Susan Stryker's Critique Of Gender Identity

Better Essays
Susan Stryker’s issues with this theory of performativity are that she believes that by Butler arguing against gender as a fixed quality of our being, she is treating gender as if it were some totally flexible choice of a cherry-picking subject. Stryker mentions in (De)subjugated Knowledges, multiple criticisms of Butler’s work. Critiquing Butler on the basis of “the self-understanding of many transgender people, who consider their sense of gendered self not to be subject to their instrumental will, not divestible, not a form of play” (10). Stryker’s critiques of gender are more nuanced because she views transgender identities as a means of challenging the fact that no one can accurately make an ontological claim about their gender identity. …show more content…
It is the issue of whether or not this performance makes gender “real” that the two of them disagree on. As I mentioned earlier, to Butler, performative means that an action exists by the very fact of its occurrence. Butler seems to ignore that because it has been reiterated and believed that gender exists inherently within one’s self, gender does then exist inherently within one’s self. For it is up to the subjective individual to determine whether or not their gender exists within themselves. This is because, as Stryker would argue, gender is unavoidably subjective. “It’s a girl!” determining the existence of this child as a girl, and in parallel structure, “gender exists intrinsically within our identity” and so it does. Stryker writes, “to say that gender is a performative act is to say that it does not need a material referent to be meaningful, is directed at others in an attempt to communicate, is not subject to falsification or verification, and is accomplished by "doing" something rather than "being" something” (10). The criterion for being a woman does not include any stereotypical femme attributes, it is merely someone who says she is a woman. Butler might argue that to be a woman one would have to fall under societies idea of what it means to be a woman. The physical form determines absolutely nothing about gender identity, it merely provides a corporeal platform in which one can display their performative gender. Butler, surely, understands the importance of gender identity and the reality of gender within society. Stryker’s issue with Butler, however, is that her language is not beneficial for trans identities who seek to highlight the significance of the authenticity of their experience as one gender. It also fails to legitimize transgender people who are “non-passing” and therefore do not abide by the rules assigned to either gender in the binary. Butler does seem keen to the idea of

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Nobody should become the epitome of masculinity or femininity because, as Devor stated, psychological androgyny fixes any gender role issues and seems to be the most peer pressure way to live. There is comfort in the idea that gender roles are not complete nor uniform and that they are the result of an imbalance from society’s expectations. The only way to break the stereotype of gender roles is to step outside of them and explore what qualities of masculinity and femininity are most…

    • 1047 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The performance is not an insight as to who a person truly is, but what a person does at a specific time. Her idea that identity is a free-floating form and not a description of some core essence is a key part of queer theory. With this and her thoughts of how sex, male and female, are not connected to gender, masculine and feminine, and desire, to the other gender, leads her to have a very open view of sexuality in itself. Judith Butler, along with her wants to end the binary construct that we know as gender today for a more expressive system, is an acceptance as well as an advocate for equal treatment for people of all…

    • 1278 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Hare And Maxion Analysis

    • 1921 Words
    • 8 Pages

    M could not do this thing in conversation with another person.” Murdoch means M’s morality of self-introspection is the activity that comes from her own personality and experience rather than any universalized reason. In fact, not everyone thinks it is necessary to do self-introspection like M. Even if everyone believes it is necessary to do the self-introspection, everyone does the self-introspection in different ways and not everyone would do the self-introspection like M. Therefore, M 's valuation is not the universalizability. Hare believes the valuations with no general reason is not understandable because they are nonsense but M 's self-introspection is the moral valuation comes from the individual personality, which exists and stands in the real world. Therefore, except U-type moral valuation, the moral valuation that comes from the personal reason is existing. Hare uses the example of K and E to claim that the valuation with non-general reason is…

    • 1921 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    They believe that such confusion should be banished, and people that are confused about their gender identity should forget about their inner sense and become something that fits the society boundaries. First, being a transgender people is not a choice, they did not choose to be different. Second, Transgender people are trying to match how they feel inside with what they see in the mirror. Third, they are not trying to change any society value. To concluded, what opponents need to understand is that transgender people should not be judged by their gender preferences, but instead by their character like everyone…

    • 800 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    One internally struggles with the notion of gender, as it holds society down to a standard of categories called male and female. Also, there is no in-between when it comes to gender, it is a binary as stated by Butler, making it impossible to a full person, able to experience all degrees of emotion or activity because there is such a mental segregation. One will lie about their beliefs so that they can conform. They also struggle externally, striving to seek recognition from others in their conforming…

    • 1856 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    That is, is a masculine female or a feminine male wrong? This question is mostly based on opinions because there are no rule books on how to have personalities. The question on gender is answered. Stating that not the biology- meaning the way you were born- but with destiny- meaning the way you live- may turn out to generate the idea of gender (Gender Trouble 7…

    • 1374 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Wife preaches feminist ideals and encourages sovereignty over a woman’s self as does Jane, desiring the independence of equal treatment of women yet neither characters fully adhere from societal norms. Nevertheless, their actions and behaviour in attempt to portray a “feminist” persona fails as rather than revolutionize women and work to change the way society sees women, they feed into the stereotypes of their respective eras and cannot, in modern terms, be considered a…

    • 1538 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Egner And Maloney Analysis

    • 1539 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Westbrook and Schilt establish an argument that explains that doing gender can determine gender in everyday interactions but it isn’t enough in political spaces, in political spaces there is a supposed need for explicit criteria to determine what a person is. With this argument, Westbrook and Schilt agree that doing gender is a valuable concept but it cannot be used in politics and policy making because society as a whole does not accept that just the performance of a gender is enough to confirm that an individual is in fact that gender. This reflects society’s engrained belief in a male and female gender system; it is either this or that. The subjects of Egner and Maloney’s research realize that society has this mentality and they seek to use West and Zimmerman’s theory to dismantle these beliefs. The drag performers’ use doing gender in an unusual way, they portray one gender while being another gender.…

    • 1539 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Her strength and anger could not be shown fully due to the gender stereotypes holding her back. I believe that no one should have boundaries because of their gender. I believe equality is the key to peace, and equality can not be achieved without ridding society of…

    • 607 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    If Hermione is to truly be a feminist figure then she needs to be able to access all of her emotions equally. There is a high degree of doubt that any feminist critic would expect a male character to never show his emotions as that is unhealthy behavior, so there is no need to apply that standard to Hermione. Because Hermione can be recognized as a third wave feminist, it is even more important to recognize that Hermione showing her emotions in a variety of scenarios is not necessarily feminine behaviour, but that the inverse, not showing emotions, is regarded as masculine. When Hermione opens herself in terms…

    • 1624 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays