identifying the same flaws as Beecher, Guraya, London, and Guraya (2014) discusses the importance of informed consent in medical research. Both of these philosophers provide convincing arguments supporting their opinions, however, I agree with Beecher’s view as researchers ought not to limit human experimentation because of its merits and beneficial consequences. Exposition Samuel Hellman offers his position against human experimentation, as inherently wrong. By this he means that changes to the practice of human experimentation could make it morally permissible. He claims that it is now possible to offer unique and specialized care for patients in the healthcare system and as a result of that, human experimentation is not…

    • 1146 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Henrietta Lacks Equality

    • 1884 Words
    • 8 Pages

    As a medical professional, it is not enough to not do harm, one must also do additional work to provide benefits to the patient (Coale, 2015). According to Henrietta’s attending physician Howard Jones, “Henrietta got the same care any white patient would have; the biopsy, radium treatment and radiation were all standard” (Skloot, 2010). Despite proper beneficial treatment, Henrietta’s death is linked with having a more aggressive adenocarcinoma, diagnosed years after her death, as well as being immunosuppressed due to syphilis. Even with change in diagnosis and knowing more about the role immunosuppression has with cancer, the treatment would not have changed (Skloot, 2010). Skloot points out that although the individual doctors may not have…

    • 1884 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Despite going against what is ethically right in invading Henrietta lacks somatic rights, the world has seen a myriad of disease antidotes. Still to this day even, “[her] cells have become the standard laboratory workhorse”(Stump 131). If they had not taken HeLa cells for research, there’s no way to tell if we could have suffered a mutilating cost. Without the cures HeLa cells have done, we could have reached an apocalyptic scene where those very diseases that were cured might have spread across the world, killing millions. The Executive Director of the Presidential Commissions Lisa M. Lee states, “The benefits of research have to outweigh the risks to the individuals involved” (Stump 131).…

    • 720 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The book “The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks” dives into the story of an African-American woman who was diagnosed with cervical cancer and died at a young age shortly after, leaving behind 5 children, a husband, and many cousins. When Henrietta was at John Hopkins being treated for her cancer, the doctors took a sliver of her tumor and cultured it to see if they could make the cell “immortal”. This all happened back in the 50’s when colored people weren’t seen as equal citizens to white people. Because of this, doctors withheld a lot of information, and they took the sliver from her without her consent and supposedly never told her about it. (Although there was one colleague who claimed that Gey did in fact tell Henrietta about the cells,…

    • 992 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Her immortal cells will always continue to live on, but only after Henrietta and her family faced many obstacles. Henrietta lived her life being exploited by researchers. Her or her family never got any recognition or compensation for Henrietta 's role and contribution to Science via the HeLa cell line. Doctors also abused their power and acted inhumanely when caring for her and trying to treat her cancer by taking the cells in the first place. Not much of anything that was done to Henrietta Lacks by doctors and researchers could be justified.…

    • 1232 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    HeLa was vital to cloning research, counting the number of chromosomes in a human cell, and the polio vaccine. HeLa refers to a cell line that given a endless supply of nutrients can divide forever. In this way, they are considered to be “immortal.” These cells are so prominently used in scientific research that if lined up, HeLa cells would circle the Earth more than three times. But where did these cells come from?…

    • 901 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The main ethical dilemma in the Case of Henrietta Lacks and Debate over Ethics and Bio-Medical Research and Informed Consent is that researchers took and profited off of the cells of Henrietta Lacks without her consent and without compensating her or her family. There are certain facts that are important to understand in this case. The person who began this ethical issue was George Otto Gey when he used the cells made available to him that had been of Henrietta Lacks, creating the He-La cell line (Skloot, 2010). Sadly, at the time, informed consent did not yet exist and did not become doctrine in practice until the late 1970s which was long past Lacks’ time (Skloot, 2010). Even though informed consent was not traditionally practiced in public…

    • 970 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Henrietta Lacks is a poor, middle school dropout, mother of five, African American woman who is forced to drive miles upon miles to get to Hopkins Hospital that provided free medical treatment (Skloot 33). During this point in history, all hospitals were segregated, and if any blacks wanted medical treatment they had to travel further for treatment. Also, African Americans were put in a bad economic spot, and most did not have the money for adequate health care. Therefore, Lacks did not have any other options other than to go to Hopkins, where they treated her poorly by taking a sample of her cervix without asking if this was acceptable (Skloot 33). Because Lacks was uneducated, the doctors did not feel the need to ask for permission because they did not believe she would understand what they were looking for or why they would do it.…

    • 1566 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays