Stuart Greene Argument As Conversation Rhetorical Analysis

Good Essays
In “Argument as Conversation,” Stuart Greene attempts to convince readers that an argument is a conversation. When most people think of arguments, they tend to think of them as being a negative thing. Stuart Greene is trying to have people realise that arguing is used in conversations to move it along, keep it interesting and to also inform people. He tries to focus on how an argument is not to a way to dispute someone, but rather an ongoing conversation with that person.

He uses a Kenneth Burke quote, explaining research to be like a conversation that has been going on long before you entered and will continue long after you leave, to show that both conversations and writing have gotten our civilisations to where they are by spreading ideas.
As this quote is said it gives me the impression that there will always be more to learn through the conversations that are spoken between people and the writings that we share with people everyday. It also shows me that knowing about the past will
…show more content…
He believes that if you are able to identify the issue and the situation in the conversation then you are able to frame good questions and thoughts. Having the questions in mind, allow the continuation of learning among all people whether based on that topic or not. I do have to agree with him on this, because with out good questions the conversation would just “die” and people would go on their ways with out learning anything.
Greene also brings up framing in detail. He uses the metaphor of taking a picture and blurring out the unimportant details, which emphasises the memory, he wants to capture. He talks about how is sets the stage for writing and developing ideas but still having detail. Framing is a technique that I think we all use but are not aware of. We all have the ability to remember something in detail, but it is the details that we remember by how we frame the

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Much like ontological leadership, progressive pragmatism works through previous mistakes and problems, but in perhaps a more critical and hostile way. This occurs to allow everyone to express their feelings and really get everything off their chest for the means of improvement. By using both definitions, the authors are using ethos to get the purpose across. Ethos is an appeal that makes the audience or viewer believe the writer is a credible and trustworthy source. Examples are seen through the definitions of ontological leadership and progressive pragmatism as seen…

    • 967 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In this quote, Munnecke is showing the reader how they can get closer to stepping out of their linguistic shell. He uses many personal and relatable examples toward the ending of his article when describing the flow. The flow is a difficult concept to understand, and I think that is why Munnecke dedicates a large chunk of his article trying to explain it. Munnecke does a great job at repeating the “definition” of the flow to really get the readers to understand what the flow really is. Repetition…

    • 1211 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Minimal encourage helps you draw out the client’s story. Minimal encourage can include silence, verbal, and nonverbal. Examples of some of these would be a nod, words like “wow” and “ohh” repeating keys words that they used in their story can also help get more information for example “ Furious?” “Your fault?” When you paraphrase you are showing your client that you were listening to their story and the issues. When you paraphrase you do not repeat what you client has told you word for word, instead you repeat a shortened version of what they have shared with you that has important key words that they have used, while using the person’s name or “you”. Some of the things that paraphrasing accomplishes is a check for the speaker and listener, builds rapport, keeps the client focused, and keeps the patient talking or to move on.…

    • 1492 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Thought is an idea or proposition conducted by thinking or occurring quickly in the mind. Macdonald reminds the reader that one 's thoughts aren 't gained by a simple skim of a text you have scavenge your way through the text to find the main ideas and detail so you could get the right ideas. Then you can write down all your thought that way you avoid confusion and have an organized essay. The way Elbow uses thought is by explaining it as a process of gathering information you don 't need structure all you need is the ideas of what you want to write about. Thought is the important thing or else you wouldn 't get ideas running in your…

    • 1283 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Stuart Greene’s article Argument as Conversation was an insight on how arguments go hand in hand with most conversations whether to inform or to prove a point. He starts by inferring that arguments don’t have a time line but are continuous. We use past, present, and future information to reinforce our side of the argument. Greene quotes Kenneth Burke’s example of an argument which states, if you walked up to people arguing, the topic of that conversation has been going on long before you got there and will continue even after you leave. Greene also explains if you want to jump into that argument you should identify the situation and not just be able to frame your points of your argument, but have good counter questions which makes your argument…

    • 194 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In his article “Argument as Conversation”, Stuart Greene attempts to purpose the proper way to make arguments into intellectual conversation. Whether you are in class, or spending some time with family, arguments usually happen and are a unique part of everyday life. As Greene states in the article, “Argument is very much part of what we do every day; We confront a public issue, something that is open to dispute, and we take a stand and support what we think and feel with what we believe are good reasons” (Greene 28). With that being said, Greene believes that arguments are already very much like a conversation. However, there are multiple things one must understand before joining such conversations.…

    • 514 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Because Johnson comes right out to state his argument, he is able to lead his readers into a situation where they have to stay to see just how Johnson can argue these points. With the arguments clear in their minds, Johnson can use his explanation skills through the rest of the book to show his readers just how important popular culture is today compared to books. The clear statement of two arguments also makes the reader more curious about Johnson’s book because from the title of his book, Everything Bad Is Good For You, the reader really only knew of there being one argument. But since Johnson came out to state a second argument, it may just allure his readers further into his book as they become more curiously attracted to the interesting addition Johnson has made part way into his book. And with this persuasive addition, Johnson can be self-assured that he has gained interest from his readers, making for a fascinating…

    • 1065 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    I would repeat the directions and break down the task into small steps so that he or she can be able to process it in his or her mind. It is important that I give the client positive reinforcement. Furthermore, I believe that behaviorist theory would be effective to my teaching because I can encourage the students to do at their own best. It is also the way to improve their performance and behavior. I will try to avoid punishment as much as possible, unless it is necessary.…

    • 975 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    It made me think that I was doing everything wrong and I would have to start from square one all over again. It was one thing to come up with evidence to back up my argument and another thing to show how it backs it up entirely. I went to conference with Professor Kinney-Lang to discuss this feedback to see where how I can move forward with what I had. He reassured me that my work would not be put to waste. I just had to push my ideas further.…

    • 1036 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Throughout the paper, Edmundson also ask questions to the readers, then answer them. I think that this is a great way to make the readers understand more of what he is trying to say. He also add “My overall point is this:” towards the end of the paragraphs, this makes the whole points to be clearly understood in one sentence. Edmundson also uses ethos, pathos, fallacies, and logos throughout the paper. He uses pathos to convince the readers of his arguments.…

    • 1282 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays