Symposium: Comparing Alcibiadies And Aristophanes

Improved Essays
Plato’s symposium is nothing less than a brilliant masterpiece, presenting us with a damning decision between the two views of love. If we choose the path Socrates has delineated, rising to the Good, we are unable to take the first step on the ladder as long as we reflect on Alcibiadies and Aristophanes. An individual can only fully follow Socrates if they are persuaded of his account to be true, but Alcibiadies and Aristophanes makes us think otherwise. Alcibiadies and Aristopahnes causes the individual to question the pursuit of the Good by making the person think they are sacrificing something; so much so that the pursuit and ascent on the ladder no longer seems to be embracing the whole of the Good. Consequently, either way we choose we

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The most thought provoking text for me this semester was the chapter on Alcibiades from Plutarch’s Lives. From reading about, and discussing, the life of the ancient Greek war-hero, I was provoked to question what people look for in their leader, and what exactly makes a leader “good”. To spare no sentiment, Alcibiades, by today’s standards, appears to be downright crazy. He frequently was involved in physical altercations in which he would intentional injury others, often times without being provoked. He showed up at a man’s house fully unclothed asking to be “chastised”, and he even once cut off a dog’s tail.…

    • 761 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Plato’s Republic, Aristophanes’ The Assemblywomen, and Blundell’s chapter on Sparta women citizen, depicted many ideas of women’s value and participation in their societies. Blundell shows that the more radical lines of Spartan women ensured that female domestic power was accepted and maybe encouraged. In Plato’s and Aristophanes’ works can reflect a comparison to Blundell’s chapter on Sparta. Spartan women were raised in an all-female environment as their father or husbands were training for or at war most of the time. They saw little of their brothers once the barracks had claimed them at the age of seven.…

    • 1160 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The passages that will be discussed in this half of the essay are Thucydides 6.91 to 6.93 and will look at particular ideas and themes that are raised by this piece of text. Alcibiades and Thucydides both experienced exile from Athens, which allows Alcibiades to communicate with Sparta, and allows Thucydides to gain eyewitnesses and accounts from both sides. The text is a speech within Thucydides by Alcibiades to the Spartans. This speech Alcibiades is urging the Spartans to send troops to help the Syracuse and invade the territory belonging to the Athenians. One of the features of this speech is Alcibiades giving the Spartans advice on how to effectively strike against the Athenians.…

    • 961 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Love In Plato's Phaedrus

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Socrates has two main speeches in “Phaedrus” the first regarding love and its negative effects as a means of refuting Lysias’s claims about love. Socrates discusses love as a form of madness and how it forces people to lose morality and control. He seems to be drawing on his own opinions that he has formed from the polis. He is convinced that love is a terrible thing and that it causes more harm than good. However, in his second speech, known as “The Great Speech”, he discusses love as eros and that there are four types of divine madness.…

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Agathon's Symposium

    • 692 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The meaning of Eros and its functions is intricate and unique, such as how it serves. In The Symposium, by Plato, patrons evaluate Eros functions and purpose by giving their own interpretation on love. Each speech is unique and critiques previous speeches to show purpose for their own individual interpretation. Agathon concentrated on details, such as “love’s virtues”(196c) and described how others had “[failed to speak about] the nature of the god himself”(195a). However, Diotima (unveiled by Socrates) demonstrated how while Agathon's speech was “beautiful”(198b), but lacked real philosophical content.…

    • 692 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Erotic love can be categorized as “two kinds of value [and] two kinds of knowledge” () from Plato’s Symposium; it’s content raises the decision between an abstract way of pursuing erotic love and the traditional pursuit of a soulmate. Aristophanes and Alcibiades share a common pursuit of wholeness through the physical form. Aristophanes uses a tale of traditional Greek mythology which teaches humans were once whole, but as punishment humans were separated into two beings and given the life purpose of finding the other half. Furthermore, Alcibiades contributes to Aristophanes description of love by telling his own life story of being unable to find his other half and describing himself as enslaved to love. Aristophanes and Alcibiades both share…

    • 982 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Argumentative Strategies of Plato vs. Aristophanes In Aristophanes’ “Clouds” and Plato’s “Apology” Socrates is satirically attacked and rationally defended respectively. The two argumentative styles of Aristophanes and Plato are on opposite sides of the spectrum. Aristophanes utilizes satire and humorous exaggerations of sophist teachings to denounce Socrates. Alternatively, Plato’s “Apology” uses logic and reason in order to defend himself against the charges brought against him.…

    • 2212 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Aristotle’s “Types of States” and Aristophanes’ “The Birds” seem completely unrelated initially however when “Types of States” and “The Birds” read closely both share the common theme of government and how government can greatly influence the way society works. Aristotle and Aristophanes contributed their ideas of government through their works each explaining in their own way how government affected society; Aristotle explaining directly in “Types of States” and Aristophanes showing what he believed would happen through means of entertainment in “The Birds”. The purpose of both writings was to be used as an attempt to convince the audience of their views on government persuading the audience to adopt their ideas. Aristotle and Aristophanes,…

    • 1444 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Plato’s Symposium, multiple philosophical thinkers discuss, argue and critique the abstract concept of love and eros. Each thinker had their own fascinating way of describing this phenomenon, but two philosophers- Aristophanes and Diotima- sparked more questions and arguments than any others. Aristophanes was a famously known comical poet in the ancient times and Diotima was a woman who Socrates claimed to met years back who passed on her wisdom on the subject of love. Although both speeches are completely different in style, tone and context, both Aristophanes and Diotima essentially build off of each other’s ideas. Aristophanes's speech focuses on love being a desire for wholeness and instead of refuting this, Diotima criticizes this…

    • 1182 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The purpose of the Symposium is to determine what exactly Love is, and Socrates explains his own views through the teachings of Diotima. While Diotima takes the position that to be in Love means you must be in active pursuit of something, I disagree. Instead of acting as just a verb, Love can also serve as a noun. The first problem arises when trying to figure how to label Love.…

    • 1695 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In The Symposium translated by Robin Waterfield and The Odyssey translated by Andrew George, the concept of love is explored. In The Symposium, love is discussed at the dinner party hosted by Agathon, in which many Greek partygoers give their input, including Aristophanes. Aristophanes’ claim is that Love is what brings the halves together, the halves humans were split into by Zeus. Odysseus is on a quest that takes him from his kingdom and wife. Although Odysseus has relationships with other women on his quest, he still insists on going back to his wife, whom he loves.…

    • 617 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    People today have longed to find their other half or soulmate. This idea has mentally been placed into the human mind through cinematic films and through romantic novels. However, the idea of longing for your other half in actuality derives from philosopher Aristophanes. The philosopher used this theory to explain why humans looked for one another to complete them and the reasons why we feel incomplete without another. Aristophanes challenges Hesiod’s theory about love being only physical – that you can love someone as long as their exterior is beautiful.…

    • 1039 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Socrates used to assume that love was a good and a beautiful thing. However, Diotima held a different opinion. After the discussion, she makes Socrates confused and doubtful of his thoughts about love as he has a new opinion about love. He thinks that it is ugly and bad, something that Diotima refuses. They, therefore, agree that love is neither ugly nor beautiful but it is something between beautiful, ugly,…

    • 1090 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Thesis statement Through the speeches by men, love is examined by men attending a symposium or a drinking party. The symposium has its main concerns with the beginning, the purpose and nature of affection and care. Therefore, love is the central theme in Plato’s dialogues in Symposium. Introduction The Symposium is a philosophical text written by Plato in approximately 386-370BC.…

    • 1440 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    The texts Plato Symposium and Sappho, Selected Poems discuss the topic of love as experienced by a select few of society- and thus reject the notion that love is a universal human experience. Through this essay, love will be examined as it pertains to each text and then these ideas will be observed to understand how they reject the notion that love is a universal human experience. Set in ancient Greece, Plato’s work titled Symposium presents his view that love can only be experienced by men and boys -through various speeches given by characters who are giving eulogies on love. Although many different ideas are presented through the speeches, one common theme holds true throughout all seven speeches: not once is the notion of real and virtuous…

    • 1841 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays