Stoker Argumentative Fallacies?

Improved Essays
Argumentative fallacy 's can be seen in everyday life from talking with one 's mom to speaking with their boss, the trouble is identifying these fallacy 's and being aware that they do exist and can affect oneself and the person they are speaking to. Being able to know the difference between an ad hominem and straw man could be the difference between winning one 's argument. To begin with, two quite opposite articles have been provided that contain a central claim about the Iraq war. One of these articles is written by Anna Quindlen, 'We 've been here before ', while the other one is by Donald Stoker, 'Insurgencies rarely win '. Quindlen 's article contains much argumentative fallacy’s that can be found throughout her writing, limiting the …show more content…
In Quindlen 's article, one of the prominent argumentative fallacies made is in the last paragraph, as she states, “Someone with a trumpet should play taps outside the White House for the edification of a president who has not attended a single funeral for the Iraqi war dead” ( Quindlen). The fallacy made here is an ad hominem because although Bush is guilty of not appearing at any funeral for the Iraq war, the personal attack is irrelevant to the topic at hand and all it does is show how much Quindlen hated Bush. The fact that Bush had not attended any funeral can be supported by an interview Bush agreed to do from a reporter from the Defense Departments Stars & Stripes newspaper. In this interview, one of the questions prompted was, “why, to date, he has not …show more content…
What was the cause, the point, the strategy? And suddenly many Americans started to realize that there was no good answer” (Quindlen). By giving her audience the background knowledge that she was a mother who had a son dead, she provokes emotion into the audience that makes them feel sorry for Sheehan and helps them jump onto Quindlen 's bandwagon that Bush is a horrible person since he refused to speak with her. Quindlen was correct in saying that Sheehan had showed up at Bush 's ranch, wanting answers about her son’s death from the Iraq war. This can be proven as there is a news report on Sheehan saying, “Sheehan, who co-founded the anti-war group Gold Star Families for Peace led about 50 demonstrators near the Bush ranch Saturday.” (Quijano) asking “ 'why did he kill my son? '” and “ 'ask him [the president] what that noble cause was '”( Quijano). These direct statements for the source herself, Cindy Sheehan, prove that Quindlen did not make a fallacy with her information, just with her choice of words/placement. Compared to Stokers article, Quindlen 's article appears full of emotional appeal to get her audience to join her in her 'Bush hating club '. This sharp contrast in Stoker 's article can be seen as he states, “When the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    A question that comes to mind is that, why is Hillary Clinton Crooked? Why does President Trump feel the need to go on Twitter to basically bully other politicians? Yes, she may have hidden some emails from the government in the past but that doesn’t mean she is a dishonest human being. Another post Donald Trump put out there was that “Two dozen NFL players continue to kneel during the National Anthem, showing total disrespect to our Flag & Country. No leadership in NFL” (Twitter, 23 Oct. 2017)!…

    • 797 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He felt like he was abandoned by his mother. Moreover, in his eyes, his mother just lets him starve making him feel unloved and unwanted even though she was there with him all throughout. As the confrontation continues, Ronnie angrily asked his mother what she could have done for him. In response the mother admitted that “your father ruint me-and you's the result” and disgustedly said that “just when you get big enough to work and do me some good, you have to go and die.” This expresses that she wasn’t fond of having him in the first place because he is just a result of an unexpected pregnancy. Consequently, for her it is just a mistake that ruins her life, but she still decided to keep him, hoping in the future to have a better life.…

    • 817 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Syrian Democracy

    • 1396 Words
    • 6 Pages

    One of the mothers whose husband was killed by a sniper said, “We 're just living on the edge of life. We 're always nervous, we 're always afraid”. (the story of the conflict) USA have so…

    • 1396 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    People were disgusted, because they felt for these people so strongly. The state chose to stop burying citizens of other states. This relates to the example of Antigone’s persistence in the burying of her brother, Polynices, in Sophocles’ Antigone. Polynices was branded as a traitor and had lost his citizenship to Thebes; King Creon refused to bury him, letting his body rot. Antigone could be compared to the volunteers who buried the refugees because they knew it was right—she wanted to give her brother at least a simple burial.…

    • 1680 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Racism has always been a problem in the nation but it is only recently coming out of the clear once again. It seems like we are reliving the time where Jim Crow laws were causing riots between races. Eddie Glaude said that before the march, Washington D.C seemed like an empty and abandoned city. “Liquor stores shuttered their doors. Washington Hospital canceled non-emergency surgeries.” (“James Baldwin and the Ugly Moral Problem in America’s Heart”, 2017) But the government knew that it will be a race riot rather than a protest and came prepared.…

    • 1368 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Many Trump supporters would argue that political cartoons such as Bryan’s should be considered slander because they can have a damaging effect to the president’s reputation. However, Trump’s tweets from his personal Twitter damage his reputation just more than a political cartoon ever could. In one incident on February 22, 2018, Trump discusses what certain news stations have been reporting by saying, “I never said “give teachers guns” like was stated on Fake News @CNN & @NBC. What I said was to look at the possibility of giving ‘concealed guns to gun adept teachers with military or special training experience - only the best. 20% of teachers, a lot, would now be able to,” (Trump).…

    • 1338 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    He was also majorly exposed when it came to his presidential election, while Nixon was old, nasty, and went through the accusations and name calling due to the Watergate scandal. Nixon’s and his reelection comity team failed to retrieve the wire taps, caught, persecuted, and traced back to Nixon. No lie or action is good if you need to hide it by sending a cover up burglars and the people that you are hiding it from is the American public. Nixon was considered a great president to the American people. He ended American involvement in the war in Vietnam, brought American POWs back home, and shut off the military draft that had the American public frighten due to the fear of going to war.…

    • 1346 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Rwanda Genocide Essay

    • 1902 Words
    • 8 Pages

    They shunned the word so that the government was not legally obliged to act under terms of the 1948 Genocide Convention (Power, 2001). Several leaders, including United States President Bill Clinton, insisted that they was unaware of what was happening in Rwanda. Despite this, the genocide was clearly visible. The attacks on the Tutsis were shown on the media starting on April 8th. The Washington Post ran a front page article on April 24th on how the rising number of victims in Rwanda was a reminder of the Holocaust (Power, 2001).…

    • 1902 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The parents of the shooters were portrayed through the media as bad parents. In time of grief, the surviving victims are trying to find who to blame for the mishap. The blame in this case was set upon the parents of the shooters, “ we think of them a a Dr. Frankenstein who created a monster. We blame them and we hound them” (Schwartz 294). We give them no sympathy, because people don 't think about how they lost a loved one too.…

    • 1097 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    My mother gave me unconditional support. However, when I talked to my father, he was extremely angry and dismissive. My father said to me “You are destined to be a failure”. And he also believes that it was kind of wastes spend much money on girl’s education. After deeply hurting me, he decided to divorce with my mom.…

    • 996 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays