Robert Yates Letter Analysis

Amazing Essays
Robert Yates wrote a letter to the federal congress concerning the freedom of people’s rights being stifled by the relatively small amount of representatives that are elected. He believed this form of organization would eventually lead to a tyrannical or monarchal government. Robert Yates was born January 17,1738 in Schenectady, New York and became a figure who was known for his views on the rights of the people. He studied law in New York with William Livingston and became admitted to the New York Bar in 1760. In the pre-revolution years Yates was apart of the Radical Whigs, who were against corruption. They became strong advocates for protecting the liberties of the colonies. During the revolution, he served four years on the Albany Committee …show more content…
In such a vast majority and rising population, he sees a concern between the relationship of the representatives and the people. How can the people have a strong support system in their representatives when most will never actually get the chance to meet them or know them personally. The eventual catalyst is that this problem will bring uneasiness and distrust between the majority and their country stating throughout his letter, “…it is impossible the people of the United States should have sufficient knowledge of their representatives…a great part of them will, probably, not know the characters of their own members”. How can a country be unified if we are all strangers to each other. Yates sees this as being a big problem in the long run of the country. The representatives will begin to be seen as “… a body distinct from them, and having separate interests to pursue…” he gives the example that if a man is employed by a stranger, he is less likely to be trusting of him because he does not know his character or ambitions and will “trust him with caution, and be suspicious of all his conduct.” Hypothesizing of all the uneasiness and distrust in the government, the conclusion shows it will become extremely lethal, mainly because if the United States needed to ban together the notion of so many diverse and …show more content…
Organizing smaller groups in view for a large majority causes mistrust and uneasiness to develop from not knowing the representatives. Eventual decline will effect the voting of the majority and those political issues. In some way he is exactly right. A multitude of American Citizens do not trust their representatives for the reason that they do not know who they are. The people separated from the government slowly by infiltration occurring from the seclusiveness that the political issues appear to hold. America is not as strong in mutual unification of freedom but rather more, every man for himself, which is a predecessor of what Yates predicted. In a way his want of more representatives, is excellently disprove by Madison and Hamilton showing that you need less representatives because with more there is udder chaos, and no real solution can be achieved with so many people and opinions. Altogether, Yates’s letter proved very eye opening and insightful for eventually problems needing better solutions and conclusions in order to protect the rights of the

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    After the Revolutionary War the colonies needed some help with the low imports from Britain since they were cut off from the war and the debt was increasing. As the Federalists and Anti-federalists argued on whether the Constitution should be formed, a conclusion was generated in 1788. Patrick Henry was born in 1736. His…

    • 813 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Both major political parties in the United States are refusing to work together to solve problems. This causes many individuals to rethink about how their system of government works. These individuals tend to complain more about how their government doesn’t represent their political party or their political ideas, rather than how their government does not represent enough of individuals of different…

    • 1459 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    There is strong belief to avoid the middle ground and compromise due to the increasing incivility in political discourse. Competing interests, egos, and ideologies all make for a contentious environment in democratic societies and lead to a level of incivility (Foxman #). However, the biggest problem that seems to arise from uncivil discourse is the way it completely changes elections and the effectiveness of governance (Massaro #). As politicians have been using uncivil discourse as a tactic to gain votes and raise money no common ground can be reached (Massaro #). The problem of uncivil discourse has been ignored within politics because the only common ground that can be reached is the idea that uncivil discourse is a tactic.…

    • 1203 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Right now a small group of individuals have so much power, and if someone’s ideas don’t match with that small group of people then they just have to forget their thoughts, since they are not nearly as important. Americans are too scared to do anything about the government because they think it is too powerful, but they should have no fear because the governments power builds off fear. Wilson believed, “You only need about 24 men to bring down the government” (103). Wilson felt like the government was made up of imposters trying to run the…

    • 1770 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In one wanted to cause a heated debate, all they must do is mention Congress and its inefficiency. Many venture to take a guess as to why it is so inefficient, citing the individual members or the design itself. However, an overwhelming amount of American citizens are unaware of the fact that the inefficiency they complain about is actually how the government is supposed to function. One of the major criticisms of government inefficiency is of the members themselves, regular people are tired of the inaction and ceremonial legislation, and the solution is to replace every incumbent. On the other hand, criticism of the system’s structure has been cited as the reason for inefficiency, and that if all members of Congress are replaced, given time, the system will revert back to its inefficiency.…

    • 1644 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This theory is related to with this article because many people were starting to go out on the street saying that they are disagree on the results of election because they are afraid of how Trump will take actions about the many undocumented immigrants and other people will remove from the United States and they are thinking that they are doing a right action for the United States. However, the frustration leads to the distrust from person to person because they might have different perspectives on the politics. According from LA times, Nathanel Persily Stanford law professor emphasized that “Even when the news is good people do not trust about it” which means that some people are feeling betrayed from the other states and people from the America that they will be ruined in four years. Also, some people were getting beaten up from others because they voted for Trump and posted in the Social media. Also, some people were discussing about how they could do anything on the women after the effects on the Trump becomes presidency during our discussion after the election.…

    • 1566 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Official Language

    • 1003 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The non-English and English speakers agree that in some way they are threatened by the opposing culture. They feel as if the other will be overrun by the more powering group. Although Americans fear that these non-speakers are trying to take their jobs, land, and mainly their money. Non-English speakers feel as if they are not allowed to show pride in their heritage if they are not allowed to express themselves in…

    • 1003 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Some examples of false statements in this passage is the cause to riots and gathering of people. This is false because nothing will stop arguments that arise in society and as American citizens always have to be “right.” Another false statement would be the simple operation of the government with the rights of man. This is not true at all because men and women are not equal in means of jobs, rape, and many other things. Thomas Paine had extremely high hopes for America, but he was wrong. Some of which most people probably think or should be true for the government to run in a higher quality and also for the American citizens to be equal and work together in an exponential…

    • 838 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    By having uninformed voters, it could create a unsafe environment for minority groups that are outnumbered as seen in this recent election in the United States. With an large uneducated public, there comes dangerous territory of it possibly undermining modern democracy due to these individuals not knowing their rights, duties and responsibilities as citizens (Crick 113). In order to strengthen democratic attitudes, there has to be a consensus of voters that understand the system, are able to scrutinize their officials, and intellectually critic their government on policy…

    • 1580 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The divide comes from the reasoning that even not making a deal and walking out of a negotiation can help further public support. Another reason for the divide is the mentality of “just because they support it I cannot.” In this day and age, the support of a party from citizens can come from hatred for another party. The reason that public support is essential to the parties and individuals is because people are elected and need to stay in favor with their supporters. This does, however, infuriate many people of the opposing party because the inability to agree means that nothing can be accomplished. This is the fight between "policy and politics" (Binder & Lee, 2013, p. 4).…

    • 2408 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Decent Essays