Summary Of Bob Herbert's Article 'Blue Collar Brilliance'

Improved Essays
How to Define Intelligence
Recently in my college composition class I read 2 articles that left me wondering “How do we learn?” On one hand I had “College the Easy Way” by Bob Herbert, saying how through advancement of skills such as critical thinking, complex reasoning and writing we increase our intelligence. Meanwhile, in the second article “Blue-collar Brilliance” by Mike Rose who says that our culture today separates the body from the mind and reinforces this idea by defining intelligence solely on grades and IQ tests. He also goes onto stating how intelligence can be earned in different ways through his own personal experiences. Being a child who both has a father who went to college and a mother who did not, I feel that I can understand
…show more content…
I will need both a higher education and experience to pursue my future. But, in Bob Herbert’s piece he goes in depth about how today’s college students are not advancing in the skills he finds advance intelligence. For example, Herbert contributes, “The development of such skills is generally thought to be the core function of a college education... Many of these young men and women are unable to communicate effectively, solve simple intellectual tasks (such as distinguishing fact from opinion), or engage in effective problem-solving.” This shows a very serious problem in Herbert’s piece, as he finds that college students aren’t contributing to the work force without these skills. Herbert also include a statistic from highered.ssrc.org stating in students’ first two years of college 45% of them don’t improve their skills and that by the end of their four years still 36% don’t improve. He adds these to prove his point that there is a lack of intelligence being gained while in college. And with the amount of money college students have to pay it would only make sense for them to be developing these skills and gaining …show more content…
I’ve since studied the working habits of blue-collar workers and have come to understand how much my mother’s kind of work demands of both body and brain. A waitress acquires knowledge and intuition about the ways and the rhythms of the restaurant business...Rosie devised memory strategies so that she could remember who ordered what. And because she knew the average time it took to prepare different dishes, she could monitor an order that was taking too long at the service station.”
Rose’s mother knew her trade well and had communication skills not only when it came to the customers but with her co-workers and boss as well, showing that she had the “Lingo” that showed her authority and know-how. He also touches on how his mother knew how to “work smart” by using the critical thinking skills to complete all her tasks in the most effective way while accounting for new problems that may come

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Myriad Benefits of College In this century an education is indispensable and mandatory to be successful. According to a recent survey in Feldman’s book, P.O.W.E.R , college students said they wanted “ to learn more things that interest me.” Moreover, forty percent wanted to be more cultured. But sixty- eight percent reported they hoped college would provide a path to a more lucrative career.…

    • 381 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Essay Assignment 1: Summary In his essay, “Blue-Collar Brilliance,” Mike Rose shows us that even though there are jobs that do not require lots of studies, that does not mean that people who perform in those fields are not as intelligent as those called “white-collar” in other-word, well-educated people. He states what his mother and uncle does as examples to describe the value of a blue-collar worker performing what they know in their jobs. His mother, Rose Meraglio Rose (Rosie) worked as a waitress in a Coffee Shop in Los Angeles.…

    • 306 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Being a waitress, as Rose describes, requires a special "work smart,"(Rose) as his mother learned. His mother had to sequence and group tasks as well as evaluate customer emotions in order to be successful in the restaurant environment. Rose's mother described her daily routine as, "there isn’t a day that goes by in the restaurant that you don’t learn something."(Rose) Rose created an antithesis to Ehrenreich's claim of a restaurant job being strenuous, stress-inducing, and meaningless for its minimum wage, where as a restaurant job could be considered meaningful and enjoyable to a specific person. The work also required a unique set genuine skills that were evolved from the job which could not be taught without first hand experience.…

    • 1298 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Charles Murray’s What’s Wrong with Vocational School he claims that only a certain percentage of high school graduates are going to college and will pass. Murray is trying to appeal to the students with high IQ’s and tell them that going to vocational school might be more educational and the students will learn more while getting jobs that pay more sometimes six figures. Murray also argues that sometimes going into the work force after high school is better than going to college because a certification can always be overlooked on certain jobs rather than experience is looked at on every job interview. Murray uses ethos, logos and pathos along with several other rhetorical devices to explain why college is not always the best choice.…

    • 1183 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Whether at a job, at home, or in between, any experience can be just as educational as a class at a university. In “Blue Collar Brilliance”, the author, Mike Rose, uses anecdotes from his family’s experiences to prove how although his family members might not have had much formal education, they all were “intelligent” due to the lessons they learned at work. Given my family’s own experience, I can attest to that. Throughout all of the generations of my family, half have attended a traditional university, while the others went to work or had a different experience, some even had both.…

    • 1024 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this essay, “College Prepares People for Life,” by Freeman Hrabowski portrays the notion that college is an absolute requirement to prepare students for “THE REAL WORLD”. Hrabowski embellishes the fact that without college, students are not going to be ready for the competitive job market and won’t be able to reach a high level of success if they don’t have the college experience. Yes Hrabowski point of view is completely understandable because in today’s society college has become such a norm and a place if you don’t go you will ostracized for, that students have no choice then to mindless focus on something that they are not passionate about. As a joiner in high school I can vouch first-hand the peer pressure from school, friends, teachers,…

    • 1107 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Zac Warble ENG W131 Sec 4:30pm Rhetorical Analysis II Post high school education in america has dwindled in the last 3 years do to a 30 percent increase in drop out rate and a 10 percent decrease in graduating students per year. Also for the students that do graduation there has been a decrease in employers wanting people straight out of college, wanting experience over knowledge. So this has raised the one question.…

    • 1582 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Price Of Admission

    • 902 Words
    • 4 Pages

    If the college experience is improved, then, it will gain value at an even faster pace than it is losing it, due to increases in tuition rates and the like. To that end, the article puts forth some interesting ways to more effectively engage students. One of the most interesting of these ways is to simply increase cognition of students at college, forcing them to use their minds more in the process. For instance, the article states that "some 64 percent of undergraduate students are enrolled in vocational majors, instead of choosing fields like philosophy, literature, or the physical sciences" (Hacker and Dreifus 180). This means that these students should be persuaded that their "impractical" studies are actually a practical and logical use of college, encouraging others to take that route if possible as well.…

    • 902 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Drop-outs Vs. Degrees In the article “Blue-Collar Brilliance”, Mike Rose argues against the need for a formal education by giving examples of his own family, mainly his mother and uncle, Rose states that many often closely associate intelligence with traditional schooling even though there are many examples of people that drop out of school and still live ‘successful’ lives. While some of Rose’s points are well supported and agreeable his overall argument for the dismissal of general education is, in my view, incorrect and should not be applied in the education system.…

    • 703 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The value of a college degree is a dispute that is commonly contemplated, yet rarely answered. I will attempt to express my attitude towards college education, personally defined as an Associate’s Degree for returning adult students. In an effort to explain the greater benefits of a college degree despite the common rhetoric that it is not financially worthwhile, I have considered the positive and negative effects of doing so. I have examined the following articles, “Learning by Degrees and Live Chat With the Author,” “The Major and the Job Market, the dream and the reality,” and “In the Basement of the Ivory Tower,” to support my stance. When one maintains a desire to progress academically and an open-mindedness to educational demands in the…

    • 842 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He reasons that if said student is high in the standings in terms of their academic ability, they should be obtaining a college education (238). He believes that the odds that this student will “enjoy” what is being taught is greater because this student is able to handle the materials (239). He argues that a student who does not enjoy “the hardest aspects of college” is more likely to be interested in going to a vocational school where what they teach “pertains to” the student’s “career interests” (240). Going to college is, according to Murray, a waste of time for many, as most occupations do not require such amounts of knowledge…

    • 770 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Do you think college is important to go to? Do you want to go to college? College is a good education to take. It`s a good idea because you can earn more and get a job at first place. College can inspire you or lead you to a new world that you have never seen.…

    • 462 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the article, “College is a waste of time” by Dale Stephens, Dale gives his persuasive opinions on why college is a waste of time by giving out evidences of how college isn’t fully beneficial and describing people who are successful today without a college degree. Dale describes college as “rewarding conformity, regurgitation, and theory”, instead of, “rewarding independence, learning, and application”. Providing that college is also hungry for people’s wallet, The College Board Policy Center showed that tuitions have increased 3.6 times since 30 years ago. Not everyone needs college to be successful such as Mark Zukerberg who made it big without a diploma. Summing up the article, Dale states that in the end it’s people’s choice to look for…

    • 1046 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Limited Learning On College Campus Analysis

    • 1143 Words
    • 5 Pages
    • 3 Works Cited

    Even worst the author argues that one out of three senior graduates had no improvements whatsoever in their writing and critical thinking skills than when they first arrived to college. [4] With these staggering statistics many people are beginning to wonder if higher education has been placed in the midst of a higher education…

    • 1143 Words
    • 5 Pages
    • 3 Works Cited
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    As a society, when we define things such as intelligence in a cookie-cutter fashion, we are only hurting ourselves. When our school does this, we are only hurting our students into becoming one-size fit all members of society. As a culture, we should move away from these ideas into a more fluid education where we can teach students on an individual level rather than telling them to do things that might not be fit to their set of skills. In order for a more intellectually diverse society, our education system and the idea of intelligence needs to…

    • 1491 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays