Summary Of Francis's Misinterpretation

Improved Essays
The order that Francis founded started with a simple idea of living a very poor life, preaching the teaching of Jesus and submission to the church or assistance to anyone in need. A main part of Francis’s vision involved helping those in need without receiving anything in return. But in spite of the success of the order he started, Francis decided to resign his position as the head of the order. His resignation emerges from his understanding that his movement has changed too much. Lepers play a significant role in Francis’s life since it helps explain Francis vision, the misinterpretation by his followers and the need to go toward an organized order caused by the Papacy.
The first sign of Francis’s resignation from his movement in 1220 can be shown from his vision, which is expressed in his experience with the lepers in Assisi. As a youth, Francis viewed the lepers as opposite of his idea of beauty, yet once he rejected his past life, however, he discovered a new truth about them. In Thompson, Francis describes his transformation, as “When I was in my sins, just to see lepers was very bitter for me. And the Lord himself took me among them, and I showed mercy to them. And on leaving them, what seemed bitter to me had turned for me into sweetness of body and soul” (Thompson 16). By helping lepers, Francis realized that what is more important in life was not the way he had been living. It is not by mere coincidence that Francis would be compared to Jesus since he emulated Jesus from the scriptures who regularly would care for the lepers. In helping a marginalized people, Francis exemplifies the idea that would become the foundation of his order, which is being a “lesser brother”. Rather than trying to follow or lead others for personal gain, the way to find spiritual peace is in helping and placing others above one’s own interest. The problem with putting others’ interests over one’s own is that it does not help in being a leader. He may place certain acts as examples of his way of life, but he cannot impose his idea on anyone since the very idea of submitting to someone should be voluntary. This idea of being a lesser brother would be confused by his followers, especially with the troublemaker John of Capella. A major issue that would cause Francis to believe he was not a proper leader and resigns was the issue with Brother John of Cappella. Helping the lepers would be one of Francis’s first tasks of leaving the world and gaining God’s mercy, yet he would be outraged by the actions of John of Capella and his community helping the lepers. His reaction to this would be to appeal to the Pope for assistance to abolish this movement yet a
…show more content…
In his working papers, which would be his early rule, he outlines the basic idea of his way of life. A part of his rule that tries to restrict the dealing with money is changed as Thompson describes,” Francis immediately modifies this hard rule and allows the collection of alms for lepers when there is dire necessity. “But let them beware of money,” he cautions” (Thompson 98) Francis would be a mix of a realist and an idealist, since he would want his order to maintain its poverty status yet he makes an exception for the most marginalized group, the lepers. Francis would assert the idea of poverty and the rejection of the material world, even more in his official rule. As Thompson writes,” In chapter 4, that on money, Francis closed the loopholes we noted in the Earlier Rule that allowed the brothers to accept cash alms for aid of lepers and the sick. Now they are not doing so directly or through intermediaries. Rather, the ministers are to rely on “spiritual friends” when they need to care for the sick.” (Thompson 106) The way of life that Francis created after rejecting his family and helping the lepers is shown in this passage. As a mendicant order, being poor and helping others is all his movement is about. This rule may be reinterpreted later on to allow the Franciscans to gain a lot of land, but Francis’s intention were for his rule to represent his vision and finally being able to leave the mantel of being a

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    According to Francis, the key reason behind the issue…

    • 556 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In a wonderful way, in an instant, he turned completely to the work of God” (Thomas of Celano 29). He had just gathered up many, if not all, of his valuables and decided to go into town to sell them because he no longer had a need or want for material possessions. He then took all of the money that he gathered and gave it to the first needy person he saw, who happened to be a poor priest in a dilapidated church on the verge of collapse. He took the money that his past self would have gladly spent on extravagant clothing or some other unnecessarily pricey items and donated it all to the priest for the rebuilding of the church. He went against the immoral rule in his society of treating the poor like…

    • 1294 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Unsurprisingly this way of life brought followers, who asked to be called Friars Minor, or “Little Brothers” (pg. 102). Francis and his way of life was approved by Pope Innocent III and there were three orders that served towards forwarding the cause. The first order were the men or “Little Brothers” the second were the women, who though they requested to own nothing and to be homeless, because of the gender roles of the time were required to live their chaste lives in supervised walls. The third order were the…

    • 601 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Francis continued to grow spiritually and felt a calling of going out and spreading the word of the Lord to continue his habits of following the lord. If it weren't for Francis’s ability to stand to his virtues, he would not have made such an impact on the world like he has. Now he had a lot of virtues and I can’t even think of a vice that he had in his later days. Some of the good habits that allowed for him to do such good was following one of God’s most important laws; Loving everyone. Francis treated each person and all of creation as if they were all gifts from God above.…

    • 1733 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The attitudes towards “the poor” between 1450 and 1700 in Europe differed greatly depending on the speaker’s perspective. In general, those with greater power or a higher social ranking had a dismal opinion of the poor, and those who were more ordinary, didn’t necessarily look down on the poor so much as they pitied them. Another factor that changed views on the poor was the date. In the 15th century people had more understanding and empathy, but that drastically changed as the 16th century came around and people were skeptical and doubtful of the poor. Finally in the 17th century the views of the poor were once again regarded as with kindness and understanding.…

    • 706 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Pope indulgences should not be preached a lot. The people of the church should be taught that money and greediness should not tie in with God. They should also be taught that they should not make money their god. He thinks that the true meaning of church is the holy gospel and the holy ghost. He believes that if the pope preaches against the truth he should go to hell unless he gets right with god.…

    • 500 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The fundamental objective affiliated with Isabelle Huellant-Donant’s article “Martyrdom and Identity in the Franciscan Order (Thirteenth and Fourteenth Centuries)” is an attempt to analyze, utilizing documentation pertaining to the Franciscan Order and Papal legislation, the mendicant order’s perception of martyrdom, specifically in regards to the application of martyrdom directed towards the constituents of the Franciscan Order . The article also assesses the correlated development of institutionalized regulations imposed upon proselytizers associated with the Order of Friars Minor as a ramification of martyrdom’s contemporary perception and the intrinsic structure of the Order of Friars Minor. Reiterated frequently throughout the document…

    • 531 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Martin Luther was an influential scholar in the 16th century who changed the face of the Catholic church by sparking the beginning of the Protestant Reformation. To the Christian Nobility of the German Nation is one of the first works written by Luther in 1520. The text gives the reader an insight into the life of Luther, while he exhorts and rebukes the authority and ideals of the Roman Catholic Church. Within the text, Luther challenges the three main ideals of the Church and insinuates an ecclesiastical movement. Furthermore, I agree with Luther’s approach to completely disband all the metaphorical walls that the Romanists have developed in the attempt to revolutionize Church and State.…

    • 1120 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Francis doesn’t feel any shame towards his family but rather he says, “I don’t mind. I want to get a job.” (289). Due to the shame he felt towards his poverty and mother at a young age, Francis grows up valuing money over education. It is also this shame that drives him to be even more motivated to move to America where he spent the majority of his later years.…

    • 1116 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Martin Luther’s “95 Theses” seemed to affect not only the members of Wittenberg, Germany, but also the entirety of the Holy Roman Empire. This document, which led to Pope Leo X’s “Exsurge Domine,” caused quite an uproar in the Catholic church. One reason Luther’s theses evoked a concerned reaction from church officials was made clear in Luther’s eighty-sixth point specifically.…

    • 221 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Moliere 's Tartuffe, and Voltaire 's Candide are each praiseworthy abstract works of the eighteenth century in their own particular rights. Fraud is a sarcastic drama, and Candide a provocative travelog. While each sticks somberly to its type, different similitudes and also differentiating contrasts can be followed among the previously mentioned works. Composed amid the Age of Enlightenment, each of these works mirrors the belief system of the period and subsequently, has different likenesses. Firstly, each of these works commends reason over religion and the hypothesis that man is in charge of his own behavior.…

    • 1406 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Martin Luther’s weren’t the only reforms that swept Europe in the early 1500s. He had come to his conclusions a tortured soul, desperately searching for a way to be redeemed in the eyes of God. But those same conclusions were reached by another, and not from the perspective of a tortured soul, but from the scholarly pursuit of truth. The teachings of Ulrich Zwingli affected Switzerland much the same as Luther’s affected Germany, but not even these great reformers were prepared for the Anabaptist movement. In this paper I will summarize chapters 5-6 in Justo Gonzalez’s The Story of Christianity.…

    • 801 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Evolving Tolerance In recent years, the word tolerance has become a topic of serious deliberation. As a social and political buzzword, tolerance sparks many debates about religion, lifestyle, morality, and politics. Historically speaking, the definition of tolerance has evolved throughout the years and has come to mean something very different from its original meaning. The word is also used in situations or settings that often diverge from the strict dictionary definition.…

    • 730 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Pope Gregory VII Often considered one of the most influential and controversial popes of the Middle Ages, Gregory VII became pope after a long career in the papal court. Historians have claimed that the papacy of Gregory VII is so important and must be emphasized, they have coined the term “Gregorian Reform”. Gregory VII played an important role in Europe during his time, and was a major contributor both before and after his election to the reform. When discussing the biography of Pope Gregory VII, there are many key topics one must address.…

    • 1613 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Proverbs 28:6 entreats with these words, “Better is a poor man who walks in his integrity than a rich man who is crooked in his ways (ESV).” A Song to Lady Poverty is an ode that speaks to the virtues of those who have chosen to live a life devoid of “worldly” pleasures as written by St. Francis of Assisi. I will talk briefly in this paper about it. As I consider today’s church (non-Catholic)…

    • 254 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays