Summary: An Analysis Of Thomas Jefferson's Dilemmas

Great Essays
Jefferson’s Dilemma The United States history thus so far, is full of many bargains but one of the most controversial and beneficial bargains is the Louisiana Purchase. This bargain occurred back in the 1800s of which the President Thomas Jefferson was able to undertake the deal of the century. This bargain initiated when Jefferson wanted to purchase New Orleans because France was enforcing stricter regulations therefore, making it difficult for American settlers to trade in that particular location. Then Talleyrand proposed “what will you give for the whole Louisiana,” a counter offer that the nearly deaf American Robert Livingston, was in no position to undertake. This offer then brought about a series of the most radical things that President …show more content…
He was a “strict constructionist meaning that he believed the government could only do things specifically named in the constitution.” Next, the Government was also unsure on how to govern the newly acquired land. The politicians also discussed about what they would do with the French settlers already living there whether to kick them out or to give them different treatment since they were French. It was also said that the “acquisition of Louisiana would only benefit the western states and give power to the southern states.” Thomas Jefferson, being the strict constructionist, tended to abide the constitution no matter what the circumstances. He even went on to challenge Alexander Hamilton’s national bank idea since the constitution it did not explicitly say anything about building a bank. However, the Louisiana Purchase was a whole different story; it was a deal that even the Jefferson could not decline. He would be a fool if he declined the offer …show more content…
Among these obstacles was the lack of governmental organization which further fueled the issues. A few suggestions were implied of which one resolution was that it could be turned into a colonial possession or made into one big state as it was already or divide it into multiple states. Since Jefferson, himself, was not expecting to govern more than just New Orleans; he had gotten more than he had originally bargained for. Given the new circumstances Jefferson now had more land to govern and more people to oversee. Not only was he watching over his own people, he had to watch over their own enemies the French and the Indians. This alone was a difficult task, since the nation was not sure what to do with the French, they could kick them out, turn them into slaves, or imprison them. As for the Indians, it was just as bad, since they were getting kicked off their own homeland and being forced into other communities. These possible solutions would only spark more fighting and violence towards the English farmers or settlers moving

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Not to mention, he also retired most of the Navy’s warships, leaving us a weak army. Once Jefferson becomes president congressmen alerts Jefferson to prepare for a war against France. In addition, “Spanish officials who still governed New Orleans announced the closing of that port to American commerce (October 1802).” (PG. 184) Leaving Jefferson in a tough position he preferred to negotiate rather than going to war. This negotiation resulted in the Louisiana Purchase.…

    • 829 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The United States expanded across North America to the west at a rapid rate most notably in the 1840’s through the 1850s. Many social, econonomic, and political factors lead to the nations growth and acquisition of land. Social interests included families’ desire to seek more land out west along with economic opportunities for interstate commerce and political agendas concerning territorial expansion. The Louisiana Purchase of 1803 from the French government, by President Thomas Jefferson, cost $15 million, and included territory from Canada to New Orleans, and the Mississippi to the Rocky Mountains (Westward Expansion, 2009). The purchase of these territories doubled United States’ size and according to Jefferson it was crucial to the nation’s…

    • 740 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    After fighting against France’s navy less than a decade prior with the Quasi War, the US was not intent on fighting France again so quickly. It is careful thinking such as this that made Madison so brilliant. The acquisition of Louisiana not only resulted in Manifest Destiny, - the belief that it was God’s intent for the United States to expand all the way to the west coast - but it also resulted in new lands still owned by the US to this day. Major historical events such as the Kansas-Nebraska Act that defined where our country stands today would not have happened had the United States not purchased Louisiana. Madison’s strategic and wise thinking prevented another war with France and the potential loss of New Orleans, a major port…

    • 1126 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Revolution of 1803 In the Revolution of 1803 by Peter S. Onuf the thesis was the events related to the Louisiana Purchase, The territories before the Louisiana Purchase, Jefferson’s Inaugurals speech, and the views of Jefferson on the revolution. The Louisiana Purchase was the purchasing of land from the French. This expanded the United States west ward. “United States acquired 82800 square miles for 15 million dollars,” (91).…

    • 325 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    First he had to deal with France and the Louisiana Purchase. After the Haitian Revolution and the loss of its sugar colonies, France led by Napoleon Bonaparte decided that it no longer wanted a North American empire. This led to the Louisiana Purchase where the United States bought the Louisiana territory. Jefferson created this deal, but there was no explicit power in the constitution for the president to purchase foreign lands. Document C details a letter from Jefferson to John Breckinridge where he admits to reaching beyond the constitution in order to make the deal happen.…

    • 884 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For most Americans, the Louisiana Purchase is regarded as one of the most influential treaties of our nation in expanding its borders and securing its status as a world powerhouse in political dominance. However, a significant yet otherwise subdued dilemma the Louisiana Purchase treaty caused was an unconstitutional expansion of federal powers, specifically with regards to the president. Robert Knowles argues that the assumed expansion of federal powers to include additions of states and integration into the union significantly hindered the balance between federal powers and state powers, granting the former much more importance in the “empire of liberty” model.…

    • 1066 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Louisiana Purchase was a land deal in 1803 made between France and the United States that resulted in America expanding further into the New World and doubling their land size. This real estate deal resulted in the mass acquisition of land made under Jefferson’s presidency and later fueled Polk into wanting to expand further through the mid-19th-century idea of Manifest Destiny. This idea, made by John L. O 'Sullivan, was that it is America’s god-given right to expand from the Pacific to the Atlantic Ocean. The synthesis of the Louisiana Purchase and the later idea of Manifest Destiny helped spur many debates over newly gained territories through territorial expansion. These debates arose from issues on whether or not land from the Louisiana…

    • 1755 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Louisiana Purchase Thomas Jefferson was an active hero, a spokesman for democracy, and the third president of these United States of America. As president, he was always faced with diversity; whether it was dealing with the Barbary pirates in the middle east, belligerent British trade policies, and even the greatest acquirement of all time: the Louisiana Purchase. The Louisiana purchase was one of the best procurements that could have happened to this great nation. That is why The purchase of Louisiana held no significant moral dilemmas for President Thomas Jefferson, because it benefited the nation by growing more than double the size of the United states, gave the country complete control of the port of New Orleans, and provided territory…

    • 747 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Section I, 1. Why was Napoleon willing to sell the Louisiana Territory to the United States? How did Jefferson’s Louisiana Purchase transform America’s understanding of itself and its future? Was it inevitable that the West would become part of a much greater United States? Napoleon Bonaparte, before he decided to sell Louisiana was already facing many problems.…

    • 1666 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Louisiana Purchase Dbq

    • 1052 Words
    • 5 Pages

    After the successful succession of the original Thirteen Colonies from Great Britain the idea of Manifest Destiny became prevalent in America. Manifest Destiny is the American belief that they have the divine right to expand and push westward. Due to this belief, after the 19th century Americans would have acquired a vast majority of the land in the continent. However, before this could occur there would be negotiations, war, and dispute that took place throughout the 1800s-1850s. This period involved disputes including the Louisiana Purchase of 1803, conflict with other countries, The Annexation of Texas, and the settlement in Oregon.…

    • 1052 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Louisiana Purchase

    • 1008 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The Louisiana Purchase is an event that caused a great deal of controversy during the early 1800s. This vast tract of land was purchased by Mr. Thomas Jefferson before the government had a chance to approve it. Congress did indeed approve this purchase, but it was only after they decided not to analyze the constitution too in-depth. This is the very reason that so many Americans were split on this issue. Despite the controversy, one thing is certain, the Louisiana Purchase has opened our eyes and helped us gain a better knowledge on how our constitution works.…

    • 1008 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However signing and negotiating foreign treaties were allowed. Jefferson had to act fast, he signed the treaty and purchased the territory. He believed in an agrarian society, so he also promised to provoke agriculture and handmaid commerce, but on December 22, 1807 the Embargo Act was passed. The Embargo Act closed all of the United States imports with the intent to pressure Europe. Britain was seizing American ships so Jefferson felt that the best way to prevent this from happening was to cut off all foreign trade.…

    • 865 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Thomas Jefferson was a strict constructionist which means that every word in the constitution is to be taken at face value and nothing is to be assumed, or more simply put, if it is not in the constitution than the government cannot do it. He attests this in a letter he sent to a senator in 1820 on the matter of the Missouri compromise. His answer to the question can be summarized by the last sentence of the second paragraph of this letter, "This certainly is the exclusive right of every state, which nothing in the Constitution has taken from them and given to the general government." Although seventeen years prior in the midst of his first term as president of the United States he made the biggest purchase of land in American history the Louisiana purchase. When he knew well that there was nothing in the constitution that gave him the right to buy new territory, explore it, and even go beyond the borders of the land.…

    • 1033 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He was an anti-federalist and in order to reduce the influence of the central government, Jefferson decreased the amount of government employees, lowered Army enlistments, and cut the national debt. During his presidency, Jefferson was faced with foreign affairs every day. It often pushed him towards Federalists policies that negates his personal political philosophy. Jefferson’s is very well spoken and that is one of the reasons he was able to purchase the Louisiana Purchase for $15 million. Jefferson’s ideal agrarian democracy ignores the fact that slaves are the ones to work on the richest farmlands in the Unites States.…

    • 2099 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Jefferson’s Great Gamble: The Remarkable Story of Jefferson, Napoleon, and the Men Behind the Louisiana Purchase, Charles A. Cerami’s recounted the one of the most overlooked events in American history. Thomas Jefferson and Napoleon Bonaparte, two of history's greatest leaders, stood face to face for the western lands of America. It was indeed grueling mission for Jefferson: outmaneuvering the great Napoleon Bonaparte, determining the morality of westward expansion, and most importantly keeping America intact and out of war. Cerami, an economist and historian, featured the drama, cajolery, fear, and betrayal America confronted before leading itself to massive real-estate deal known as Louisiana Purchase. Cerami informed the readers about the significant people and crucial events that eventually led to the Louisiana Purchase.…

    • 1237 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays